Board 8 > Avengers Endgame Mafia Topic 5: Day 1 End

(+) Yeah! (+)

Um ##vote: Ulti

How the fuck did yinz mess this up
---

No idea how red was town. Han did act crazy as hell just to breadcrumb he was bodyguard too. Wild.
---

Wait, what?
---

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.
---

Obellisk posted...

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.

I'd assume Han died bodyguarding the watcher.
---

Corrik7 posted...

Obellisk posted...

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.

I'd assume Han died bodyguarding the watcher.

But that leaves red.
---

Is it possible someone vigged red?
---

Really ulti? That's a weak vote. We have a late day swing onto a town power, and that's how you wanna start day 2?

Hbthebattle posted...

Wait, what?

What's this directed at?
---

Scum has rb

They targeted me
---

I'm at work i'll talk more later
---

Obellisk posted...

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.

Explain why you would think Tange became most likely scum out of everyone after that action
---

Corrik7 posted...

Obellisk posted...

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.

I'd assume Han died bodyguarding the watcher.

I don't think so.
---

I have a hard time believing the innocent intentions of the people who voted Tange and know better. It felt like he got a lot of votes because "that was a mean thing to do", and not "that action makes you scum"
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

UnderUrMattress posted...

Scum has rb

They targeted me

Who did you attempt to target?

Sbell
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

Because Tange royally fucked up.

Bullshit. No one played worse day 1 than Han.

You guys do this shit all the time. You random players you consider lesser players. It's pretty bullshit. Idk why they even keep signing up.
---

Killing Red despite all the floating suspicion on him is something I see Scare doing.

How are you Mason buddy?
---

UnderUrMattress posted...

UltimaterializerX posted...

UnderUrMattress posted...

Scum has rb

They targeted me

Who did you attempt to target?

Sbell

La why?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Wait, what?

What's this directed at?

Reds death, mostly
---

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Wait, what?

What's this directed at?

Reds death, mostly

I mean it's interesting but is it THAT surprising? You've seen him be killed day 1 a lot, right?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Wait, what?

What's this directed at?

Reds death, mostly

I mean it's interesting but is it THAT surprising? You've seen him be killed day 1 a lot, right?

Well, A: I thought he was for sure scum, and B: if he isn't scum, he was still one of the players with a lot of heat on him yesterday. I don't understand why he of all people would get killed by scum, which is why I think it's possible a vig was involved.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Obellisk posted...

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.

Explain why you would think Tange became most likely scum out of everyone after that action

I'm torn on the neighbors, wasn't going to participate in either one getting lynched yet. I believed hbs claim. And after Thor flipped vanilla I think it's a fairly believable that captain America is vanilla too. And as much as it might pain me to say, I currently believe Ulti.

So tange doing that at that hour, yeah I thought it was scummy enough to kill it.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Wait, what?

What's this directed at?

Reds death, mostly

I mean it's interesting but is it THAT surprising? You've seen him be killed day 1 a lot, right?

Well, A: I thought he was for sure scum, and B: if he isn't scum, he was still one of the players with a lot of heat on him yesterday. I don't understand why he of all people would get killed by scum, which is why I think it's possible a vig was involved.

Because he's town? And when he's town scum views him as one of the best players and always goes for best players first since they're afraid of keeping them alive? You're over complicating it and it feels like you're playing up the reaction *shrug*
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

You say this as if there was any way to know he was power before he flipped. All he did was act scummy and dare people to shoot him. That is his own fault for breaking the code, and it's really shitty given we lost a commuter and very likely our two best town players because of it.

Frankly the only people in this game I actually trust are you, Stu, Cam, and your neighbor. Pretty much everyone else is low impact or looks awful.

You say you trust him, then you turn around and vote him?

Holy shit is ulti actually town?

Hey sultan will you please describe the neighbir chat we had during night 1.

Obellisk posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Obellisk posted...

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.

Explain why you would think Tange became most likely scum out of everyone after that action

I'm torn on the neighbors, wasn't going to participate in either one getting lynched yet. I believed hbs claim. And after Thor flipped vanilla I think it's a fairly believable that captain America is vanilla too. And as much as it might pain me to say, I currently believe Ulti.

So tange doing that at that hour, yeah I thought it was scummy enough to kill it.

So you were just looking for "scummy enough"?

Why'd you believe HB's claim?

(And sure the role is proven to not be completely impossible, but safe lists exist and it's no more believable than any other flavor is it?)
---

UltimaterializerX posted...

Obellisk posted...

So tange doing that at that hour, yeah I thought it was scummy enough to kill it.

I'm with you on this, and anyone calling that lynch scummy has never had someone lie about a same-time on them. It's one of those unwritten rules that you just don't break. It's in "the code".

Anyway I think Cam is a great direction. Gonna reread and see if any changes happened once I pointed 'town' at him. I unfortunately have to go to sleep and work another 8-8 tomorrow. I'll be around when I can.

And because of the logic you're using scum had an easy excuse to jump on Tange. It works both ways. Im sure scum took advantage of that
---

benjamin3740 posted...

UltimaterializerX posted...

Obellisk posted...

So tange doing that at that hour, yeah I thought it was scummy enough to kill it.

I'm with you on this, and anyone calling that lynch scummy has never had someone lie about a same-time on them. It's one of those unwritten rules that you just don't break. It's in "the code".

