Current Events > Red Dead Redemption 2 [women]

Topic List	Page List: 1, 2
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/09/19 5:53:05 AM #1:	Best Character - Results (2 votes) Abigail Roberts 0% (0 votes) 0 Karen Jones 0% (0 votes) 0 Mary-Beth Gaskill 0% (0 votes) 0 Molly O'Shea 50% (1 vote) 1 Sadie Adler 50% (1 vote) 1 Susan Grimshaw 0% (0 votes) 0 Tilly Jackson 0% (0 votes) 0 <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927183843] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote> Best Character - Results (2 votes) Abigail Roberts 0% (0 votes) 0 Karen Jones 0% (0 votes) 0 Mary-Beth Gaskill 0% (0 votes) 0 Molly O'Shea 50% (1 vote) 1 Sadie Adler 50% (1 vote) 1 Susan Grimshaw 0% (0 votes) 0 Tilly Jackson 0% (0 votes) 0 </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
pres_madagascar 09/09/19 5:57:42 AM #2:	Sadie is Bae. --- https://imgur.com/23CCcZB https://imgur.com/32mwCo1 https://imgur.com/oqklqKC <cite>pres_madagascar posted [p:927183896] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie is Bae. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
slmcknett 09/09/19 6:04:50 AM #3:	Clearly Sadie. --- https://imgur.com/1LrhmQE Kari Wahlgren: "Guys, I just can't wrap my mouth around it." <cite>slmcknett posted [p:927183990] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Clearly Sadie.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/09/19 4:29:43 PM #4:	Abigail looks badass in that pic <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927204567] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Abigail looks badass in that pic </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
au_gold 09/09/19 4:31:43 PM #5:	Sadie. --- Let me talk to your mother. Get your mother please. <cite>au_gold posted [p:927204662] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
eston 09/09/19 4:32:36 PM #6:	Sadie is far and away the best female character and probably has one of the best arcs in the entire game. I loved how they factored her into the epilogue. Next up would probably be Ms. Grimshaw. She was so uptight and reserved for most of the game, but underneath it all she was a stone cold badass. Plus I really enjoy losing poker to her --- http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i215/estonc/grizzly_bear_chairs_2.jpg https://imgur.com/8kjZU <cite>eston posted [p:927204703] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie is far and away the best female character and probably has one of the best arcs in the entire game. I loved how they factored her into the epilogue. Next up would probably be Ms. Grimshaw. She was so uptight and reserved for most of the game, but underneath it all she was a stone cold badass. Plus I really enjoy losing poker to her </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Lost_All_Senses 09/09/19 4:32:51 PM #7:	Sadie is the best character in general --- Name checks out https://i.imgtc.ws/vBF8odT.png <cite>Lost_All_Senses posted [p:927204713] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie is the best character in general</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
EverDownward 09/09/19 4:34:52 PM #8:	Sadie's too manufactured, which is why so many consider her the best girl - because Rockstar put the most effort in her. Abigail will always be my girl, though. Loved her in the first Redemption, and thought she was even better in the second game. --- "Tried to point my finger, but the wind was blowing me around in circles, circles." <cite>EverDownward posted [p:927204808] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie's too manufactured, which is why so many consider her the best girl - because Rockstar put the most effort in her. Abigail will always be my girl, though. Loved her in the first Redemption, and thought she was even better in the second game.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
boxington 09/09/19 4:50:22 PM #9:	went with Tilly, especially after I saw her actress in something, but I can't remember where. --- b-bb-box <cite>boxington posted [p:927205563] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>went with Tilly, especially after I saw her actress in something, but I can't remember where.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
