Board 8 > English Literature Mafia Topic 8: Dedicated to Delseban Part II: The Musical

(+) Yeah! (+)

turbopuns3 posted...

Chris if red was town do you think he would have town cleared you in his own personal view after day 1

I think if he was town he'd have gone "K Chris is probably town let me tell you what I learned from that with an entire night to think this over since I have been playing mafia for over a decade and know Luis well" instead of whatever that was.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Cam my friend what are YOUR thoughts on my magic trick with Red?

I've been a bit occupied

I missed the entire magic trick and red stuff

Let me check it out

I want to reread it in the morning. My original thought was Chris got him. My second thought was that bussing Luis and red seems like something Chris would have fun doing. My third thought was eh maybe that wasn't so great a trap.

Pez down to 60% scum btw
---

Tom Bombadil posted...

I want to reread it in the morning. My original thought was Chris got him. My second thought was that bussing Luis and red seems like something Chris would have fun doing. My third thought was eh maybe that wasn't so great a trap.

Pez down to 60% scum btw

Red and I have never lost as scumbuddies btw
---

Explain the exact progression of those thoughts. Were they buffered by intermediate posts or other insights? About how much time between each thought?
---

They were probably buffered by focusing on cam I don't keep a timeline but I think pez got me to the third one
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I think if he was town he'd have gone "K Chris is probably town let me tell you what I learned from that with an entire night to think this over since I have been playing mafia for over a decade and know Luis well" instead of whatever that was.

Even with the whole posting during a work break thing, too? Town red has no concern if multiple people are experiencing ChrisFear?

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Luis just kept coming back around again and again inside my head. It was like "Ergh he hasn't been super bad but that two post combo has so many things wrong with it." Finally a

I see it here, reading, give me a sec

tag



me reacting to my death

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dGalix-sVXs" data-time="


---

turbopuns3 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I think if he was town he'd have gone "K Chris is probably town let me tell you what I learned from that with an entire night to think this over since I have been playing mafia for over a decade and know Luis well" instead of whatever that was.

Even with the whole posting during a work break thing, too? Town red has no concern if multiple people are experiencing ChrisFear?

Do I look incapable of defending myself? <_<
---

Pez doesnt loke me for taking the advice of o believe it was Han and maybe Ulti? to keep my reads short and sweet opposed to what i was doing in games of past. I have good reada just dont i guess exspress them the best. So no matter what i do it doesnt seem to help with atleast someone though form my experience the ones who pick on me for my reads the most are usually scum trying to convince everyone om scum beacuse im an easy miss lynch so let me go back and look into your game more beacuse right now im thinking this possibly what is going on
---

So focusing on cam had you think that scum Chris might do that? Anything in particular about the flow of conversation that made you jump to that rather than focusing hard on cam?

Was there anything in Pez's post in particular that spurred the thought that maybe it wasn't a great trap?
---

yeah I still don't understand the magic trick

I'll keep looking lol

But as I said, I'm pretty busy right now and have to read up when I have free time

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Do I look incapable of defending myself? <_<

Well I'm just saying it could be less red defending you and more red soothing babby towns

Idk I'm just toying with it

turbopuns3 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Do I look incapable of defending myself? <_<

Well I'm just saying it could be less red defending you and more red soothing babby towns

Idk I'm just toying with it

And doing nothing else?
---

Focusing on cam had I think nothing to do with it im trying to multitask

Gimme a sec on the pez part
---

Let me put this another way: Red needed more information, it is why he asked me to give him my thoughts.

Do you think that YOU are better at determining I am town than red?
---

Ok Chris I think your magic trick was cool. But I think it's not convincing all the way because you didn't give a solid idea if what town Red would do. So you correctly predicted what Red would post. But it isn't 100% clear to me that town Red doesn't have the same thoughts. You did a good job of explaining why scum Red makes the post and that's damning. But why doesn't Town Red an what does Town Red say instead? Any specifics?
---

Like I could go "DANG, GOT EM" and vote red but then I'd just be sitting here waiting for red

Speaking which, red said voting SBell day 1 was stupid :(

Camarija posted...

yeah I still don't understand the magic trick

I'll keep looking lol

But as I said, I'm pretty busy right now and have to read up when I have free time

Lopen posted...

turbopuns3 posted...

Like what was town red supposed to say if he does know how you play and he saw you play that way

I think his point was that town red wouldn't find a reason to post something that serves no purpose other than to put over "look how well I know Chris!" Like that doesn't clear Chris at all. It also was just a repeat of what Chris already said. Basically it was a loaded "town clear" (which was pointless because very few people are suspecting him to begin with)

That explains the meat of the magic in the trick as concisely as possible and how it's catching scum.
---

Keep in mind Chris currently has one vote

Babbys do not need to be soothed.
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Pez doesnt loke me for taking the advice of o believe it was Han and maybe Ulti? to keep my reads short and sweet opposed to what i was doing in games of past. I have good reada just dont i guess exspress them the best. So no matter what i do it doesnt seem to help with atleast someone though form my experience the ones who pick on me for my reads the most are usually scum trying to convince everyone om scum beacuse im an easy miss lynch so let me go back and look into your game more beacuse right now im thinking this possibly what is going on

I see no meat to your reads. I want to know what you see. Be specific if possible. But what I see from you is still beat described by me as cheap. Maybe there's depth behind it you're not telling us. But I don't see it. Still think you could be scum. In fact if we lunch Red today in probably voting for you tomorrow.
---

pezloco posted...

