Board 8 > A Feast For Crows Mafia: Topic 3 - Winter Friends Are Friends Forever

(+) Yeah! (+)

##unvote
##vote:puns

I liked his vote least.
---

If anyone saw who deleted, please PM me immediately.
---

no worries
it was Mzero
---

[2] MysteriousStan: Han, (dowolf), (Jeff Zero), puns, (Leo), (death)
[2] puns: Shad, Stan
[1] Nana: (Chris), (KBM), (MI), KBM, (Stan)
[1] Chris: (puns), (Scare), Nana
[1] Leo: Chris, (MI)
[1] Death: VI
[1] FFD: red
[0] Scare: (Leo), (Stan), (puns), (Death)
[0] dowolf: (Chris), (MI), (Leo)
[0] Boko: (MI), (KBM)
[0] VI: (Chris)
[0] red: (VI), (KBM)
[0] MI: (puns)
[0] Jeff: (Nana)

With 17 alive it takes 9 to lynch. Day ends at 9 PM CST tonight, a little less than 3 hours from now.

(note to Suprak - deleted post was me, sorry!)
---

you know you can just edit posts right, Mzero?
you're not in the game

anyway I am tempted to just vote FFD, but that'd lead to the same uncertainty as voting Scare
on the other hand, that goes for everyone
---

fuck it

feel more life from Puns (and Nana) than FFD

##Vote: FFD
---

fuck dude

##Unvote

I doubt any scum throws out Ninja Cop. that would be a last minute scenario hail mary play where you're a one shot mafia power.

What on earth made you think that a scare claim was something you'd need to immediately be aware of?
---

##Vote: Han

This guy is next.
---

Stan would you say you are bad at hiding when you're power?
---

are you thinking Han saw an easy lynch in Stan, Puns?
---

##Unvote

this also kills my theory that dowolf could have been a scumpowered lynch to save Stan
---

Um I was voting for Scare and he was the vote leader? Not that hard to imagine that would be priority info to know.
---

htaeD posted...

are you thinking Han saw an easy lynch in Stan, Puns?

it's in line with his suspicion of me which I feel was pretty fake and also uncharacteristic of him when I'm town. our personalities tend to mesh very well.

so back to my previous list which was Scare/Han/dowolf/red

of them I think Han's lynch is the juciest based on player content. plus he's one of only a few who haven't been voted yet. and his suspicions are all pretty lame thus far honestly, moreso now given stan's claim.
---

bng_mmmk posted...

I doubt any scum throws out Ninja Cop. that would be a last minute scenario hail mary play where you're a one shot mafia power.

What on earth made you think that a scare claim was something you'd need to immediately be aware of?

also you didnt ask this sooner?
---

Oh well that's a thing too come back to after work. Can we lynch puns now that he wants to lynch the guy who started the lynch he was just on?
---

I thought the same thing
but I like my vote more on FFD for tonight
anyone have any last questions for me? MI?
, gotta work in the morning and all
---

htaeD posted...

Stan would you say you are bad at hiding when you're power?

Hard to say cause I usually only roll scum power. Also I haven't played in awhile so I don't remember how much I've been pressured as power (minus scanner cause it's become a pattern now) vs being vanilla.
---

Three separate votes within 10 posts of one-another. The fallout is real. We need solidarity.

puns, what do you think of what Shad just said about you?
---

Shaduln posted...

Oh well that's a thing too come back to after work. Can we lynch puns now that he wants to lynch the guy who started the lynch he was just on?

forgive me for asking, but I was curious where you were lately
busy at work?
---

oh poor innocent Jeff
you have yet to live through a b8 special
---

htaeD posted...

bng_mmmk posted...

I doubt any scum throws out Ninja Cop. that would be a last minute scenario hail mary play where you're a one shot mafia power.

What on earth made you think that a scare claim was something you'd need to immediately be aware of?

also you didnt ask this sooner?

It was in my mind but I've just gotten home from work and prior to that was posting from my phone whenever I could sneak it in
---

MysteriousStan posted...

htaeD posted...

Stan would you say you are bad at hiding when you're power?

Hard to say cause I usually only roll scum power. Also I haven't played in awhile so I don't remember how much I've been pressured as power (minus scanner cause it's become a pattern now) vs being vanilla.

then its probably not likely that scum read you as townpower and tried to force you to claim sooner, thats mostly why I was asking
---

htaeD posted...

you have yet to live through a b8 special

Gods willing, I shall one day be alive to experience it firsthand!
---

but we should avoid that most of the time
---

Sorry, I'm multi-tasking at the moment but it's clear that the Nana lynch just isn't going to go anywhere today. My full attention will be back on this in a bit, but I'll be able to keep up with what's happening.

htaeD posted...