eston 09/09/19 5:47:43 PM #10:	EverDownward posted... Abigail will always be my girl, though. Loved her in the first Redemption, and thought she was even better in the second game. I honestly found her pretty obnoxious in the first game, but I liked her in the second. She just didn't do a lot to stand out. I will say though, I wasnt crazy about Sadie's voice actress --- http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i215/estonc/grizzly_bear_chairs_2.jpg https://imgur.com/8kjZU <cite>eston posted [p:927208116] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>EverDownward posted...</cite> <quote>Abigail will always be my girl, though. Loved her in the first Redemption, and thought she was even better in the second game.</quote> I honestly found her pretty obnoxious in the first game, but I liked her in the second. She just didn't do a lot to stand out. I will say though, I wasnt crazy about Sadie's voice actress</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AlecSkorpio 09/09/19 5:49:23 PM #11:	I'd bang the shit outta Molly, Dutch was trippin --- Christian Bale profited off the Iraq War <cite>AlecSkorpio posted [p:927208208] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>I'd bang the shit outta Molly, Dutch was trippin</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
eston 09/09/19 5:50:05 PM #12:	Man, fuck Molly lol --- http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i215/estonc/grizzly_bear_chairs_2.jpg https://imgur.com/8kjZU <cite>eston posted [p:927208230] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Man, fuck Molly lol</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ROBANN_88 09/09/19 5:50:28 PM #13:	is that farm lady from the beginning of 1 somewhere in 2? i liked her --- https://imgur.com/cUNC8DI <cite>ROBANN_88 posted [p:927208258] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>is that farm lady from the beginning of 1 somewhere in 2? i liked her</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Vita_Aeterna 09/09/19 5:51:39 PM #14:	Sadie Adler for sure. Mary-Beth is a sweetheart though. --- "Death is so terribly final, while life is full of possibilities." <cite>Vita_Aeterna posted [p:927208314] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie Adler for sure. Mary-Beth is a sweetheart though.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
eston 09/09/19 5:54:18 PM #15:	I kinda felt like there was supposed to be more going on with Mary Beth and Arthur. There's several times throughout the game where she sits Arthur down so he can talk about his problems (all optional convos, but marked on the map), but it was weird because they don't have all that much interaction in the story parts. --- http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i215/estonc/grizzly_bear_chairs_2.jpg https://imgur.com/8kjZU <cite>eston posted [p:927208422] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>I kinda felt like there was supposed to be more going on with Mary Beth and Arthur. There's several times throughout the game where she sits Arthur down so he can talk about his problems (all optional convos, but marked on the map), but it was weird because they don't have all that much interaction in the story parts.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AlecSkorpio 09/09/19 6:03:42 PM #16:	eston posted... I kinda felt like there was supposed to be more going on with Mary Beth and Arthur. There's several times throughout the game where she sits Arthur down so he can talk about his problems (all optional convos, but marked on the map), but it was weird because they don't have all that much interaction in the story parts. I know people theorized that she was the scrapped love interest, but I still think it was probably Sadie and they realized how tone deaf it was at the last minute and dropped it. --- Christian Bale profited off the Iraq War <cite>AlecSkorpio posted [p:927208826] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>eston posted...</cite> <quote>I kinda felt like there was supposed to be more going on with Mary Beth and Arthur. There's several times throughout the game where she sits Arthur down so he can talk about his problems (all optional convos, but marked on the map), but it was weird because they don't have all that much interaction in the story parts.</quote> I know people theorized that she was the scrapped love interest, but I still think it was probably Sadie and they realized how tone deaf it was at the last minute and dropped it.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Vita_Aeterna 09/09/19 6:18:37 PM #17:	eston posted... I kinda felt like there was supposed to be more going on with Mary Beth and Arthur. There's several times throughout the game where she sits Arthur down so he can talk about his problems (all optional convos, but marked on the map), but it was weird because they don't have all that much interaction in the story parts. Tilly and Molly both offer to talk to Arthur as well. I don't think Mary-Beth was ever a love interest, she's actually far too young. She's 21 years old. --- "Death is so terribly final, while life is full of possibilities." <cite>Vita_Aeterna posted [p:927209399] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>eston posted...</cite> <quote>I kinda felt like there was supposed to be more going on with Mary Beth and Arthur. There's several times throughout the game where she sits Arthur down so he can talk about his problems (all optional convos, but marked on the map), but it was weird because they don't have all that much interaction in the story parts.