Board 8 > TV Crossover Mafia - Topic 7 - You're about to enter the scary door.

(+) Yeah! (+)

eaedwards6400 posted...

Corrik posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Corrik posted...

It is so fun when after the deadline posts win games for teams. = /

Need to go back to strict hosts. That was a waste of like a week.

No, nuh uh. Don't do this s***. His post was literally .05 after the dealine. .05 it wasn't a plan to make you think he was town. You just got too arrogant. Sheep played an amazing game. Don't take that away from him.

Basically afking after a fluke after the deadline vote.

Pretty amazing.

About as amazing as basically FD basically afking with scum lawyer to the almost win.

I mean, take your win and the good game. Nobody got out thought or outplayed on town. It was a fluke. After deadline posts are not supposed to exist by definition because they are after the deadline. Thus, it was an a fluke happening with something that shouldn't have existed in the game that gave yinz the win.

I mean, I guess good job not blowing it, sheep? Lol = )

God. You're really one of those horrible people that are afraid to admit when they are wrong or when they made a mistake arent you? Sheep has been active every day AND EVERYDAY YOU WOULD SAY HE HAD TO BE TOWN. that's not afking. Sheep was in the hub the whole time. Sheep played a damn good game. Sheep called on night 1 what was going to happen for him to win the game and it went almost flawlessly. Is it really that hard to admit when you're wrong?! And I'm having this reaction and it isnt even about me. I just cant stand the thing you're doing and that is refusing to admit fault. It isnt that hard to do.

The ones that could have blown it were us that had to do and not making obvious connections to Sheep. And if you look at the scum board there are times where we are frightened that pirate was going to.

Has nothing to do with admitting I am wrong. Has to do with you can't admit you benefited from something that isn't supposed to exist in a game. Point blank. If you just go, yeah, that late post really helped us I won't lie. End of discussion. When we won when everyone town cleared sultan over his late post, I said when we benefitted from it and it shouldn't have existed also. The difference is I am consistent.

You are sitting here acting like I solely lynched every single person in this game and going hahaha you just can't admit you were wrong rah rah. The fact is everyone was wrong on him because his late post which shouldn't have existed led them to that.

It is what it is. If you as the winner can't admit you benefitted from it, then that is on you. Not me.

You clearly did benefit from it
---

Ashethan posted...

Some thoughts on the game:

Overall, I thought the scum team played too close together, except for Sheep (who was obviously his team's MVP). I was shocked that town adamantly refused to lynch Pirate on day 1 when his claim was bad. (Not Ned Flanders, but just how the claim came about). Yes, it's an uncountered Doc, but when combined with everything after it, I was truly shocked that Pirate wasn't lynched. Though it just goes to show: You shouldn't give up. I felt he did a good job on Day 2 when Corrik counter claimed him (I found it absolutely hilarious when Corrik did that and thought Pirate was caught for sure)

After lynching Scare, town got their act together a bit. Lynching 3 scum in succession. Most of town played very well during those days, though ending days early gave them little to read from some players (namely Sultan). With zero information to work with because they lynched the cop, and the thief died on night 2 after scanning the dead guy. I think everyone got a bit impatient toward the end. Corrik and FD both seemed to be leaning toward "Maybe sheep is scum," but never could get to it. There were a few times I thought he blew it. Especially when Corrik asked Ben if Sheep busses players.

Also, the scum team had no idea who the mason was, and at one point thought it was Corrik. So I think Mzero made the right move not claiming it. It's not like he was being lynched anyway.

I think I acknowledged in one post that save for his vote at the end of day 1 there was nothing to really point to him being town.

I noticed while reading the logs his post counts dropped dramatically almost every day prior.

Oh well. If he hadn't had the vig shot, I think in the final 3 people would have maybe figured it out. I myself was just starting a full game reread when I found out I was dead and the game was over. = (

Not saying I would have found it because FD and Ben didn't have much to make them seem town really either minus a couple spurts. But, you would really have to wonder why "confirmed town" sheep was in the final 3 and people were getting shot over him.
---

You just named the Sultan example AND YOU cleared Sheep as town. You shouldn't be metaing that thing in the first place. And that's why this is you are refusing to admit you were wrong. You're never supposed to meta because metaing can get you in trouble and that's exactly what happened. What I am angry about is you are attempting to take away Sheep's gameplay because you are blaming "benefited from something that shouldn't be in the game" when you could you say we benefited from it but it is everyone whose cleared him for that's fault for clearing him. YOU of all people should know better and your attempt to turn this back on me is pathetic.
---

I do have to say that I had fun watching this thing - even if I didn't know what was going on due to my lack of experience. Perhaps before I enter the fray again - in the unlikely event that I do - I should just watch and learn.

