Board 8 > turbopuns mafia topic 6 no puns intended

(+) Yeah! (+)

Brohan just going limp is whatever, Chris murdering a claimed doctor set my red flag off so hard I was hoping someone replaced out.

You did well Death I wasn't sure about you, I think Ulti buggered up when he claimed x shot originally then claimed a use after enabler Vi was killed then changed his claim completely.


Nice work, hats off to ya.
---

MenuWars posted...

Dude you were so obvious that game, literally killed someone that claimed doctor when you'd never do that as town, not to mention you killed the guy that was claimed psychic when you're back up psychic. It was beautifully played but my god how did noone see it.

I saw it. I thhink Chris ignored that question or gave a really vague answer
---

http://s15.zetaboards.com/zxcvbnmmnbvcxz/forum/5102462/

probably not open yet

I was a godfather and gambler enabler (if I died, all gambling powers would disappear)
Brohan was a millermaker
Ulti was a rolecop/rolethief (the power he stole was lost when VI died the same night)

scum wasnt even that powerful
---

By the way I am pretty sure I may be the only town player in the universe who could have saved Terra day 2. My fucking specialty is saving flailing town from themselves. I was delighted as his claim just got worse and worse.
---

I also love how Ulti makes up an enabler role that was absolutely nothing like the one I flipped as

But whatever this setup makes DNE seem normal
---

benjamin3740 posted...

MenuWars posted...

Dude you were so obvious that game, literally killed someone that claimed doctor when you'd never do that as town, not to mention you killed the guy that was claimed psychic when you're back up psychic. It was beautifully played but my god how did noone see it.

I saw it. I thhink Chris ignored that question or gave a really vague answer

God damnit no I didn't. I said, when he claimed it, 'I could see there being a scum psychic."

...And there was. Me.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

MenuWars posted...

Dude you were so obvious that game, literally killed someone that claimed doctor when you'd never do that as town, not to mention you killed the guy that was claimed psychic when you're back up psychic. It was beautifully played but my god how did noone see it.

Hey, by the time he was dead he wasn't claiming doctor anymore.

Yes but you're the guy that taught me the golden rule of, if in doubt as town, claim doctor because it draws a shot, mafia would have to be crazy to do it, etc etc.

Admittedly you did do it, but you're Chris. I'm pretty sure Red's head exploded.
---

I should have probably lynched Ulti for his nonsense claim, I guess. That did set off alarm bells. I don't know. It's not like lynching Brohan helps any though. The game is literally no different in that position.
---

VeryInsane posted...

I also love how Ulti makes up an enabler role that was absolutely nothing like the one I flipped as

But whatever this setup makes DNE seem normal

No, hold on. Time out.

DNE had a mason serial killer who automatically won at 3.

Let's not go too far. This setup was weird but DNE is DNE for a reason. Bad VI.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

The confirmed town list is always 100% accurate :( (Except when Corrik is on it)

And ahhh, a safelist of roles. I kind of feel like maybe Town should have been told that. Given we know about mafia having a safelist of flavor, it would be the same thing. Not knowing though causes all kinds of shenanigans, which was the point of the game I;m sure.

I never complain about setups, so i hve nothing to say here. Except that all the people metaing roles still on day 3 were either stubborn or mafia

I was milking that for all it was worth, until Puns told us to stop it
---

Wow, so there WAS a jailer and a roleblocker on town. that's digusting.
---

Also I was Doctor Psychic. I told no lies about my role.
---

I did also let myself get led around the nose by Chris's claim despite thinking he was scum for much of the game. Clearly poor on my part.
---

to be fair, Ulti always claims nonsense
but changing it a lot is a scumUlti trait if ever there was one
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

I did also let myself get led around the nose by Chris's claim despite thinking he was scum for much of the game. Clearly poor on my part.

also surprised nobody pointed out that my distrust for Chris almost entirely disappeared

I had to stop myself from telling Mzero that he never liked Brohan too
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

I should have probably lynched Ulti for his nonsense claim, I guess. That did set off alarm bells. I don't know. It's not like lynching Brohan helps any though. The game is literally no different in that position.

No, we'd have found out Chris' allignment the next night I'm pretty sure. Unless he had a plan around all that. (You wouldnt have gotten a scan though)
---

Well at least these guys get to learn Chris fear first hand.
---

Pretty easy move to murder Sceptile and claim roleblocked, with you blocking me. It really keep the game in check.
---

...and Sceptile, no as Cop you should've murdered the shit out of the guy you had a guilty scan on who hadn't made a post in forever.
---

I didn't really think things out very much on the last day. I just let it go because it was easier to believe Chris and Ulti were both town. I did think that it was possible they were both scum. The way they kept complimenting me was really suspicious. But fighting just seemed like a lot of work. I definitely did not play too well.
---

One thing i did bad is that I didnt have any experience with Scum chris and just used my "normal player" tells on him. So when he was emotional and when he counterclaimed doctor, i thought they were town tells.
---

I will say that it is tough. When you have the mafia roleblocker you kill the roleblocker, but it's about...do you have the roleblocker? Mafia is always going to have some in between and honestly I say it is never the right move to kill the idle loser unless you think he is the blocker. You always kill ben or me there, the blocker or the power player.
---