</quote> Tilly and Molly both offer to talk to Arthur as well. I don't think Mary-Beth was ever a love interest, she's actually far too young. She's 21 years old.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AlecSkorpio 09/09/19 6:45:38 PM #18:	Vita_Aeterna posted... she's actually far too young. She's 21 years old. lol I think most women got married in their mid to late teens back then. --- Christian Bale profited off the Iraq War <cite>AlecSkorpio posted [p:927210549] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Vita_Aeterna posted...</cite> <quote>she's actually far too young. She's 21 years old.</quote> lol I think most women got married in their mid to late teens back then.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
UnfairRepresent 09/09/19 6:48:32 PM #19:	Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut? --- ^ Hey now that's completely unfair! https://imgtc.com/i/bHqCLJF.png https://i.imgtc.com/YnvkpvU.png <cite>UnfairRepresent posted [p:927210675] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Shotgunnova 09/09/19 6:52:30 PM #20:	Sadie was great. Some of the others were hit-and-miss. --- Take me down from the ridge where the summer ends And watch the city spread out just like a jet's flame <cite>Shotgunnova posted [p:927210855] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie was great. Some of the others were hit-and-miss.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AlecSkorpio 09/09/19 6:54:13 PM #21:	UnfairRepresent posted... Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut? ~~Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada.~~ They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: ~~That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?~~ --- Christian Bale profited off the Iraq War <cite>AlecSkorpio posted [p:927210916] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut?</quote> Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada. They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Southernfatman 09/09/19 6:54:47 PM #22:	Sadie is cool, but she's a little...ugh I'm just going to say it...mary sue-ish (for a real lack of a better term here) somewhat. Or at least they were trying a bit too hard to make her seem cool/badass. She still was great though regardless. Mary Beth might be the best. I swear there was supposed to be more there. Screw that other Mary. And the pervert in me has Karen for runner up. I liked Ms. Grimshaw too. --- https://imgur.com/hslUvRN When I sin I sin real good. <cite>Southernfatman posted [p:927210934] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie is cool, but she's a little...ugh I'm just going to say it...mary sue-ish (for a real lack of a better term here) somewhat. Or at least they were trying a bit too hard to make her seem cool/badass. She still was great though regardless. Mary Beth might be the best. I swear there was supposed to be more there. Screw that other Mary. And the pervert in me has Karen for runner up. I liked Ms. Grimshaw too.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
DocileOrangeCup 09/09/19 6:57:45 PM #23:	Karen --- https://imgur.com/kHnd6lr https://imgur.com/uG042id https://imgur.com/tIfDfZH https://imgur.com/xhtRl8w https://imgur.com/ggQozRe https://imgur.com/sKAQfDJ <cite>DocileOrangeCup posted [p:927211057] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Karen </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
UnfairRepresent 09/09/19 7:05:18 PM #24:	AlecSkorpio posted... UnfairRepresent posted... Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut? ~~Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada.~~ They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: ~~That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?~~ You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2 --- ^ Hey now that's completely unfair! https://imgtc.com/i/bHqCLJF.png https://i.imgtc.com/YnvkpvU.png <cite>UnfairRepresent posted [p:927211361] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut?</quote> Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada. They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?</quote> You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Lost_All_Senses 09/09/19 7:07:05 PM #25:	Southernfatman posted... Sadie is cool, but she's a little...ugh I'm just going to say it...mary sue-ish (for a real lack of a better term here) somewhat. Or at least they were trying a bit too hard to make her seem cool/badass. She still was great though regardless. I feel like it wasn't overstated. It was cool to have the chick be more down and badass than most the dudes. But she still seemed realistic to me. --- Name checks out https://i.imgtc.ws/vBF8odT.png <cite>Lost_All_Senses posted [p:927211426] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Southernfatman posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie is cool, but she's a little...ugh I'm just going to say it...mary sue-ish (for a real lack of a better term here) somewhat. Or at least they were trying a bit too hard to make her seem cool/badass. She still was great though regardless.