Board 8 > Fourpack of Fun: Secret of Mana/Red Dead Redemption, San Andreas/Uncharted 2

(+) Yeah! (+)

SNESFAQs?
---

I voted San Andreas > Secret of Mana but in retrospect Secret of Mana probably wins. Secret of Mana is a step below the usual SNES classics but that's probably still enough to beat San Andreas really. And it's unwise to trust games from 2007 and beyond unless there's a really good reason to, and I think that even Uncharted 2 and RDR aren't on the short list of 2007+ games that can amount to something.
---

To be fair would Secret of Mana break 45% on Chrono Cross? It probably could, but it'd be a tossup.
---

i voted GTA > Secret of Mana cuz I have never followed a single games contest ever

i dont think i've even voted in one

which is crazy considering how obsessed with contests I am
---

San Andreas lost to Golden Sun. I LOVE Golden Sun and am one if its most outspoken fans here and even I admit that it's not a pillar of popularity here. San Andrea's isnt beating any of these games.

I'll go with U2 > SoM.
---

Uncharted 2's match with Sonic 2 was tainted by the Undertale rally admittedly.

But didn't Uncharted get, like, doubled? So how much better would it really do "normally"?

Hmmm, admittedly we've already seen Secret of Mana take on Sonic 2. I don't think SoM did too much better against Sonic 2 than Uncharted 2 did. So perhaps Uncharted does have it. SoM also isn't nearly as mainstream on this site or the gaming community in general compared to something like Chrono Trigger or Super Mario RPG.

A shame Uncharted 2 didn't have a more debated path last contest. Everyone seemed to agree that the Portal 2/Sonic 2 winner would beat Uncharted 2, and that's exactly what happened.
---