As for my remark to Corrik on Day 1, I legit thought I could disclose my availability in response to Corrik's trash talk so long as I made no game-related comments. That's all. I was lurking almost the entire time, but many a time I came on to post votals only to see them already there. Funny how that works.

I am open to co-host any time I am wanted.
---

Corrik posted...

Ashethan posted...

Some thoughts on the game:

Overall, I thought the scum team played too close together, except for Sheep (who was obviously his team's MVP). I was shocked that town adamantly refused to lynch Pirate on day 1 when his claim was bad. (Not Ned Flanders, but just how the claim came about). Yes, it's an uncountered Doc, but when combined with everything after it, I was truly shocked that Pirate wasn't lynched. Though it just goes to show: You shouldn't give up. I felt he did a good job on Day 2 when Corrik counter claimed him (I found it absolutely hilarious when Corrik did that and thought Pirate was caught for sure)

After lynching Scare, town got their act together a bit. Lynching 3 scum in succession. Most of town played very well during those days, though ending days early gave them little to read from some players (namely Sultan). With zero information to work with because they lynched the cop, and the thief died on night 2 after scanning the dead guy. I think everyone got a bit impatient toward the end. Corrik and FD both seemed to be leaning toward "Maybe sheep is scum," but never could get to it. There were a few times I thought he blew it. Especially when Corrik asked Ben if Sheep busses players.

Also, the scum team had no idea who the mason was, and at one point thought it was Corrik. So I think Mzero made the right move not claiming it. It's not like he was being lynched anyway.

I think I acknowledged in one post that save for his vote at the end of day 1 there was nothing to really point to him being town.

I noticed while reading the logs his post counts dropped dramatically almost every day prior.

Oh well. If he hadn't had the vig shot, I think in the final 3 people would have maybe figured it out. I myself was just starting a full game reread when I found out I was dead and the game was over. = (

Not saying I would have found it because FD and Ben didn't have much to make them seem town really either minus a couple spurts. But, you would really have to wonder why "confirmed town" sheep was in the final 3 and people were getting shot over him.

All results oriented thinking. Revisionists history.
---

My only real misplay imo was targeting pj n2 but that didn't matter.
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Corrik posted...

Ashethan posted...

Some thoughts on the game:

Overall, I thought the scum team played too close together, except for Sheep (who was obviously his team's MVP). I was shocked that town adamantly refused to lynch Pirate on day 1 when his claim was bad. (Not Ned Flanders, but just how the claim came about). Yes, it's an uncountered Doc, but when combined with everything after it, I was truly shocked that Pirate wasn't lynched. Though it just goes to show: You shouldn't give up. I felt he did a good job on Day 2 when Corrik counter claimed him (I found it absolutely hilarious when Corrik did that and thought Pirate was caught for sure)

After lynching Scare, town got their act together a bit. Lynching 3 scum in succession. Most of town played very well during those days, though ending days early gave them little to read from some players (namely Sultan). With zero information to work with because they lynched the cop, and the thief died on night 2 after scanning the dead guy. I think everyone got a bit impatient toward the end. Corrik and FD both seemed to be leaning toward "Maybe sheep is scum," but never could get to it. There were a few times I thought he blew it. Especially when Corrik asked Ben if Sheep busses players.

Also, the scum team had no idea who the mason was, and at one point thought it was Corrik. So I think Mzero made the right move not claiming it. It's not like he was being lynched anyway.

I think I acknowledged in one post that save for his vote at the end of day 1 there was nothing to really point to him being town.

I noticed while reading the logs his post counts dropped dramatically almost every day prior.

Oh well. If he hadn't had the vig shot, I think in the final 3 people would have maybe figured it out. I myself was just starting a full game reread when I found out I was dead and the game was over. = (

Not saying I would have found it because FD and Ben didn't have much to make them seem town really either minus a couple spurts. But, you would really have to wonder why "confirmed town" sheep was in the final 3 and people were getting shot over him.

All results oriented thinking. Revisionists history.