</quote> I feel like it wasn't overstated. It was cool to have the chick be more down and badass than most the dudes. But she still seemed realistic to me.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AlecSkorpio 09/09/19 7:07:07 PM #26:	UnfairRepresent posted... AlecSkorpio posted... UnfairRepresent posted... Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut? ~~Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada.~~ They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: ~~That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?~~ You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2 You missed the main part of my post, which was that how was he supposed to contact them in time? Also, if they were only killing "active" members, ~~why did they end up killing John at the end?~~ --- Christian Bale profited off the Iraq War <cite>AlecSkorpio posted [p:927211428] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut?</quote> Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada. They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?</quote> You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2</quote> You missed the main part of my post, which was that how was he supposed to contact them in time? Also, if they were only killing "active" members, why did they end up killing John at the end?</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Southernfatman 09/09/19 7:12:26 PM #27:	Lost_All_Senses posted... I feel like it wasn't overstated. It was cool to have the chick be more down and badass than most the dudes. But she still seemed realistic to me. Yeah, I mean that in the mildest of ways. Sometimes it can be a tiny tiny tiny bit much for me. Overall, she's great though and I dug her. --- https://imgur.com/hslUvRN When I sin I sin real good. <cite>Southernfatman posted [p:927211638] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Lost_All_Senses posted...</cite> <quote>I feel like it wasn't overstated. It was cool to have the chick be more down and badass than most the dudes. But she still seemed realistic to me.</quote> Yeah, I mean that in the mildest of ways. Sometimes it can be a tiny tiny tiny bit much for me. Overall, she's great though and I dug her.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
UnfairRepresent 09/09/19 7:43:10 PM #28:	AlecSkorpio posted... UnfairRepresent posted... AlecSkorpio posted... UnfairRepresent posted... Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut? ~~Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada.~~ They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: ~~That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?~~ You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2 You missed the main part of my post, which was that how was he supposed to contact them in time? Also, if they were only killing "active" members, ~~why did they end up killing John at the end?~~ Well in the first game it was because They had to justify their salaries. They weren't going to let John off the hook for his crimes. But due to RDR2 it's more likely revenge for the death of Ross' buddy I mean don't forget Archer wasn't there --- ^ Hey now that's completely unfair! https://imgtc.com/i/bHqCLJF.png https://i.imgtc.com/YnvkpvU.png <cite>UnfairRepresent posted [p:927212912] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut?</quote> Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada. They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?</quote> You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2</quote> You missed the main part of my post, which was that how was he supposed to contact them in time? Also, if they were only killing "active" members, why did they end up killing John at the end?</quote> Well in the first game it was because They had to justify their salaries. They weren't going to let John off the hook for his crimes. But due to RDR2 it's more likely revenge for the death of Ross' buddy I mean don't forget Archer wasn't there</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
