Board 8 > turbopuns mafia topic 6 no puns intended

(+) Yeah! (+)

Player list

1. Sceptile
2. Nana
3. Ulti
4. GranAures
5. death
6. eaedwards6400
7. benjamin3740
8. DoomTheGyarados
9. Brohan
10. MZero

ded

[MKD1] pjbasis, TOWN Prostitute
[LD1] Leafeon13N, TOWN Serial Hider (1-use)
[LD2] Terra-enforcer, TOWN Untargetable (1-time) + Psychic + Princess
[KN2] VI, TOWN Miller + Serial 1-use Unblockable Universal Lightning Rod + Vengeful Gambler + x-use Enabler + Forensic Investigator/Detective/Doublevoter/Paralyzer Enabler
[KN3] Meta_Knight123, TOWN Backup Strongman (1-use)

Day 4 ends at 9pm eastern today
---

gat
---

K
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

For Ben to be town, Chris has to be scum. That is the real conclusion you should be coming to.

I would feel okay with this. This would also mean Chris survived another night which would be extremely surprising to me.

I'm confused what you feel okay about. Chris being scum? We probably lose if he is.

If Ben flips town, I am okay with a Chris lynch.

The game will have ended.

You're certain about the size of the enemy team?
---

We'd still have a decent chance if I could be sacrificed and the game could continue. If only PJ wasnt modkilled ):
---

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

For Ben to be town, Chris has to be scum. That is the real conclusion you should be coming to.

I would feel okay with this. This would also mean Chris survived another night which would be extremely surprising to me.

I'm confused what you feel okay about. Chris being scum? We probably lose if he is.

If Ben flips town, I am okay with a Chris lynch.

The game will have ended.

You're certain about the size of the enemy team?

Not 100%, but no sign of Indies makes 11/4 an extremely plausible guess. Would not really hope for better.

Nana, are you saying that because I didn't reveal my scan but said I had info, Chris confirms himself psychic by claiming without knowing for sure if I scanned him? I agree Chris is probably psychic.
---

That said, it's not like he can do anything about a scan on him unless he claims to have been Millerized like Ulti did. So no real harm to assume I didn't scan him.
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

eaedwards6400 posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

For Ben to be town, Chris has to be scum. That is the real conclusion you should be coming to.

I would feel okay with this. This would also mean Chris survived another night which would be extremely surprising to me.

I'm confused what you feel okay about. Chris being scum? We probably lose if he is.

If Ben flips town, I am okay with a Chris lynch.

The game will have ended.

You're certain about the size of the enemy team?

Not 100%, but no sign of Indies makes 11/4 an extremely plausible guess. Would not really hope for better.

Nana, are you saying that because I didn't reveal my scan but said I had info, Chris confirms himself psychic by claiming without knowing for sure if I scanned him? I agree Chris is probably psychic.

Yes.
---

tag
---

back
movie not as bad as I predicted

glad to see discussion is still ongoing
time to continue reading
---

My Immortal posted...

tag

also poor MI

so town
he died before the game ever began
---

rest of day2 was lackluster for Brohan, but he did leave his vote on Mzero in the end

leafeon [6] - (Doom), (MetaKnight), Doom, Sceptile, death, (eaed), MetaKnight, mzero, Gran
MZero [4] - Brohan, (Terra), pjbasis, Terra, eaed
death [1] - (Sceptile), (VI), (Doom), (ben), (Gran), ben, (eaed)
pjbasis [1] - (Nana), (Terra), Ulti, (Ben)
Gran [1] - Leafeon
eaed [1] - (Terra), (death), (Terra), (ben), (mzero), Nana, (death)
Doom [0] - (Sceptile), (death), VI
Sceptile [0] - (Nana), (Gran), (MetaKnight)
Ben [0] - (eaed), (Sceptile), (eaed)
Terra [0] - (MZero)
Nana [0] - (eaed), (Doom), (Doom), (eaed)
Ulti [0] - (VI), (Brohan), (MZero)
MetaKnight [0] - (eaed), (Gran)
Brohan [0] - (Terra), (MZero), (MetaKnight)
VI [0] - (eaed)

