Poll of the Day > Has anyone read and watched "I Kill Giants?

(+) Yeah! (+)

I really liked the movie and want to get the comic book. Just wondering if the comic book is as good/better than the movie.
---

I didn't like the movie very much, but the comic isn't bad. The tones are completely different between the two. The movie makes no effort to be anything more than a poor man's A Monster Calls, while the book has a much more lighthearted, goofy sort of vibe.
---

Pus_N_Pecans posted...

I didn't like the movie very much, but the comic isn't bad. The tones are completely different between the two. The movie makes no effort to be anything more than a poor man's A Monster Calls, while the book has a much more lighthearted, goofy sort of vibe.

Well, I liked the movie, so our tastes are probably opposite. So if you liked the comic, I probably won't like it.
---

The comic was great...if a little hammy. Didn't know there was a movie, I don't see the story translating to film very well.

lihlih posted...

Well, I liked the movie, so our tastes are probably opposite. So if you liked the comic, I probably won't like it.

You should just watch A Monster Calls and call it a day. They're very similar, but A Monster Calls is much, much better.
---