Sceptile, did you even have a scan left?
---

If town just lynched brohan the most obvious mafia of literally all time then ulti was dead to rights

Brohan flips Millermaker and MZero had blocked him the night ulti lied about being millerized

Then you have Doctor chris still alive on day 6? Maybe town gets that one and has a shot at scumdeath endgame

But really when pj was modkilled it got bad and then princess claiming protection Jack shew man
---

Wow. That was not very fun at all lol. My own fault the holiday weekend really screwed me up so much more than I anticipated and the game plan was to catch up at Tuesday but I never could. Should have followed my instincts when Chris was alive day 3 having evidence on someone is too hard to pass up though.
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

I didn't really think things out very much on the last day. I just let it go because it was easier to believe Chris and Ulti were both town. I did think that it was possible they were both scum. The way they kept complimenting me was really suspicious. But fighting just seemed like a lot of work. I definitely did not play too well.

Man, I am capable of being nice.
---

Me and Chris same time post!
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Pretty easy move to murder Sceptile and claim roleblocked, with you blocking me. It really keep the game in check.

Yeah but then at least I'd die knowing the truth :'(
---

MenuWars posted...

...and Sceptile, no as Cop you should've murdered the shit out of the guy you had a guilty scan on who hadn't made a post in forever.

Why? It's not like 0-4 is a better game than 1-3. I couldn't really come up with a good reason why I should lynch guaranteed scum first if I end up lynching Ben eventually.
---

and has a shot at scumdeath endgame

not again
---

Honestly, so was already losing steam by Day 2 and the Terra flip just killed what I had left. Being gone for the active parts of the day didn't help but once it finally settles in that trying to make sense of the roles and setup was going to be largely useless I think I legit stopped really caring.
---

bng_mmmk posted...

If town just lynched brohan the most obvious mafia of literally all time then ulti was dead to rights

Brohan flips Millermaker and MZero had blocked him the night ulti lied about being millerized

Then you have Doctor chris still alive on day 6? Maybe town gets that one and has a shot at scumdeath endgame

But really when pj was modkilled it got bad and then princess claiming protection Jack shew man

... Oh. I'm not sure that would have occurred to me.
---

At least I had the 100% Scum Chris voting record still as yeah

Was on a warpath Day 1 with votes and then the setup became too wtf for me to care

Like I realized Terra's flip synergizes with mine but if he just claimed like backup princess nobody cares about him and we lynch Brohan Day 2 and have some cake
---

again, we could have gone for a Nolynch
---

Right. Two man power trip.

<.<
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

You always kill ben or me there, the blocker or the power player.

Town had no power left!
---

I wanted to ask about the decision to have ties end in no lynch. That seems a little odd to me, I'm not used to that rule. What advantage does that gain?
---

eh the role setup wasnt even that vexing to me
outside of the mean false hope provided by serial roles and serial lightning rod
---

I didn't mean power as in role power, I meant the fact that I am a power player. I don't need a night action to be more dangerous than most players!
---

Game was simply down to a massive play from Chris with back up from Death, no offense Ulti but if Chris hadn't overshadowed the day 2 and 4 completely somebody would've sniffed out your claim. Of that I have little doubt.
---

bng_mmmk posted...

If town just lynched brohan the most obvious mafia of literally all time then ulti was dead to rights

Brohan flips Millermaker and MZero had blocked him the night ulti lied about being millerized

Then you have Doctor chris still alive on day 6? Maybe town gets that one and has a shot at scumdeath endgame

But really when pj was modkilled it got bad and then princess claiming protection Jack shew man

Damnit. Damnit damnit damnit. That would have been sweet

and yeah wow the crazieness of day 4 totally made me forget death was even playing and that I think he's obvscum. Would i have been able to convince anybody of that? Probably not
---

bng_mmmk posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

You always kill ben or me there, the blocker or the power player.

Town had no power left!

And mafia had no Roleblocker XD
---

On the downside, I don't think I would have ever lynched death, I was utterly fooled by his play.
---

Also Ben the correct play is jailkeeping me. 100%
---

benjamin3740 posted...

bng_mmmk posted...

If town just lynched brohan the most obvious mafia of literally all time then ulti was dead to rights

Brohan flips Millermaker and MZero had blocked him the night ulti lied about being millerized

Then you have Doctor chris still alive on day 6? Maybe town gets that one and has a shot at scumdeath endgame

But really when pj was modkilled it got bad and then princess claiming protection Jack shew man

Damnit. Damnit damnit damnit. That would have been sweet

and yeah wow the crazieness of day 4 totally made me forget death was even playing and that I think he's obvscum. Would i have been able to convince anybody of that? Probably not

to be honest, some of your reasons for suspecting me were just things I do all the time as town or scum
---

Sceptilesolar posted...

On the downside, I don't think I would have ever lynched death, I was utterly fooled by his play.

you were so close day1
---

VI I almost orgasmed when I saw he had blocked me. Like...oh my it was so good.

You give scum chris an inch and I will fucking murder you. Lesson learned folks!

I am not the best because I am flawless, I am the best because I can take an idle brohan and an ulti who is spitting straight nonsense and just have everyone ignore them.

It's fun, I hope I am town next time and then people will accuse me of being scummy like they always do.
---