You are just trying to argue to argue at this point.
---

I hope people enjoyed the game. Sorry for being late on some of these flips, since they came at unexpected times. I didn't know a lot of these flavors but learned about some of them because of it. Of note, I hadn't watched Futurama in like 18 years.
---

Ashethan posted...

I hope people enjoyed the game. Sorry for being late on some of these flips, since they came at unexpected times. I didn't know a lot of these flavors but learned about some of them because of it. Of note, I hadn't watched Futurama in like 18 years.

I had fun, was kind of surprised to be killed when I was.
---

Ashethan posted...

I hope people enjoyed the game. Sorry for being late on some of these flips, since they came at unexpected times. I didn't know a lot of these flavors but learned about some of them because of it. Of note, I hadn't watched Futurama in like 18 years.

I enjoyed the shit out of it... i would love to be town next time
---

Plum, I'm never going to think you arent playing me ever again.
---

Good game Ashe. Well enjoyed.
---

Damn. I didn't like sheep day 1 but got distracted by plum and it went on the back burner.

yeah, had we listened to me day one for a change...mind you I was barely there for the end of day.
---

Also if you are going to use mafia day vigi again you need tighter stipulations. Mafia using it towards an end of day where they are going to be lynched breaks the game. Town shouldn't be able to be hurt for attempting to lynch scum.

Leafeon13N posted...

Also if you are going to use mafia day vigi again you need tighter stipulations. Mafia using it towards an end of day where they are going to be lynched breaks the game. Town shouldn't be able to be hurt for attempting to lynch scum.

Using dayvig after the first 24 hours would have extended the day by 24 hours. It couldn't be used on day 1 either. And Jailkeeper could have kept it from being charged up. I've seen similar stipulations on a Scum DayVig before, which I based it upon.
---

My suggestion is that scum dayvig has to use ir in the first 3 day phases or they lose it.
---

Could always make it that DayVigs don't work if they are the lynch leader. (As either alignment) I suppose.
---

I appreciate the game ash!

I dont appreciate my own play this time, but thats not on anyone except myself >__>

Was telling the truth when I didnt know the game started

Im almost never on B8 except for mafia and B8NFL, and Im tagging those topics. Once I got here and theyre already about 1000 posts, I truthfully have struggled to get invested into the game. Thats 100% on me, and I do apologize for that, but I still think a beginning game tag would have saved me a lot of trouble.

As for replacing out, I would shoot them at least try never to do it. However, I just got laid out by the strep throat and it just sat every ounce of strength I had this weekend. So Im sorry for that as well, but then did a much better job than I did in this game
.
---

well dang :/

I felt like i did okay this game though. I had a good read on eaed being too chummy towards Rik and I felt like I played well enough in the moment of plum's claim. Not saying anyone else wouldn't have also pointed out plum's inconsistencies, but at the very least I didn't fall on my ass. Also I figured out who the mason was which was more than scum could say so nyah~

Town thief when scum doesn't have a flavor split is pretty damn useless tho :/ I know you said you didn't want it to be a 2nd cop, but when it's implemented like this it counts for .01 of a cop. Scum can see the lack of split and realize that there is no reason to even lie about their flavor. It would have been a different story if bender had actually been miller, but otherwise there is a potential universe where bender is one of the first flips (as vanilla) and suddenly any assholeish character can be town and the flavor cop is doing squat.

I can't really complain about dayvig either because 4 + an extra night kill is reasonable so we can just pretend that sheep shot twice the final night by saving the extra kill. It yields the same result.

.

.

.

MVP:
Rik
MZero
Sheep

or something like that.
---

If it had been a proper final 3 I'm not sure where I would have leaned. Ben struck me as very town in the immediate time after he had replaced in, but his argument(s) with Rik during the last day were making me question it. So I probably would have thrown it away even without that dayvig.
---

Corrik lost his card to call me scum so I'm less salty

But man guys such a bad lynch on me. Half was scum but red slept on it and corrik just messed up. I knew for sure plum and pirate were scum

Good game to scum, I love the holding out on the dayvig move

But pirate was so obvious that I wanted to counter claim him but I couldn't as cop :/
---

Also yeah mzero was obvious Mason as soon as day 2 started, the post fd cited and for sure the crumb

Also pj wal obvious protection as he was the one to agree with me that pirate was off
---

ScareChan posted...