kinetika_ 09/09/19 9:07:19 PM #29:	pres_madagascar posted... Sadie is Bae. Yep, no contest. --- PSN: PurifyNothing <cite>kinetika_ posted [p:927216606] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>pres_madagascar posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie is Bae. </quote> Yep, no contest.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/09/19 9:55:38 PM #30:	eston posted... I wasnt crazy about Sadie's voice actress I feel similar. Not exactly a problem with the voice actress, but Sadie as a character sounded too gruff to be charming for me. She as definitely cool tho. ~~Everyone who rode with Arthur at the end was a G.~~ <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927218841] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>eston posted... </cite> <quote>I wasnt crazy about Sadie's voice actress</quote>I feel similar. Not exactly a problem with the voice actress, but Sadie as a character sounded too gruff to be charming for me. She as definitely cool tho. Everyone who rode with Arthur at the end was a G. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
jumi 09/09/19 10:42:40 PM #31:	Sadie was the best character, but Tilly was bae. --- XBL Gamertag: Rob Thorsman Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/robertvsilvers <cite>jumi posted [p:927221174] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie was the best character, but Tilly was bae. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
hockeybub89 09/09/19 10:45:06 PM #32:	Sadie, but Abigail is pretty good too --- http://card.psnprofiles.com/1/NIR_Hockey.png http://www.last.fm/user/hockeybub89/ <cite>hockeybub89 posted [p:927221271] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie, but Abigail is pretty good too</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
jumi 09/09/19 10:46:14 PM #33:	ROBANN_88 posted... is that farm lady from the beginning of 1 somewhere in 2? i liked her Bonnie MacFarlane? No, she's not in 2. ~~You can see her ranch, though.~~ --- XBL Gamertag: Rob Thorsman Facebook: http://www.facebook.com/robertvsilvers <cite>jumi posted [p:927221327] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>ROBANN_88 posted... </cite> <quote>is that farm lady from the beginning of 1 somewhere in 2? i liked her</quote> Bonnie MacFarlane? No, she's not in 2. You can see her ranch, though. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
AlecSkorpio 09/09/19 11:05:13 PM #35:	UnfairRepresent posted... AlecSkorpio posted... UnfairRepresent posted... AlecSkorpio posted... UnfairRepresent posted... Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut? ~~Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada.~~ They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: ~~That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?~~ You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2 You missed the main part of my post, which was that how was he supposed to contact them in time? Also, if they were only killing "active" members, ~~why did they end up killing John at the end?~~ Well in the first game it was because They had to justify their salaries. They weren't going to let John off the hook for his crimes. But due to RDR2 it's more likely revenge for the death of Ross' buddy I mean don't forget Archer wasn't there So basically, they would have ~~killed Sadie and Charles~~. Thanks. --- Christian Bale profited off the Iraq War <cite>AlecSkorpio posted [p:927222091] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted...</cite> <quote>UnfairRepresent posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie bugs me because it makes RDR1 make no sense in Retrsospect. Why didn't John ask for Sadie and Charles help? Sadie risked her life to bust John out of prison but won't lift a finger to save Abigail and Jack? Wut?</quote> Sadie says she is going to South America at the end, and I believe Charles says he is going to Canada. They didn't exactly have the internet to get the message out to them back in 1911. Edit: That's not even getting into how John wouldn't contact them on account of them also being members of Dutch's gang. You know, the gang he is actively being blackmailed into killing?</quote> You're just rationalizing. You're not being blackmailed into killing the entire gang, just Bill, Dutch and Javier because they are active. In fact John was just told to kill Bill. Then the stakes escalated when Javier and Dutch turned up and the assignment expanded. John would totally want to just break Abigail and Jack out. The plot only makes sense because John is establised to have no friends. Charles, Sadie, John and Uncle combined could easily bust Abigail and Jack free. Look how easy it was to save John in RDR2</quote> You missed the main part of my post, which was that how was he supposed to contact them in time? Also, if they were only killing "active" members, why did they end up killing John at the end?</quote> Well in the first game it was because They had to justify their salaries. They weren't going to let John off the hook for his crimes. But due to RDR2 it's more likely revenge for the death of Ross' buddy I mean don't forget Archer wasn't there</quote> So basically, they would have killed Sadie and Charles. Thanks.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/10/19 2:41:00 AM #36:	AlecSkorpio posted... So basically, they would have ~~killed Sadie and Charles~~. Thanks. The Pinkertons ~~are like Dutch. Use people then kill them.~~ <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927227670] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted... </cite> <quote>So basically, they would have killed Sadie and Charles. Thanks.</quote>The Pinkertons are like Dutch. Use people then kill them. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
