Board 8 > Rating Every Fire Emblem Character Day 15 - these characters that exist

(+) Yeah! (+)

Stuff:
- Ratings 1-10, no decimals. If you include a decimal, I will round down.
- We will do two ratings for each character character (CH) & unit (UN). They will be separate lists and you do not have to rate for both lists. Character rating is for design, personality, aesthetics, story, etc. and unit rating for everything gameplay related. If you only submit one rating and dont specify which, it will default to the character rating.
- You are free to rate any characters from past days or change your rating.
- Nominations for future characters are accepted. This does not guarantee your noms will be up for rating the next day but they will be moved up the queue for sooner rather than later.

Spreadsheet:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lne8OQTQ7CwA5UXfzbD-Gsl34JuhamCU9oUgW85JC9w

Past Days:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xdaRcNoKXPEjPNuA8-lRIZtVEQXI-qOJyqO3HZgdC6A

CH (67):
1. Reyson 9.250
2. Ike 8.800
3. Eldigan 8.667
4. Soren 8.583
5. Shamir 8.500
6. Hector 8.333
7. Joshua 8.308
8. Lucius 8.000
9. Nephenee 7.800
10. Nino 7.727
11. Sigurd 7.700
12. Tanith 7.500
13. Marth 7.444
14. Innes 7.222
15. Ayra 7.200
16. Lyn 7.125
17. Ares 7.000
18. Takumi 7.000
19. Leon 7.000
20. Lethe 7.000
21. Gerik 7.000

41. Linde 6.333
58. Ogma 5.333

72. Xander 4.000
73. Tharja 3.000
74. Peri 3.000
75. Camilla 2.500
76. Corrin (M/F) 1.250

UN (87):
1. Sigurd 10.000
2. Reyson (9/10) 10.000
3. Robin 9.889
4. Corrin 9.667
5. Camilla 9.500
6. Lena 9.429
7. Ryoma 9.429
8. Ike (10) 9.250
9. Caeda 9.222
10. Marcus 9.000
11. Olivia 9.000
12. Xander 8.857
13. Lance 8.714
14. Finn (4) 8.667
15. Sain 8.571
16. Florina 8.500
17. Tanith (9) 8.500
18. Lex 8.500
19. Kent 8.286
20. Hector 8.235
21. Ares 8.200
22. Abel 8.200
23. Allen 8.143
24. Ferdinand 8.000

70. Ogma (11) 5.250
74. Linde (11) 4.750
75. Clair 4.667

83. Nino 3.455
84. Rebecca 2.143
85. Abel (12) 2.000
86. Astrid (10) 2.000
87. Lena (12) 1.750

Day 15: these characters that exist

This is a filler topic. Next one will be up relatively soon. Sorry if you care about any of these characters.

If you care enough to rate any of these:

Athena CH
Boah CH
Bord CH
Caesar CH
Castor CH
Cord CH
Darros CH
Dolph CH
Frey CH
Macellan CH
Matthis CH
Midia CH
Norne CH
Radd CH
Rickard CH
Roger CH
Roshea CH
Tomas CH
Vyland CH

Athena UN (11)
Athena UN (12)
Boah UN (11)
Bord UN (12)
Bord UN (11)
Caesar UN (11)
Caesar UN (12)
Castor UN (11)
Castor UN (12)
Cord UN (11)
Cord UN (12)
Darros UN (11)
Darros UN (12)
Dolph UN (11)
Dolph UN (12)
Frey UN (11)
Frey UN (12)
Macellan UN (11)
Macellan UN (12)
Matthis UN (11)
Matthis UN (12)
Midia UN (11)
Midia UN (12)
Norne UN (11)
Norne UN (12)
Radd UN (11)
Radd UN (12)
Rickard UN (11)
Rickard UN (12)
Roger UN (11)
Roger UN (12)
Roshea UN (11)
Roshea UN (12)
Tomas UN (11)
Tomas UN (12)
Vyland UN (11)
Vyland UN (12)

Athena CH 5

she got the last hit on the final boss in my playthrough

everyone else gets 3 i think...

Frey UN (11) 8

The only person I can even say anything interesting about here is Vyland, and even then it's better sitting on until Wolf/Sedgar come around because they're the better ones.

Unit wise almost everyone here is just the bad version of someone else, with the others being just bad on their own. The only guy that would be relevant is SD Frey, but he's only playable on Normal so he kind of inherently can't be very good because he can't actually help you at all on the difficulties where it would matter.

---

I absolutely can't be fucked to say anything about these losers as units, but I'll talk briefly about them as characters!

Athena CH 7
Boah CH 1
Bord CH 3
Caesar CH 4
Castor CH 1
Cord CH 3
Darros CH 5
Dolph CH 4
Frey CH 3
Macellan CH 4
Matthis CH 1
Midia CH 6
Norne CH 6
Radd CH 4
Rickard CH 6
Roger CH 6
Roshea CH 7
Tomas CH 1
Vyland CH 3

Athena doesn't deserve to be on this list, she's a cool sword lady and has a great line where she's like "We will help you" and Marth says "Great, gather your men and let's go" and she's like "Men? We are a woman. One woman!" Athena kind of rocks.

Boah is basically the whole reason things go to shit with Hardin and Nyna, and he has no redeeming factors.

Bord and Cord certainly exist.

Caesar and Radd are maybe the only examples of real mercenaries FE has. Marth tries to friendship recruit them in FE12 and they're like, "no, pay us." That's all I've got on Caesar and Radd!

Castor is one of Caeda's dopey recruits. He's a scam artist and it's slightly funny but not really.

Darros is a pirate. His personality? Also pirate. And yet, could be more pirate. 5 pirates out of 10

Frey exists to die ten minutes into FE11 and he can't even do that right

Dolph and Macellan are legitimately hilarious in terms of character design but they have zero character.

Matthis is the fucking worst.

Poor Midia, she doesn't deserve to be on this list. She almost has real character traits! She rolls up to help you, bringing with her Boah, Tomas, Dolph, and Macellan, so like, no help there. But I guess the thought is appreciated.

Norne is cute. Use her instead of Gordin, she needs a friend!

Rickard doesn't deserve to be on this list. He has some good interactions with Julian at least.

Roger is the funniest FE recruit, Caeda pseudo-flirts with him for all of 10 seconds and he's like "fuck yeah i'll betray my country!"

Roshea doesn't deserve to be on this list. He's the only Wolfguard member with A) common sense and B) actual character, so bonus points for him there.

Tomas might be the most worthless FE character of all time. I'm not sure he has a single line of dialogue? And he's an infantry archer on top of it all.

Vyland sucks, he's so bland he might as well be part of the Sable Knights (eagerly awaiting them for a future filler topic!!!). The most memorable thing about Vyland is his dumb name.

---

Kenri posted...

Darros is a pirate. His personality? Also pirate. And yet, could be more pirate. 5 pirates out of 10

But he wants to give up being a pirate!

---