But man guys such a bad lynch on me. Half was scum but red slept on it and corrik just messed up. I knew for sure plum and pirate were scum

My clock actually fell behind by over 2 minutes and didnt notice. I was trying to tabulate votals then saw a post timestamp and realized i goofed.

ScareChan posted...

Corrik lost his card to call me scum so I'm less salty

But man guys such a bad lynch on me. Half was scum but red slept on it and corrik just messed up. I knew for sure plum and pirate were scum

Good game to scum, I love the holding out on the dayvig move

But pirate was so obvious that I wanted to counter claim him but I couldn't as cop :/

I didn't realize u were not being as active due to power instead of scum
---

I *was* active. The rest of the game wasnt so I spent the day out with my wife instead and even then cheated on my time with her to pop in. It killed all the brownie points I built up with her lol.
---

I told you to go home
---

All I know is, I appreciate the Lucifer reps.
---

Well... that sucks way to go sheep. Very good job your claim right after mine made me rethink you a little but definitely not enough and holy hell corrik and sbell blah welp no 2 and 1 see you guys next game
---

well done Blade!

fun game to read.

I don't like the idea of "I can confirm the Mason by having you talk to him and answering questions that I've asked him outside of the game". I think there's a connection outside of the game that shouldn't exist.
---

Oh and I was still really bothered by the info that Pirate was providing to the game. mind you it was still to be taken with a grain of salt. But there was too much of scum screwing with this game. Between the vote and that.
---

Sheep was the player I suspected the least out of anyone after the Pirate lynch. I considered everyone else. Oh well good job sheep

And I didn't claim mason for obvious reasons. They obviously wanted to silence red so why would I reveal myself? I just did my best to pass on his thoughts. Like he said his first instinct after Day 1 was plum so I went back and read him, and that kind of got the ball rolling on that lynch.

Oh yeah and too many early hammers this game. We basically had 3 days of nothing to analyze, which made it a lot easier for Sheep to ride that early attempted hammer
---

Obellisk posted...

Oh and I was still really bothered by the info that Pirate was providing to the game. mind you it was still to be taken with a grain of salt. But there was too much of scum screwing with this game. Between the vote and that.

He didn't really give us anything of really note.
---

MZero11 posted...

Sheep was the player I suspected the least out of anyone after the Pirate lynch. I considered everyone else. Oh well good job sheep

And I didn't claim mason for obvious reasons. They obviously wanted to silence red so why would I reveal myself? I just did my best to pass on his thoughts. Like he said his first instinct after Day 1 was plum so I went back and read him, and that kind of got the ball rolling on that lynch.

Oh yeah and too many early hammers this game. We basically had 3 days of nothing to analyze, which made it a lot easier for Sheep to ride that early attempted hammer

No. Not enough early hammers.

When lynches are set everyone just afks and you just kill the morale of everyone who is active in the game. I was noticeably off at when you guys extended the one day for no reason.
---

Corrik posted...

Obellisk posted...

Oh and I was still really bothered by the info that Pirate was providing to the game. mind you it was still to be taken with a grain of salt. But there was too much of scum screwing with this game. Between the vote and that.

He didn't really give us anything of really note.

no I know, it was more the idea behind it.
---

And corrik, I don't know why I let you get under my skin this game. I would like to apologize to you. I let you set me off and then it just escalated and it was stupid.

I'm looking forward to our next game.
---

MZero11 posted...

Sheep was the player I suspected the least out of anyone after the Pirate lynch. I considered everyone else. Oh well good job sheep

And I didn't claim mason for obvious reasons. They obviously wanted to silence red so why would I reveal myself? I just did my best to pass on his thoughts. Like he said his first instinct after Day 1 was plum so I went back and read him, and that kind of got the ball rolling on that lynch.

Oh yeah and too many early hammers this game. We basically had 3 days of nothing to analyze, which made it a lot easier for Sheep to ride that early attempted hammer

If I ever make Board 8 Mafia Mafia, then one role would be Corrik, Independent Hammerer where he wins by ending a game day within 10 minutes

(Or to make it easier, when he gets to hammer)
---

Obellisk posted...

And corrik, I don't know why I let you get under my skin this game. I would like to apologize to you. I let you set me off and then it just escalated and it was stupid.

I'm looking forward to our next game.

I still don't even know why you got mad.
---

VeryInsane posted...

MZero11 posted...