Granted he may not have known Mzero was a candidate for a lynch when he left, but it still says a lot
on the flipside, I notice Bens vote
though its not as bad as I was also a major lynchcandidate and that stopped fast
still feels unpleasant to see Ben not just pick a side from the final two trains..
---

day2 Brohan becomes the leading lynch for a while
Mzero is one of the major forces against him, while Sceptile was against it
probably doesnt say much if sceptile decided to scan Brohan, buts its interesting to see the roles reversed
Gran looks worse for abandoning the lynch quickly

then Terra makes his claim and Chris counters that and pretty much everyone abandons the Brohan lynch, though at this point its hard to blame anyone but Terra

...so in the end not that much to gain from Brohan, since he never bloody posts

also where is everyone?
---

I am around and contemplating just getting a move on with this lynch. I still believe that lynching Ben is the correct move.
---

well at this point I am thinking they are both scum, so I am prepared to put my vote down
but yeah, like I said, we shouldnt wait til the last second
---

I am home from work, long day.

Death! I see you have seen the obvious.
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

I am around and contemplating just getting a move on with this lynch. I still believe that lynching Ben is the correct move.

I agree but no need to rush things.
---

I didnt want to kill Red or Mzero. That's why i didnt vote for one
---

##Vote: Ben

Despite my natural paranoia, the game does not make sense to me with Ben telling the truth.
---

either that or I am being played
(by you, or Mzero or even sceptile)
but I am not going to let paranoia get to me and will take responsibility
---

SCUMHAMMER

j/k
---

UItimaterializer posted...

Sceptilesolar posted...

I am around and contemplating just getting a move on with this lynch. I still believe that lynching Ben is the correct move.

I agree but no need to rush things.

I mean, it's only three hours in advance, and I am not too interested in continuing this.
---

I enjoy the fact that you said j/k even though you placed no vote.
---

I probably will vote in a few minutes though, need to go to work tomorrow

if that is allright with you two (and anyone else watching but not talking)
---

I am pooped, no problem with me.
---

you still want to talk, Ulti?
or do you have some final instructions?
---

Just dont blame me when this is over. You're killing me because I was seen jailing Chris. I've said all i can to defend myself.

Right now Chris is trying to lead everyone on me because it wins him the game. There is NO reason you should be killing me over Brohan.

Final Scum team prediction - Brohan, Chris, Mzero, ... (Ulti or Nana. Depends on what scum roles flip)
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Just dont blame me when this is over. You're killing me because I was seen jailing Chris. I've said all i can to defend myself.

Right now Chris is trying to lead everyone on me because it wins him the game. There is NO reason you should be killing me over Brohan.

Final Scum team prediction - Brohan, Chris, Mzero, ... (Ulti or Nana. Depends on what scum roles flip)

You kill the mafia roleblocker over the mafia ___ because the great sir chris (your words btw) wants another scan from his scanner.
---

Lol and Chris has led the lynch every day. When has he been right? Never. He;s either bad or scum, and it's obvious he;s not bad so. You guys are being fooled
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Just dont blame me when this is over. You're killing me because I was seen jailing Chris. I've said all i can to defend myself.

Right now Chris is trying to lead everyone on me because it wins him the game. There is NO reason you should be killing me over Brohan.

Final Scum team prediction - Brohan, Chris, Mzero, ... (Ulti or Nana. Depends on what scum roles flip)

You kill the mafia roleblocker over the mafia ___ because the great sir chris (your words btw) wants another scan from his scanner.

I'm the mafia roleblocker. Right now youre killing me over confirmed scum and it's very possibly LYLO
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Just dont blame me when this is over. You're killing me because I was seen jailing Chris. I've said all i can to defend myself.

Right now Chris is trying to lead everyone on me because it wins him the game. There is NO reason you should be killing me over Brohan.

Final Scum team prediction - Brohan, Chris, Mzero, ... (Ulti or Nana. Depends on what scum roles flip)

....you kill the blocker before any other role so the scanners can go nuts. Derp.
---

*I;m not the mafia roleblocker

(Inb4 Ulti - "PERESPECTIVE SLIP!!!!11")
---

If you're not the mafia roleblocker I fully admit town is fucked. You were seen targeting the doctor night 2 and then poor VI died. If you're not the mafia roleblocker you fucked up hard.

