Current Events > should statues of Andrew Jackson be taken down?

Topic List
Page List: 1
darkphoenix181
08/16/17 12:57:24 PM
#1:


should statues of Andrew Jackson be taken down?





http://www.latimes.com/opinion/readersreact/la-ol-le-andrew-jackson-new-orleans-20170501-story.html

https://www.wsj.com/articles/amid-toppled-confederate-statues-andrew-jackson-stands-tall-1490393581

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/entry/a-national-monument-is-not-a-statue-and-andrew-jackson_us_5909ff8de4b03b105b44be35

So should this be fair next?
---
sigless user is me or am I?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Damn_Underscore
08/16/17 1:00:49 PM
#2:


This is the slippery slope.

Now our own history is being trashed because it isn't up to modern progressive standards.
---
Shenmue II = best game of all time
Shenmue = 2nd best game of all time
... Copied to Clipboard!
darkphoenix181
08/16/17 1:01:52 PM
#3:


Damn_Underscore posted...
This is the slippery slope.

Now our own history is being trashed because it isn't up to modern progressive standards.


not necessarily

explain why you want Andrew to stay up other than slippery slope plz
---
sigless user is me or am I?
... Copied to Clipboard!
ToonLinkWithGun
08/16/17 1:04:24 PM
#4:


Take them all down.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
darkphoenix181
08/16/17 1:07:55 PM
#6:


ToonLinkWithGun posted...
Take them all down.


what do you mean by them?

all Andrew Jackson statues or all statues period?
---
sigless user is me or am I?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Damn_Underscore
08/16/17 1:08:49 PM
#7:


The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.
---
Shenmue II = best game of all time
Shenmue = 2nd best game of all time
... Copied to Clipboard!
hockeybub89
08/16/17 1:09:12 PM
#8:


... Copied to Clipboard!
NadYobWoc
08/16/17 1:10:06 PM
#9:


Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.
---
Cowboy Dan's a major player in the cowboy scene
... Copied to Clipboard!
nativengine
08/16/17 1:15:55 PM
#10:


Andrew Jackson did terrible, awful thing to my people. I wouldn't want to see his statues come down. Despite my personal feelings on the guy, he's a hero to a lot of Americans and I can accept that.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Damn_Underscore
08/16/17 1:25:40 PM
#11:


NadYobWoc posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.


Do you even know the history?

The Supreme Court said that the Indian Tribes who lived in Georgia would be allowed to keep their land. Andrew Jackson feared war between the Georgia militia and the Federal Government (who would defend the decision of the Court) + the Indian tribes, so he ignored the Supreme Court's decision and negotiated a deal with the Tribes by the Indian Removal Act, which was passed by Congress, to give them the land that is now Oklahoma.

Most people went to Oklahoma, but many refused to go and stayed in their home lands. Eventually there was a deadline for them to leave and everyone eventually left. But the people who left at the final deadline took the same paths as everyone else, so there was a lack of food & supplies and the paths were very crowded, which caused disease to spread.

That is the Trail of Tears. Andrew Jackson can be criticized for the situation, but not nearly as much as he is today by some people.
---
Shenmue II = best game of all time
Shenmue = 2nd best game of all time
... Copied to Clipboard!
eston
08/16/17 1:26:44 PM
#12:


... Copied to Clipboard!
NadYobWoc
08/16/17 2:09:04 PM
#13:


Damn_Underscore posted...
NadYobWoc posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.


Do you even know the history?

The Supreme Court said that the Indian Tribes who lived in Georgia would be allowed to keep their land. Andrew Jackson feared war between the Georgia militia and the Federal Government (who would defend the decision of the Court) + the Indian tribes, so he ignored the Supreme Court's decision and negotiated a deal with the Tribes by the Indian Removal Act, which was passed by Congress, to give them the land that is now Oklahoma.

Most people went to Oklahoma, but many refused to go and stayed in their home lands. Eventually there was a deadline for them to leave and everyone eventually left. But the people who left at the final deadline took the same paths as everyone else, so there was a lack of food & supplies and the paths were very crowded, which caused disease to spread.

That is the Trail of Tears. Andrew Jackson can be criticized for the situation, but not nearly as much as he is today by some people.

wow
---
Cowboy Dan's a major player in the cowboy scene
... Copied to Clipboard!
Damn_Underscore
08/16/17 2:12:51 PM
#14:


What does wow mean?
---
Shenmue II = best game of all time
Shenmue = 2nd best game of all time
... Copied to Clipboard!
HypnoCoosh
08/16/17 2:13:16 PM
#15:


I hope they keep pushing this agenda. Just keep on pushing guys I swear everything is gonna be alright.
---
We make men without chests and expect from them virtue and enterprise. We laugh at honor and are shocked to find traitors in our midst. - C.S. Lewis
... Copied to Clipboard!
Vyrulisse
08/16/17 2:13:47 PM
#16:


Damn_Underscore posted...
What does wow mean?