Ok Chris I think your magic trick was cool. But I think it's not convincing all the way because you didn't give a solid idea if what town Red would do. So you correctly predicted what Red would post. But it isn't 100% clear to me that town Red doesn't have the same thoughts. You did a good job of explaining why scum Red makes the post and that's damning. But why doesn't Town Red an what does Town Red say instead? Any specifics?

You said I am off limits from that.

Red thought he needed more information to confirm that.

Pez, can anyone read Tom better than you?

I am Tom and you are Red.

Think.
---

Well I remembered pez having a counter argument but on a reread it was just where he asked for a rephrase because he didn't follow it
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Let me put this another way: Red needed more information, it is why he asked me to give him my thoughts.

Do you think that YOU are better at determining I am town than red?

Well.

...

You could be scum.

lol

##vote: Red
##unvote: Red

Probably sleeping soon. I don't want town to get too focused in Red and forget to listen to each other. I almost did that last game. But I plan on trying to get Red lynched today.
---

I don't see how "town red would come into the topic with reads on some suspects after some time to catch up with reading from the 24 hours off" is something that needs roommate powers to determine

Like I don't know what a town red game looks like because I don't remember any but I've been asking for suspicions from him the whole time because surely he has a reputation for being good for some reason.
---

turbopuns3 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Let me put this another way: Red needed more information, it is why he asked me to give him my thoughts.

Do you think that YOU are better at determining I am town than red?

Well.

...

You could be scum.

No I can't you waited for the wow play and I gave you scum power, puns plz
---

Kinda want to vote pez there

Lopen posted...

I don't see how "town red would come into the topic with reads on some suspects after some time to catch up with reading from the 24 hours off" is something that needs roommate powers to determine

Like I don't know what a town red game looks like because I don't remember any but I've been asking for suspicions from him the whole time because surely he has a reputation for being good for some reason.

I go personal you go professional man. We have the same conclusion but we appeal to different audiences.

I'm Stone Cold, you're HHH
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

No I can't you waited for the wow play and I gave you scum power, puns plz

It made me laugh when I realized the only logical way to maintain my view in response to what you said was ChrisFear. Then I had to say it because it was funny

HHH? That's very hurtful.
---

turbopuns3 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Let me put this another way: Red needed more information, it is why he asked me to give him my thoughts.

Do you think that YOU are better at determining I am town than red?

Well.

...

You could be scum.

The only way this is possible based on the magic trick is if Red and Chris are scum yes? Or that scum Chris recognized that town Red would know based on Luis post that town Chris would kill Luis. But even then Chris just kills Red at night.

So only way it works is if Red is scum with Chris. But then why bus Luis? Saying Chris could be scum only makes sense if you want to argue third party. And believe me I'd listen to that. But I don't think you're going there. So why mention it?
---

It being "You could be scum"
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I'm Stone Cold, you're HHH

No HHH was Red ;)
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I am Tom and you are Red.

T

....fair enough

turbopuns3 posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Let me put this another way: Red needed more information, it is why he asked me to give him my thoughts.

Do you think that YOU are better at determining I am town than red?

Well.

...

You could be scum.

Even if he is he's probably bussing?
That's the fun thing about Pez and Chris- even if they're scum, a lot of the time they're feeding you good stuff anyway. Maybe Scum!Chris could go this far to eliminate Town!Red but going THIS hard seems kinda suicidal
---

Tom Bombadil posted...

Maybe Scum!Chris could go this far to eliminate Town!Red but going THIS hard seems kinda suicidal

Elaborate on why it's suicidal for me.
---

Man I wanted to lean even more scum on pez for taking my ChrisFear seriously but then Tom did it too and now I'm less confident in that

turbopuns3 posted...

lol

this being a separate post two secs later absolutely reeks to me of "WAIT I'D BETTER HEDGE MYBETS"
---

Come on guys I even followed up with the lol

Is it normal for corrik when people pit suspicion on him to just disappear?
---

Oh, ffs

turbopuns3 posted...

Kinda want to vote pez there

Pez has been looking horribly scum to me these recent posts every time he talks about lynching Sultan tomorrow after Red today.
---

pezloco posted...

So only way it works is if Red is scum with Chris. But then why bus Luis? Saying Chris could be scum only makes sense if you want to argue third party. And believe me I'd listen to that. But I don't think you're going there. So why mention it?

I disagree i could totally see a scum chris kill a team mate to make himself look amazing
---

Lopen posted...

Tom Bombadil posted...

Maybe Scum!Chris could go this far to eliminate Town!Red but going THIS hard seems kinda suicidal

Elaborate on why it's suicidal for me.

He basically went (non)roommate Powers on it. That's enough of a reputation stake to wipe out the d1 Goodwill if he's wrong imo
---

turbopuns3 posted...

Man I wanted to lean even more scum on pez for taking my ChrisFear seriously but then Tom did it too and now I'm less confident in that

Hey that's my roommate.

I'm honestly not sure I'm reading anything well right now. I really should've gone to bed already but I had asked Tom to stick around. And then I already had my phone out so I kept sticking around.

Back to Sultan for a moment

Am I really the only one who thinks Sultan's posts are cheap? No one seemed to care yesterday. And no one seems to care today. But no one has pointed out what I'm missing. I feel like it's just being lost in everything else.
---

Cool, easy day

Zzz

turbopuns3 posted...

Oh, ffs

Lol
---

TheSultanOfSlam posted...

Is it normal for corrik when people pit suspicion on him to just disappear?

I honestly have no idea what Corrik is doing this game

The chris vote opener was an eyesore really