Shaduln posted...

Oh well that's a thing too come back to after work. Can we lynch puns now that he wants to lynch the guy who started the lynch he was just on?

forgive me for asking, but I was curious where you were lately
busy at work?

Yep, at work I won't be able to post much.
---

everyone works

on that note, have to jet
---

I still think Han and JZ are town. The others on my lynch I'm not as sure about.
---

Jeff Zero posted...

Three separate votes within 10 posts of one-another. The fallout is real. We need solidarity.

puns, what do you think of what Shad just said about you?

Shaduln posted...

Oh well that's a thing too come back to after work. Can we lynch puns now that he wants to lynch the guy who started the lynch he was just on?

Day one is the point in the game where there's the least information out, so acting like someone starting a lynch I supported makes them automatically town to me is bad and Shad should know better.
---

##Unvote: Stan

I don't buy it but it will sort itself out.



##Vote: puns


bng_mmmk posted...

it's in line with his suspicion of me which I feel was pretty fake and also uncharacteristic of him when I'm town. our personalities tend to mesh very well.

This is so incredibly ass-backwards. We've never gelled as players. I usually write you off because you're off on some tangent which makes me think you're Town or you're not which makes me think you're Scum.


Like, there are so many factors here.

"puns jokes more as Town" check
"puns was quick to defend Jeff" check
"puns had fluff complaining about the flavor" check

Which one of those is fake, huh?
---

bng_mmmk posted...

Jeff Zero posted...

Three separate votes within 10 posts of one-another. The fallout is real. We need solidarity.

puns, what do you think of what Shad just said about you?

Shaduln posted...

Oh well that's a thing too come back to after work. Can we lynch puns now that he wants to lynch the guy who started the lynch he was just on?

Day one is the point in the game where there's the least information out, so acting like someone starting a lynch I supported makes them automatically town to me is bad and Shad should know better.

furthermore given I've already been calling Han scum today.
---

bng_mmmk posted...

Jeff Zero posted...

Three separate votes within 10 posts of one-another. The fallout is real. We need solidarity.

puns, what do you think of what Shad just said about you?

Shaduln posted...

Oh well that's a thing too come back to after work. Can we lynch puns now that he wants to lynch the guy who started the lynch he was just on?

Day one is the point in the game where there's the least information out, so acting like someone starting a lynch I supported makes them automatically town to me is bad and Shad should know better.

I wouldn't follow onto a lynch started by anyone that was on my scumlist.
---

Shaduln posted...

I wouldn't follow onto a lynch started by anyone that was on my scumlist.

Have you ever voted a scum buddy on day 1?

jw
---

Votes on Stan,

Han votes, followed up by:
HanOfTheNekos posted...

MysteriousStan posted...

I feel like I've been transported back to the early 2010's looking at that list.

How's everyone doing? Playing Persona 5 right now myself. It's p. great.

This was Stan's first post.

Just feels so fake. "Hey guys, I'm here. Look at me."

Then when he finally returns it's some weird go on Scare which, tbh, the timing with Leo made look worse but isn't the lynchpin on this.

dowolf posted...

hmm. stan comments seem interesting. What have i written about Stan so far?

dowolf posted...

this conversation feels off to me.

is one of [Stan and Jeff] scum?

you can tell me. I promise I won't hurt you if you do.

you know what, past me? You were on to something.

##Vote: Stan

(Since writing that, I have finished catching up and seen people comment on me not voting, which is funny in hindsight.

Jeff Zero posted...

Sure, happily! While I'm not defending Scare either way (it seems the basis people are forming for him being possible scum is largely mired in habits in the meta, which I'm unfamiliar with) I never got a great read on Leo voting him and then Stan voted him almost immediately thereafter. As I've stated in the past, this has looked fishy to me from square one.

I suspect them both, but there's more heat on Stan -- which means more people have called him on it with a wider host of reasons to do so. Given the interim time since I first made mention that they're possible scum, and given that I've found Leo's rebuttals better than Stan's, I've decided to vote Stan.

---

Leo3L posted...

In the interest of having an actual cohesive lynch going into end game of the day,

##Unvote

##Vote: Stan

Please claim.

htaeD posted...

red13n posted...

htaeD posted...

red would you say Stan was an easy target in the past?

Easy target, sure. Do I keep records of how many times people actually get lynched? No.

you have better records than me still

and I made my decision

##Vote: Stan

---

bng_mmmk posted...

Shaduln posted...

I wouldn't follow onto a lynch started by anyone that was on my scumlist.

Have you ever voted a scum buddy on day 1?

jw

Sure but I don't think I've ever tried to full on lead a lynch.
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

##Unvote: Stan

I don't buy it but it will sort itself out.