UnfairRepresent 09/10/19 5:52:44 AM #37:	sLaCkEr408___RJ posted... AlecSkorpio posted... So basically, they would have ~~killed Sadie and Charles~~. Thanks. The Pinkertons ~~are like Dutch. Use people then kill them.~~ That ain't fair The Pinkertons didn't start shit, they just respond to it. AlecSkorpio posted... ~~So basically, they would have killed Sadie and Charles.~~ Thanks. Only if they failed to save Jack and Abigail. --- ^ Hey now that's completely unfair! https://imgtc.com/i/bHqCLJF.png https://i.imgtc.com/YnvkpvU.png <cite>UnfairRepresent posted [p:927230325] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted...</cite> <quote>AlecSkorpio posted... </cite> <quote>So basically, they would have killed Sadie and Charles. Thanks.</quote>The Pinkertons are like Dutch. Use people then kill them. </quote> That ain't fair The Pinkertons didn't start shit, they just respond to it. AlecSkorpio posted...</cite> <quote> So basically, they would have killed Sadie and Charles. Thanks.</quote> Only if they failed to save Jack and Abigail.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
eston 09/10/19 7:23:28 AM #38:	There still wasn't any reasonably realistic way for him to get in contact with them. It would have been cool for Sadie and/or Charles to show up in RDR1, but it makes sense why they didn't. Plus IIRC John didn't know where his family was being held, so breaking them out wasn't really an option. But one character they did touch on that I thought was cool was the nun. You meet her in San Denis and do all kinds of good stuff for her while telling her what a bad person you are. It's the same nun John meets in Mexico in RDR1. --- http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i215/estonc/grizzly_bear_chairs_2.jpg https://imgur.com/8kjZU <cite>eston posted [p:927231597] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>There still wasn't any reasonably realistic way for him to get in contact with them. It would have been cool for Sadie and/or Charles to show up in RDR1, but it makes sense why they didn't. Plus IIRC John didn't know where his family was being held, so breaking them out wasn't really an option. But one character they did touch on that I thought was cool was the nun. You meet her in San Denis and do all kinds of good stuff for her while telling her what a bad person you are. It's the same nun John meets in Mexico in RDR1.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
ledbowman 09/10/19 8:26:30 AM #39:	Sandy Cheeks aka Sadie --- I wish we all waved <cite>ledbowman posted [p:927232781] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sandy Cheeks aka Sadie</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
EzeDoesIt 09/10/19 8:29:50 AM #40:	slmcknett posted... Clearly Sadie. --- Not changing this sig. <cite>EzeDoesIt posted [p:927232842] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>slmcknett posted...</cite> <quote>Clearly Sadie.</quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
RickyTheBAWSE 09/10/19 8:30:59 AM #41:	jumi posted... Sadie was the best character, but Tilly was bae. --- Never let those intent on misunderstanding you be the narrator to YOUR story! Context? Context!? CONTEXT!!! <cite>RickyTheBAWSE posted [p:927232864] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote><cite>jumi posted...</cite> <quote>Sadie was the best character, but Tilly was bae. </quote></quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Jiggy101011 09/10/19 8:40:05 AM #42:	I find it odd that Karen just disappears. --- Gamertag: F1RE v2 PSN ID: F1REx Man got me a 9 and she sexy <cite>Jiggy101011 posted [p:927233042] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>I find it odd that Karen just disappears. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
boxington 09/10/19 10:43:33 AM #43:	Jiggy101011 posted... I find it odd that Karen just disappears. Tilly says something about how ~~she likely drank herself to death in a letter~~, iirc. --- b-bb-box <cite>boxington posted [p:927236383] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Jiggy101011 posted...</cite> <quote>I find it odd that Karen just disappears. </quote> Tilly says something about how she likely drank herself to death in a letter, iirc.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