Sheep was the player I suspected the least out of anyone after the Pirate lynch. I considered everyone else. Oh well good job sheep

And I didn't claim mason for obvious reasons. They obviously wanted to silence red so why would I reveal myself? I just did my best to pass on his thoughts. Like he said his first instinct after Day 1 was plum so I went back and read him, and that kind of got the ball rolling on that lynch.

Oh yeah and too many early hammers this game. We basically had 3 days of nothing to analyze, which made it a lot easier for Sheep to ride that early attempted hammer

If I ever make Board 8 Mafia Mafia, then one role would be Corrik, Independent Hammerer where he wins by ending a game day within 10 minutes

(Or to make it easier, when he gets to hammer)

#yolo
---

Corrik posted...

Obellisk posted...

And corrik, I don't know why I let you get under my skin this game. I would like to apologize to you. I let you set me off and then it just escalated and it was stupid.

I'm looking forward to our next game.

I still don't even know why you got mad.

I have no idea. we cool bro?
---

Obellisk posted...

Corrik posted...

Obellisk posted...

And corrik, I don't know why I let you get under my skin this game. I would like to apologize to you. I let you set me off and then it just escalated and it was stupid.

I'm looking forward to our next game.

I still don't even know why you got mad.

I have no idea. we cool bro?

Always
---

VeryInsane posted...

If I ever make Board 8 Mafia Mafia, then one role would be Corrik, Independent Hammerer where he wins by ending a game day within 10 minutes

I remember Leo running a game where people got powers when they hammered.

Which led to everyone freaking out when people hammered in the next game.
---

VeryInsane posted...

MZero11 posted...

Sheep was the player I suspected the least out of anyone after the Pirate lynch. I considered everyone else. Oh well good job sheep

And I didn't claim mason for obvious reasons. They obviously wanted to silence red so why would I reveal myself? I just did my best to pass on his thoughts. Like he said his first instinct after Day 1 was plum so I went back and read him, and that kind of got the ball rolling on that lynch.

Oh yeah and too many early hammers this game. We basically had 3 days of nothing to analyze, which made it a lot easier for Sheep to ride that early attempted hammer

If I ever make Board 8 Mafia Mafia, then one role would be Corrik, Independent Hammerer where he wins by ending a game day within 10 minutes

(Or to make it easier, when he gets to hammer)

You should make that game it would be fun.
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

VeryInsane posted...

MZero11 posted...

Sheep was the player I suspected the least out of anyone after the Pirate lynch. I considered everyone else. Oh well good job sheep

And I didn't claim mason for obvious reasons. They obviously wanted to silence red so why would I reveal myself? I just did my best to pass on his thoughts. Like he said his first instinct after Day 1 was plum so I went back and read him, and that kind of got the ball rolling on that lynch.

Oh yeah and too many early hammers this game. We basically had 3 days of nothing to analyze, which made it a lot easier for Sheep to ride that early attempted hammer

If I ever make Board 8 Mafia Mafia, then one role would be Corrik, Independent Hammerer where he wins by ending a game day within 10 minutes

(Or to make it easier, when he gets to hammer)

You should make that game it would be fun.

I agree... it might be a nice history lesson
---

Dammit. I didnt follow the ultimate rule of mafia AGAIN. The first person to call me Town is ALWAYS scum (Sheep). ):
---

neonreaper posted...

well done Blade!

fun game to read.

I don't like the idea of "I can confirm the Mason by having you talk to him and answering questions that I've asked him outside of the game". I think there's a connection outside of the game that shouldn't exist.

Blade?
---

Also pro tip guys

When you call a guy scum and he starts an AMA but says dont ask about who is on his team

He is scum
---

ScareChan posted...

neonreaper posted...

well done Blade!

fun game to read.

I don't like the idea of "I can confirm the Mason by having you talk to him and answering questions that I've asked him outside of the game". I think there's a connection outside of the game that shouldn't exist.

Blade?

oh I thought that's who that was, my bad, I'm old
---

Blade is Meow1000
---

I reviewed this setup and gave some insight which I think did ultimately result in better balance. Then I volunteered to help with votals and literally never read the game after that. >_> Sorry Ash, lol.

Seeing this game end with the dayvig kill was great. During my feedback I think I said something to the effect of mafia dayvig is so fun I don't want to balance it out of the game. So that's neat it ended that way.

I'd hand out some GGs but like I said I didn't read so /shrug