##Vote: puns


bng_mmmk posted...

it's in line with his suspicion of me which I feel was pretty fake and also uncharacteristic of him when I'm town. our personalities tend to mesh very well.

This is so incredibly ass-backwards. We've never gelled as players. I usually write you off because you're off on some tangent which makes me think you're Town or you're not which makes me think you're Scum.


Like, there are so many factors here.

"puns jokes more as Town" check
"puns was quick to defend Jeff" check
"puns had fluff complaining about the flavor" check

Which one of those is fake, huh?

Really?

You don't buy the Ninja Cop claim?

Really?


For the parts about me, I've always felt like you understood my perspective when we've been town. Maybe it's one sided, but still. You can't actually articulate reasons why those points make me scum. You've just run out of rope on the Stan lynch and are now pointing at me because I was your backup which you started setting up from like your first post before revealing your Guaranteed Scum Read who actually turned out to be a cop.


My favorite though is the one about Jeff. Why can't I read him as town?
---

puns, I don't even understand your supposed suspicion of me beyond "Han is suspicious of me, oh no!"

Like, you've flopped on it so many times at this point.

"Feels like Han is piggybacking Shaduln" when I said you were on my list before Shad posted once.


Shaduln posted...

bng_mmmk posted...

Shaduln posted...

I wouldn't follow onto a lynch started by anyone that was on my scumlist.

Have you ever voted a scum buddy on day 1?

jw

Sure but I don't think I've ever tried to full on lead a lynch.

Congrats, you're in that position now.
Take the wheel and drive.
---

@dowolf - Do you now think that Jeff is scum or do you think 'past you' was wrong when he thought one of Jeff/Stan were scum?
---

bng_mmmk posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

##Unvote: Stan

I don't buy it but it will sort itself out.



##Vote: puns


bng_mmmk posted...

it's in line with his suspicion of me which I feel was pretty fake and also uncharacteristic of him when I'm town. our personalities tend to mesh very well.

This is so incredibly ass-backwards. We've never gelled as players. I usually write you off because you're off on some tangent which makes me think you're Town or you're not which makes me think you're Scum.


Like, there are so many factors here.

"puns jokes more as Town" check
"puns was quick to defend Jeff" check
"puns had fluff complaining about the flavor" check

Which one of those is fake, huh?

Really?

You don't buy the Ninja Cop claim?

Really?

Uh, duh? I don't think he's Town. I'm not going to magically flip my mind because he claimed a power role.

My favorite though is the one about Jeff. Why can't I read him as town?

Because he had done mostly nothing, DID seem Scummy at first, and you immediately jumped to his defense against Nana.
---

I was actually just wondering about that, myself.
---

Need to find if Leo had suspicions on him or was just voting for the claim.

I think Leo wanting a claim is pretty independent of his alignment though.
---

My Immortal posted...

@dowolf - Do you now think that Jeff is scum or do you think 'past you' was wrong when he thought one of Jeff/Stan were scum?

haven't fully caught up yet but:

i still like my argument there.

i don't want to vote jeff just now, though.

i leave taking those two statements to their logical conclusion to the reader.
---

I can see scum claiming cop to try to survive a night OR get the real cop to counter-claim.

But adding the ninja modifier seems too bizarre. especially for someone who hasn't been in the game for so long.
---

Looks like even as Leo's vote was on him, he was still really pushing for a dowolf lynch.
---

My Immortal posted...

Need to find if Leo had suspicions on him or was just voting for the claim.

I think Leo wanting a claim is pretty independent of his alignment though.

Just the claim.

¯\_(ツ)_/¯
---

My Immortal posted...

I can see scum claiming cop to try to survive a night OR get the real cop to counter-claim.

But adding the ninja modifier seems too bizarre. especially for someone who hasn't been in the game for so long.

If he actually is scum ninja though...

Still not a risk worth taking but the ninja modifier is not a reason.

HanOfTheNekos posted...

puns, I don't even understand your supposed suspicion of me beyond "Han is suspicious of me, oh no!"

Like, you've flopped on it so many times at this point.

"Feels like Han is piggybacking Shaduln" when I said you were on my list before Shad posted once.

I'm not someone like Chris who parades around the Internet playing in every community. My mafia experience is 98% based right here on this site. My reads and decisions aren't based in some greater mafia theory that's kept sacred in some musty tome in an archive somewhere. I've gotten to know the players and how I fit in among them. And at some point after like 5 years managed to figure out how to read newbies to an extent.

Your vibe re: me is off and that's all I need to know you're likely scum.

And re: piggybacking Shad I literally said that's not what you're doing earlier in the topic but the point was you gave him the nod for suspecting me without actually doing anything to support it at the time.
---

please move here

https://www.gamefaqs.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/75451841
---