Anyway I think Cam is a great direction. Gonna reread and see if any changes happened once I pointed 'town' at him. I unfortunately have to go to sleep and work another 8-8 tomorrow. I'll be around when I can.

And because of the logic you're using scum had an easy excuse to jump on Tange. It works both ways. Im sure scum took advantage of that

100%

There was scum on that lynch.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Obellisk posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Obellisk posted...

Well shit.

I'm not taking full responsibility for Tanges death. It was a legit scummy thing he did regardless of hbs intent on claiming and he shouldn't have engaged at all.

I think it's important to look into everyone on the lynch. Both neighbirs made it as well as Ulti. I don't think nk you should over look me at all, I certainly don't look great but I stand by my vote and I'd do it again.

And two kills. I'd like to believe it wasn't town vig on town I really would.

Explain why you would think Tange became most likely scum out of everyone after that action

I'm torn on the neighbors, wasn't going to participate in either one getting lynched yet. I believed hbs claim. And after Thor flipped vanilla I think it's a fairly believable that captain America is vanilla too. And as much as it might pain me to say, I currently believe Ulti.

So tange doing that at that hour, yeah I thought it was scummy enough to kill it.

So you were just looking for "scummy enough"?

Why'd you believe HB's claim?

(And sure the role is proven to not be completely impossible, but safe lists exist and it's no more believable than any other flavor is it?)

Because if I'm willing to believe that thanos is a Miller and that ancient one is a watcher (lesser character power role) then yes captain America getting vanilla is believable.
---

Obellisk posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

UltimaterializerX posted...

Obellisk posted...

So tange doing that at that hour, yeah I thought it was scummy enough to kill it.

I'm with you on this, and anyone calling that lynch scummy has never had someone lie about a same-time on them. It's one of those unwritten rules that you just don't break. It's in "the code".

Anyway I think Cam is a great direction. Gonna reread and see if any changes happened once I pointed 'town' at him. I unfortunately have to go to sleep and work another 8-8 tomorrow. I'll be around when I can.

And because of the logic you're using scum had an easy excuse to jump on Tange. It works both ways. Im sure scum took advantage of that

100%

There was scum on that lynch.

Anyone in particular standing out to you?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Wait, what?

What's this directed at?

Reds death, mostly

I mean it's interesting but is it THAT surprising? You've seen him be killed day 1 a lot, right?

Well, A: I thought he was for sure scum, and B: if he isn't scum, he was still one of the players with a lot of heat on him yesterday. I don't understand why he of all people would get killed by scum, which is why I think it's possible a vig was involved.

Because he's town? And when he's town scum views him as one of the best players and always goes for best players first since they're afraid of keeping them alive? You're over complicating it and it feels like you're playing up the reaction *shrug*

Well I didn't EXPECT him to be town, which is why it was a surprise. What do you expect? Were you not surprised at all by this night's results?
---

Yeah. I screwed up. My intention wasn't to end the day on Tange, things just got away from me. At the same time, no one cared to kill Thanos with me either.

Red being dead and town confuses me too but fortunately 3 of my scum reads are alive. So who do we kill? Claimed Neighbor, Watcher, or Miller?

Also, not that it matters, but I've changed my game as town and scum since we've played last Ulti.
---

Why watcher eaed?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Obellisk posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

UltimaterializerX posted...

Obellisk posted...

So tange doing that at that hour, yeah I thought it was scummy enough to kill it.

I'm with you on this, and anyone calling that lynch scummy has never had someone lie about a same-time on them. It's one of those unwritten rules that you just don't break. It's in "the code".

Anyway I think Cam is a great direction. Gonna reread and see if any changes happened once I pointed 'town' at him. I unfortunately have to go to sleep and work another 8-8 tomorrow. I'll be around when I can.

And because of the logic you're using scum had an easy excuse to jump on Tange. It works both ways. Im sure scum took advantage of that

100%

There was scum on that lynch.

Anyone in particular standing out to you?

I'm open to one scum in eaed, puns, Sultan, cam. And I'll be narrowing that down.
---

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

Wait, what?

What's this directed at?

Reds death, mostly

I mean it's interesting but is it THAT surprising? You've seen him be killed day 1 a lot, right?

Well, A: I thought he was for sure scum, and B: if he isn't scum, he was still one of the players with a lot of heat on him yesterday. I don't understand why he of all people would get killed by scum, which is why I think it's possible a vig was involved.

Because he's town? And when he's town scum views him as one of the best players and always goes for best players first since they're afraid of keeping them alive? You're over complicating it and it feels like you're playing up the reaction *shrug*

Well I didn't EXPECT him to be town, which is why it was a surprise. What do you expect? Were you not surprised at all by this night's results?

Why is this important?

Obellisk posted...

Why watcher eaed?

I wasnt a fan of Marth yesterday and the only reason I changed my vote was because he claimed watcher. Or do you mean why don't I like marth?
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Obellisk posted...

Why watcher eaed?

I wasnt a fan of Marth yesterday and the only reason I changed my vote was because he claimed watcher. Or do you mean why don't I like marth?

I meant more the claim and less the person. But yes I was ready to kill Marth with fire before the claim as well.

If we believe watcher is fake then the rb claim is fake. And scum used their roleblock on one of the deceased as well as killing them.
---

I'm getting stuck in the meta because of the two flavors I would kill Nebula.
---