Board 8 > Rating Every Fire Emblem Character Day 14 Ft. Ogma, Linde, Clair, Finn, Corrin

Topic List
Page List: 1
kateee
07/25/20 1:40:06 PM
#1:


bowwowowowow


Stuff:
- Ratings 1-10, no decimals. If you include a decimal, I will round down.
- We will do two ratings for each character character (CH) & unit (UN). They will be separate lists and you do not have to rate for both lists. Character rating is for design, personality, aesthetics, story, etc. and unit rating for everything gameplay related. If you only submit one rating and dont specify which, it will default to the character rating.
- You are free to rate any characters from past days or change your rating.
- Nominations for future characters are accepted. This does not guarantee your noms will be up for rating the next day but they will be moved up the queue for sooner rather than later.

Spreadsheet:
https://docs.google.com/spreadsheets/d/1lne8OQTQ7CwA5UXfzbD-Gsl34JuhamCU9oUgW85JC9w

Past Days:
https://docs.google.com/document/d/1xdaRcNoKXPEjPNuA8-lRIZtVEQXI-qOJyqO3HZgdC6A

CH (67):
1. Reyson 9.250
2. Ike 8.800
3. Soren 8.583
4. Shamir 8.500
5. Hector 8.333
6. Joshua 8.308
7. Lucius 8.000
8. Nephenee 7.800
9. Nino 7.727
10. Sigurd 7.700
11. Tanith 7.500
12. Marth 7.444
13. Innes 7.222
14. Ayra 7.200
15. Lyn 7.125
16. Ares 7.000
17. Takumi 7.000
18. Leon 7.000
19. Lethe 7.000
20. Gerik 7.000

21. Libra 7.000

55. Lance/Allen 4.400
55. Ricken 4.400
57. Xander 4.000
58. Tharja 3.000
59. Peri 3.000
60. Camilla 2.500

UN (78):
1. Sigurd 10.000
2. Reyson (9/10) 10.000
3. Robin 9.889
4. Camilla 9.500
5. Lena 9.429
6. Ryoma 9.429
7. Ike (10) 9.250
8. Caeda 9.222
9. Marcus 9.000
10. Olivia 9.000
11. Xander 8.857
12. Lance 8.714
13. Sain 8.571
14. Florina 8.500
15. Tanith (9) 8.500
16. Lex 8.500
17. Kent 8.286
18. Hector 8.235
19. Ares 8.200
20. Abel 8.200
21. Allen 8.143
22. Ferdinand 8.000

35. Shamir 7.250
43. Lucius 6.750
49. Libra 6.250
63. Tanith (10) 5.250

74. Nino 3.455
75. Rebecca 2.143
76. Abel (12) 2.000
77. Astrid (10) 2.000
78. Lena (12) 1.750

Day 14: Ogma, Linde, Clair, Finn, Ronan, Corinn, Eldigan

Ogma (11/12)

Mercenary -> Hero, etc.
Stats / Growths (11):
Lv: 4
HP: 22 | 90
STR/MAG: 6/0 | 40/0
SKL: 11 / 40
SPD: 12 / 30
LCK: 3 / 40
DEF: 6 / 20
RES: 0 / 0
MOV: 7

Stats / Growths (12):
Lv: 7
HP: 27 / 100
STR/MAG: 8/0 | 60
SKL: 14 / 55
SPD: 13 / 50
LCK: 5 / 60
DEF: 8 / 25
RES: 0 / 5
MOV: 7

Linde (11/12)

Mage -> Sage
Stats / Growths (11):
Lv: 1
HP: 18 / 40
STR/MAG: 0/2 | 0/50
SKL: 4 / 40
SPD: 7 / 35
LCK: 7 / 60
DEF: 3 / 0
RES: 4 / 15
MOV: 6

Clair (15)