eston 09/10/19 11:53:39 AM #44:	Apparently, depending on other factors, Swanson can just disappear too. At the end of the mission where you rescue Captain Monroe from being charged with treason, there's a scene that is different depending on whether you did a certain stranger quest. In my game I met up with the nun, who was boarding a train to Mexico. If you don't meet up with the nun, you meet with Swanson instead as he's boarding the train to NY. --- http://i73.photobucket.com/albums/i215/estonc/grizzly_bear_chairs_2.jpg https://imgur.com/8kjZU <cite>eston posted [p:927238974] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Apparently, depending on other factors, Swanson can just disappear too. At the end of the mission where you rescue Captain Monroe from being charged with treason, there's a scene that is different depending on whether you did a certain stranger quest. In my game I met up with the nun, who was boarding a train to Mexico. If you don't meet up with the nun, you meet with Swanson instead as he's boarding the train to NY.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/10/19 2:35:20 PM #45:	eston posted... Apparently, depending on other factors, Swanson can just disappear too. At the end of the mission where you rescue Captain Monroe from being charged with treason, there's a scene that is different depending on whether you did a certain stranger quest. In my game I met up with the nun, who was boarding a train to Mexico. If you don't meet up with the nun, you meet with Swanson instead as he's boarding the train to NY. A sad scene ~~whenal Arthur admits he's afraid to die.~~ <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927245998] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>eston posted... </cite> <quote>Apparently, depending on other factors, Swanson can just disappear too. At the end of the mission where you rescue Captain Monroe from being charged with treason, there's a scene that is different depending on whether you did a certain stranger quest. In my game I met up with the nun, who was boarding a train to Mexico. If you don't meet up with the nun, you meet with Swanson instead as he's boarding the train to NY.</quote>A sad scene whenal Arthur admits he's afraid to die. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/11/19 2:08:38 AM #46:	Going for 100%. Any recommendations on what to do first <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927272842] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Going for 100%. Any recommendations on what to do first </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
GameGodOfAll 09/11/19 2:36:04 AM #47:	Sadie's the best, but she's pushed the hardest to where it's not even a fair comparison to the others. I really liked Karen as a member of the group. Tilly's cool. Mary-Beth was who I liked the most. I think her and Arthur coulda had something. --- My Words Were True And Sheamus Made You Believe! https://imgur.com/Fc39f <cite>GameGodOfAll posted [p:927273480] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Sadie's the best, but she's pushed the hardest to where it's not even a fair comparison to the others. I really liked Karen as a member of the group. Tilly's cool. Mary-Beth was who I liked the most. I think her and Arthur coulda had something.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
boxington 09/11/19 2:38:19 AM #48:	idk, Arthur saw Tilly as a daughter, and Mary Beth was about the same age as her. but she would have been a way better fit than Arthur's annoying ex. --- b-bb-box <cite>boxington posted [p:927273525] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>idk, Arthur saw Tilly as a daughter, and Mary Beth was about the same age as her. but she would have been a way better fit than Arthur's annoying ex.</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/11/19 3:59:54 PM #49:	I always thought Arthur was the big brother. Dutch and Hosea was the father. <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927297549] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>I always thought Arthur was the big brother. Dutch and Hosea was the father. </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
boxington 09/11/19 4:50:51 PM #50:	true. I guess I was just basing it off of one of the camp conversations https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sO7nZiXBGAA" data-time=" --- b-bb-box <cite>boxington posted [p:927299941] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>true. I guess I was just basing it off of one of the camp conversations https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=sO7nZiXBGAA" data-time="</quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ 09/13/19 12:19:20 AM #51:	Karen vs Molly <cite>sLaCkEr408___RJ posted [p:927367013] in Red Dead R... [t:77999694]...</cite> <quote>Karen vs Molly </quote> ... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List	Page List: 1, 2

Current Events > Red Dead Redemption 2 [women] (+) Yeah! (+)

Current Events > Red Dead Redemption 2 [women]