History is offensive apparently.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
NadYobWoc
08/16/17 2:16:42 PM
#17:


Vyrulisse posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
What does wow mean?

History is offensive apparently.

It's dumb to justify and defend someone who contributed to genocide.
---
Cowboy Dan's a major player in the cowboy scene
... Copied to Clipboard!
Philoktetes
08/16/17 2:17:32 PM
#18:


it wasn't genocide it was relocation

it was a sad tragedy so many indians died on the trail of tears but that wasn't the goal
---
I don't think so, Tim.
~~ Pizza Crew ~~
... Copied to Clipboard!
NadYobWoc
08/16/17 2:19:11 PM
#19:


Philoktetes posted...
it wasn't genocide it was relocation

it was a sad tragedy so many indians died on the trail of tears but that wasn't the goal

The relocation was part of the larger genocide.
---
Cowboy Dan's a major player in the cowboy scene
... Copied to Clipboard!
lilORANG
08/16/17 2:19:22 PM
#20:


No. He's a president
---
Mars ain't the kind of place to raise your kids.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Scorsese2002
08/16/17 2:20:17 PM
#21:


All statues should be taken down, cause that's the trend.
---
R.I.P. GameFAQs Throwback Mode
... Copied to Clipboard!
Garioshi
08/16/17 2:20:43 PM
#22:


The only good thing that Andrew Jackson has ever done is win the Battle of New Orleans. Literally everything else he's done is a stain on America's record.
---
"The only things I can trust right now are myself and this big gun." - Eric from Zero Time Dilemma
http://steamcommunity.com/id/Garioshi/wishlist
... Copied to Clipboard!
ZombiePelican
08/16/17 2:23:59 PM
#23:


Garioshi posted...
The only good thing that Andrew Jackson has ever done is win the Battle of New Orleans. Literally everything else he's done is a stain on America's record.

This what regressive lefties actually believe
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
ChromaticAngel
08/16/17 2:25:05 PM
#24:


Garioshi posted...
The only good thing that Andrew Jackson has ever done is win the Battle of New Orleans. Literally everything else he's done is a stain on America's record.


This is bullshit and you know it.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Dondre_X
08/16/17 2:27:25 PM
#25:


Philoktetes posted...
it wasn't genocide it was relocation

it was a sad tragedy so many indians died on the trail of tears but that wasn't the goal


According to my Family history, if they refused to leave they were murdered.
---
Dondre......
FC:0104-4075-8605 IGN Donnell
... Copied to Clipboard!
Philoktetes
08/16/17 2:28:22 PM
#27:


then they shouldn't have refused to leave?
---
I don't think so, Tim.
~~ Pizza Crew ~~
... Copied to Clipboard!
glitteringfairy
08/16/17 2:28:34 PM
#28:


I live less than two miles from the Hermitage. Come at me bros
---
"How come you can believe in God but not Bigfoot?" V-E-G-Y http://i.imgur.com/AqR3aeX.jpg http://i.imgur.com/vvuUXpp.jpg
... Copied to Clipboard!
Duncanwii
08/16/17 2:28:53 PM
#29:


So no one notes the fact that he ignored the Supreme Court? You don't do that. Genocide or not he deserved to be impeached for that alone.
---
This is my year of Pokemon!
Pokemon games I'm playing: Platinum and Black 2.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Garioshi
08/16/17 2:33:54 PM
#31:


Damn_Underscore posted...
Absolutely the Trail of Tears is a terrible tragedy, as is the way this country treated Native Americans in general.

But to act like Andrew Jackson killed these people is wrong and dishonest.

Absolutely the Holocaust is a terrible tragedy, as is the way Germany treated Jews in general.

But to act like Adolf Hitler killed these people is wrong and dishonest.



Do you see how ridiculous you sound?
---
"The only things I can trust right now are myself and this big gun." - Eric from Zero Time Dilemma
http://steamcommunity.com/id/Garioshi/wishlist
... Copied to Clipboard!
Damn_Underscore
08/16/17 2:36:29 PM
#33:


Accidentally deleted that post above: Here it is:

Absolutely the Trail of Tears is a terrible tragedy, as is the way this country treated Native Americans in general.