Peg Knight -> Falcon Knight
Stats / Growths (15):
Lv: 1
HP: 20 / 35
ATK: 8 / 40
SKL: 4 / 55
SPD: 7 / 70
LCK: 11 / 50
DEF: 4 / 30
RES: 8 / 2
TOL: 0.45
MOV: 7

Finn (4/5)

Lance Knight -> Duke Knight
Stats / Growths (5):
Lv: 7
HP: 28 / 60
STR/MAG: 8/1 | 35/5
SKL: 8 / 30
SPD: 11 / 35
LCK: 5 / 45
DEF: 7 / 30
CON: 9 / 10
MOV: 8 / 1

Ronan (5)

Bow Fighter -> Sniper
Stats / Growths:
Lv: 1
HP: 20 / 40
STR/MAG: 4/0 / 15/55
SKL: 3 / 45
SPD: 7 / 55
LCK: 3 / 25
DEF: 2 / 5
CON: 7 / 2
MOV: 7 / 3

... Copied to Clipboard!
kateee
07/25/20 1:40:25 PM
#2:


Corrin (Fates)
/
Prince(ess) -> Noble
Stats / Growths:
Lv: 1
HP: 19 / 60
STR/MAG: 7/4 | 60/40
SKL: 7 / 50
SPD: 6 / 50
LCK: 5 / 55
DEF: 6 / 45
RES: 2 / 30
MOV: 5

Eldigan (4)


Stats/Growths:
N
P
C

Form:
Ogma CH
Linde CH
Clair CH
Finn CH
Ronan CH
Corrin (M) CH
Corrin (F) CH
Eldigan CH

Ogma UN (11)
Ogma UN (12)
Linde UN (11)
Linde UN (12)
Clair UN
Finn UN (4)
Finn UN (5)
Ronan UN
Corrin UN

in other news i find out i've been spelling corrin wrong this entire time
... Copied to Clipboard!
Panthera
07/25/20 2:38:27 PM
#3:


Corrin (M) CH 1
Corrin (F) CH 1

Conquest Corrin is maybe the worst protagonist ever. Still bad enough on the other routes to get the worst possible rating.

Ogma UN (11) 5
Ogma UN (12) 6
Linde UN (11) 3
Linde UN (12) 7
Clair UN 3
Finn UN (4) 9
Finn UN (5) 8
Ronan UN 2
Corrin UN 10

SD Ogma is pretty good for a few chapters, but even there he's not amazing. Falls off fairly quickly because swordlock sucks in SD and he doesn't have cavalier to reclass to, meaning he quickly turns into an Armorslayer bot that otherwise has no offense or durability worth mentioning. Least he has those few good chapters! In NM he's a fair bit better due to having more functional bases, being useful in the prologue briefly and access to class set A and the Paladin/Swordmaster options it brings (plus swords are better), but still nothing special. SD Linde has beefy chip damage with Aura and little else, in NM she's fairly good due to being around so early with Aura's huge might and she can do some fun stuff with Nosferatu once in a while, plus later on she can rock the Levin Sword Swordmaster set up quite well.

Clair manages to be a rare not so good pegasus knight, mainly due to having pretty crappy bases (even her speed is unremarkable!). Falcoknight, while toned down from the original, is still a powerhouse class but it's a long ways off and Alm doesn't have as many monsters to fight anyway. FE4 Finn is a weird dude to talk about due to his availability being the way it is. He's one of your better units in the first gen when he's there, especially in chapters 2 and 3, then he's important for chapter 7 and decent filler until the final chapter eventually gets to be too much for him. Pretty important guy overall!

FE5 Finn is a strong dude with a leadership star and a dumb good personal weapon, lot less impressive indoors and fades from relevance when the almighty Warp staff kicks in though. Ronan is bad. Like, really bad. His extra move relative to other unpromoted foot units can help with chapter 3 but that's about the extent of his talents. Corrin is obviously super strong, probably the best unit in Fates overall.