But thankfully nothing about this game makes sense with you as town, so that helps.
---

I mean if it was JUST the target maybe this could be discussed. But we've got another claimed roleblocker and way, way way too much protection in this game as it is.

I will never mock someone who didn't roll over as scum. props for fighting.
---

yeah I think I will be voting soon
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

nothing about this game makes sense

---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

If you're not the mafia roleblocker I fully admit town is fucked. You were seen targeting the doctor night 2 and then poor VI died. If you're not the mafia roleblocker you fucked up hard.

But thankfully nothing about this game makes sense with you as town, so that helps.

Well if that move lost me the game then that was on bad luck more than it was on me. Especially since, if there was a mafia roleblocker, you'd have been blocked anyway. Protecting you was the way to go, 100%.

For fun, who would you have targeted?
---

I'd say thats a good quote to end the day on

and I apologize in advance if it turns out I was wrong, Ben
but you did too many things, small and big, to make me think of you as town

##Vote: Ben

thats a

STOP
---

Mafia Wins.

Let's hear the criticism. I know it's coming!

Quick "I'm at work on my phone" host notes:

-the Hider PM specified it wasn't an alignment check, but he got lynched D1 without claiming. That caused some funky scanning/setup misperceptions. Oops.

-town lost an extra mislynch (not to mention a prosty) with the modkill. Sucks.

-Brohan literally did not post once for, like, 60 in-game hours, and he was scanned guilty.

-I strongly considered just modkilling brohan without warning (but didn't, obviously). wasn't going to ask someone to replace into that spot but frankly town didn't earn me throwing them a bone when they chose not to lynch him

-Mafia had a safe list of roles. Some people will probably disagree with it and that's fine.

-The point was to judge people based on their play and not their role, which some town did exceptionally well (Ben's confirmed town list was 100% accurate) but ended up lynching based on claims anyway

-just wanted to do something different and watch it play out for my own sick pleasure. I had a lot of fun!
---

chris was scum right?
---

Not canon so whatever
---

Of course Chris was scum.
---

woo flawless victory

sorry Ben, you had me pegged all along.. damn Chrono Cross muscle memory

townme would never have gone for the unsafe lynch in Ben and would have tried to convince more people to vote Brohan

or heck, go for a nolynch since we were at even numbers
---

Dude you were so obvious that game, literally killed someone that claimed doctor when you'd never do that as town, not to mention you killed the guy that was claimed psychic when you're back up psychic. It was beautifully played but my god how did noone see it.
---

Chris, Ulti, me, Brohan

it wasnt very fair
---

Chris didn't even need to be psychic to intuit who blocked him.

Did Ulti mess up claiming blocked night 2 like I assumed or was that some secret MASTER PLAN (tm)?
---

Notes:

1) The red lynch was basically a revenge lynch for FF7 mafia. He had it coming, 7 years later.
2) I was Mafia Doctor, Backup Psychic. I used this role extremely well I think!
3) It was adorable when people thought displays of emotion were a town tell. It's okay new players, you will learn quickly that I am the definition of cold blooded as scum. Most ruthless player you will ever see.

Other notes:

In theory lynching the mafia roleblocker is always the right move there. Weird setup though that town shouldn't have meta'd so hard though, but I wasn't going to stop town from doing it. You will see me, as town, go in the same avenue though unless its weighted a bit differently.

Ben played a very good game, but as soon as I saw him target me night 2 I knew we had this won.
---

The confirmed town list is always 100% accurate :( (Except when Corrik is on it)

And ahhh, a safelist of roles. I kind of feel like maybe Town should have been told that. Given we know about mafia having a safelist of flavor, it would be the same thing. Not knowing though causes all kinds of shenanigans, which was the point of the game I;m sure.

I never complain about setups, so i hve nothing to say here. Except that all the people metaing roles still on day 3 were either stubborn or mafia
---

God, it was Chris and Ulti and death? Alright, I suck. I still think Terra's claim is just the worst though.
---

MenuWars posted...

Dude you were so obvious that game, literally killed someone that claimed doctor when you'd never do that as town, not to mention you killed the guy that was claimed psychic when you're back up psychic. It was beautifully played but my god how did noone see it.

Hey, by the time he was dead he wasn't claiming doctor anymore.
---