But to act like Andrew Jackson killed these people is wrong and dishonest.

-

And to respond to Garioshi, you are being dishonest. Please stop it. Read my post earlier ITT if you want a basic idea of the history of the Trail of Tears.
---
Shenmue II = best game of all time
Shenmue = 2nd best game of all time
... Copied to Clipboard!
ChromaticAngel
08/16/17 2:45:45 PM
#34:


Garioshi posted...
Absolutely the Holocaust is a terrible tragedy, as is the way Germany treated Jews in general.

But to act like Adolf Hitler killed these people is wrong and dishonest.


Hitler relocated Jews to slave camps where they were forced to work to support the war effort of the country that enslaved them. Jackson relocated Cherokees to federally reserved land and generally didn't bother them once they got there.

Hitler built an army and encouraged that army to kill Jews. Jackson did nothing, people found gold on the Cherokee land and formed independent militia to exterminate them on their own. In theory, Jackson could have turned the US military on the militia that was going to murder all the cherokees, but we'd likely be having a very different conversation about why Jackson was a horrible president today if he did.

Hitler butchered his own people. The Cherokee nation was not part of the USA. It was native land that was conquered like the rest of America under any other president.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
LittleRoyal
08/16/17 2:49:09 PM
#35:


NadYobWoc posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.


It was very bad but not genocide and yes is sad and monstrous but literally we wouldn't be here if he didn't do that
---
I-I really needed this~~
Time to stomp some faces!!!
... Copied to Clipboard!
NadYobWoc
08/16/17 3:05:12 PM
#36:


LittleRoyal posted...
NadYobWoc posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.


It was very bad but not genocide and yes is sad and monstrous but literally we wouldn't be here if he didn't do that

It was genocide, and "we wouldn't be here" is a horrible justification.

Also, I should clarify that I'm not saying Andrew Jackson personally committed genocide. He contributed to something that was going on before and after him.
---
Cowboy Dan's a major player in the cowboy scene
... Copied to Clipboard!
LittleRoyal
08/16/17 3:10:21 PM
#37:


NadYobWoc posted...
LittleRoyal posted...
NadYobWoc posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.


It was very bad but not genocide and yes is sad and monstrous but literally we wouldn't be here if he didn't do that

It was genocide, and "we wouldn't be here" is a horrible justification.

Also, I should clarify that I'm not saying Andrew Jackson personally committed genocide. He contributed to something that was going on before and after him.


I'm not saying his actions are okay, but in saying they were a vital part of our history and as far as we go as a country, yeah we may be better off with it.

Sad as it is just think for a minute.
---
I-I really needed this~~
Time to stomp some faces!!!
... Copied to Clipboard!
NadYobWoc
08/16/17 5:40:51 PM
#38:


LittleRoyal posted...
NadYobWoc posted...
LittleRoyal posted...
NadYobWoc posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.


It was very bad but not genocide and yes is sad and monstrous but literally we wouldn't be here if he didn't do that

It was genocide, and "we wouldn't be here" is a horrible justification.

Also, I should clarify that I'm not saying Andrew Jackson personally committed genocide. He contributed to something that was going on before and after him.


I'm not saying his actions are okay, but in saying they were a vital part of our history and as far as we go as a country, yeah we may be better off with it.

Sad as it is just think for a minute.

lol shut the fuck up
---
Cowboy Dan's a major player in the cowboy scene
... Copied to Clipboard!
nativengine
08/16/17 5:44:12 PM
#39:


LittleRoyal posted...
NadYobWoc posted...
LittleRoyal posted...
NadYobWoc posted...
Damn_Underscore posted...
The only thing you could criticize Andrew Jackson for as president is the Indian Removal situation, and that was a lose-lose situation.

He was a war hero and did many great things as president.

The one article mentions that he was a slave-owner... so were most of the Founding Fathers.

"Indian removal situation"

That's an interesting was to say genocide.


It was very bad but not genocide and yes is sad and monstrous but literally we wouldn't be here if he didn't do that

It was genocide, and "we wouldn't be here" is a horrible justification.

Also, I should clarify that I'm not saying Andrew Jackson personally committed genocide. He contributed to something that was going on before and after him.


I'm not saying his actions are okay, but in saying they were a vital part of our history and as far as we go as a country, yeah we may be better off with it.

Sad as it is just think for a minute.


Do you have any idea how bad life on most reservations is to this day? Did you know I have to file to stay Native American every 4 years? That's right, we expire being Indians.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1