---
Meow!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Kenri
07/25/20 3:15:53 PM
#4:


Ogma CH 6
Linde CH 7
Clair CH 8
Finn CH 8
Corrin (M) CH 2
Corrin (F) CH 2
Eldigan CH 10

Ogma UN (11) 5
Ogma UN (12) 5
Linde UN (11) 5
Linde UN (12) 7
Clair UN 5
Finn UN (4) 8
Corrin UN 9

Ogma is one of the less interesting of the Ogmas, he's a cool guy with some background with Caeda but overall just kinda generic. I like Linde and wish she had more screentime. Clair I quite like as a character, she's probably one of my favorites from Echoes -- she's haughty but really makes an effort to be better. Finn is a great supporting character for all of Jugdral. Corrin sux. Eldigan is my favorite NPC! He's my favorite implementation of the Camus style characters because he has better reasons for fighting you than most and still ends up conflicted, and is the only(?) Camus to actually go and confront the lord he's not willing to disobey.

As units IDK the first 3 are all okay I guess. Finn is a brave lance machine which you can't complain too much about. Corrin is obv OP.

who the fuck is ronan

---
Congrats to BKSheikah, who knows more about years than anyone else.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Mewtwo59
07/25/20 5:41:30 PM
#5:


Ogma CH 6
Linde CH 6
Clair CH 7
Finn CH 9
Ronan CH 5
Corrin (M) CH 1
Corrin (F) CH 1
Eldigan CH 9

Ogma UN (11) 5
Linde UN (11) 5
Clair UN 6
Finn UN (4) 9
Finn UN (5) 8
Ronan UN 1
Corrin UN 10

Ogma is ok for a bit, but he does tend to fall off.

Linde is Aura spam and that's about it.

Clair is a fairly mediocre flier in a route where fliers aren't all that useful. The effective damage against monsters is good, and she has a good enough speed growth where she doesn't really care about losing speed from weapons. But her bases are fairly low and she only has one promotion to help them, so I can't rate her too high.

Finn is one of the better units in Gen 1, but unfortunately he leaves after chapter 3. He's great at the start of Gen 2, where he's basically another Oifey if you trained him in Gen 1. Unfortunately, he's one of two non-replacement Gen 2 units with no possibility of having holy blood, so his stats are going to fall off and he's not going to be able to hang with the enemies in the endgame. But his contributions before that still make him a great unit.

Finn in FE5 is one of the better units in outdoor maps, with his personal Brave Lance letting him kill most enemies and make him one of your better capturers. Unfortunately, he's fairly weak in indoor maps, where he's stuck with a weapon type that he's not proficient in. It's not the worst thing since it gives you a chance to rest him so you don't need to use an s-drink on him, but it dings him enough to knock him down to an 8.

Ronan is one of those units that you wonder what they were thinking when they came up with them. An archer with 15% strength growth and 55% magic growth in a game where there aren't any bows that use magic? It gives him high res due to how magic works in FE5, but with that strength he's not even going to ORKO mages. He has high move for a foot unit, but does that really matter when he can't really do anything with it?

Corrin is another OP avatar. Not so much as Robin, but they'll be one of your best units throughout all 3 routes.

---
""Love" is making a shot to the knees of a target 120 kilometers away using an Aratech sniper rifle with a tri-light scope." HK-47
... Copied to Clipboard!
kateee
07/25/20 11:48:44 PM
#6:


Damn corrin sucks

... Copied to Clipboard!
kateee
07/26/20 2:44:16 PM
#7:


Corrin (M) CH 1
Corrin (F) CH 1
Eldigan CH 7

Ogma UN (11) 6
Linde UN (11) 6
... Copied to Clipboard!
Mewtwo59
07/26/20 3:03:58 PM
#8:


Who sucks more? Corrin as a character or Ronan as a unit?
---
""Love" is making a shot to the knees of a target 120 kilometers away using an Aratech sniper rifle with a tri-light scope." HK-47
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1