Current Events > Boogie2988 finds a way to be centrist over the Fortnite domestic violence video

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3
#52
Post #52 was unavailable or deleted.
Cornmuffins
12/10/18 11:36:06 PM
#53:


It's weird how cjsdowg is vehemently anti-racist, and rightfully so, but has no problem with his unabashed sexism
---
Getting C's and D's, saying thanks and please.
You broke the golden rule, you're staying after school.
... Copied to Clipboard!
cjsdowg
12/10/18 11:36:24 PM
#54:


Vyrulisse posted...

Oh yeah that poor guy... he clearly had no choice but to beat the s*** out of his pregnant wife while his kids watched and screamed

f*** off with your bulls***


Cornmuffins posted...
It's weird how cjsdowg is vehemently anti-racist, and rightfully so, but has no problem with his unabashed sexism


I literally said MORE than once, he should not have done what he did. So unless I am ok with her abuse , that means that I think he was ok with what he did? How does that work. They are both trash people and he his more trash than she. But that does not mean she isn't still trash.
---
Bender: Well, everybody, I just saved a turtle. What have you done with your lives?
... Copied to Clipboard!
DifferentialEquation
12/10/18 11:40:57 PM
#55:


Vyrulisse posted...
cjsdowg posted...
In the full video we can see at least 4 things being thrown and him telling her to stop throwing stuff at him. The dude begs her to leave him alone and stop throwing stuff at him. Why are you making excuses for this shit .

Oh yeah that poor guy... he clearly had no choice but to beat the shit out of his pregnant wife while his kids watched and screamed

Fuck off with your bullshit


Cjsdowg already said that he was against him hitting her.

Why is it so controversial to say that he had no reason to hit her and that she also had no reason to throw shit at him? You don't need to point out that the guy was in the wrong because no one is actually defending him. It's more than everyone is completely overlooking that she was throwing shit at him. Why couldn't she simply say "I'm no longer going to make dinner for you until you get your ass off the computer."? Did she need to throw crap at him?
---
There's no business to be taxed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/10/18 11:43:16 PM
#56:


cjsdowg posted...
In the full video we can see at least 4 things being thrown and him telling her to stop throwing stuff at him. The dude begs her to leave him alone and stop throwing stuff at him. Why are you making excuses for this shit .


"Yes. Yes. Yes. I'll be out soon. JUST WAIT! I'll be out soon. Jesus Christ. I'll be out soon. I'LL BE OUT SOON! STOP! Grace. Stop. I'm serious. One of them just fell over. Can you stop? Please. I'll be out soon. Stop.
*baby starts wanting her Dad*
Please. I'll be out soon. Fuck. I'll be out soon. I'LL BE OUT SOON. GRACE. I'll be out soon. Fuck off. Honestly. I'll be out soon. Stop. Or I'll start throwing shit back at you. See how you like it. I will be out soon. I will be out soon.
*catches pizza box and throws it back*
Can you not? I said I'll be out soon!
Fuck!
*gets up and slaps his wife and she cries*

You have a weird interpretation of begging.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/10/18 11:45:45 PM
#57:


DifferentialEquation posted...
Vyrulisse posted...
cjsdowg posted...
In the full video we can see at least 4 things being thrown and him telling her to stop throwing stuff at him. The dude begs her to leave him alone and stop throwing stuff at him. Why are you making excuses for this shit .

Oh yeah that poor guy... he clearly had no choice but to beat the shit out of his pregnant wife while his kids watched and screamed

Fuck off with your bullshit


Cjsdowg already said that he was against him hitting her.

Why is it so controversial to say that he had no reason to hit her and that she also had no reason to throw shit at him? You don't need to point out that the guy was in the wrong because no one is actually defending him. It's more than everyone is completely overlooking that she was throwing shit at him. Why couldn't she simply say "I'm no longer going to make dinner for you until you get your ass off the computer."? Did she need to throw crap at him?


Nobody is focusing on that for the same reason nobody is focusing on him disregarding his family to play Fortnite. Which also isn't a good thing to do.

Everyone is focused on him because it escalates from an argument between them to domestic violence. That's when the line is crossed. He did that. Not her.

What happened before isn't relevant.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
cjsdowg
12/10/18 11:48:06 PM
#58:


Darmik posted...
DifferentialEquation posted...
Vyrulisse posted...
cjsdowg posted...
In the full video we can see at least 4 things being thrown and him telling her to stop throwing stuff at him. The dude begs her to leave him alone and stop throwing stuff at him. Why are you making excuses for this shit .

Oh yeah that poor guy... he clearly had no choice but to beat the shit out of his pregnant wife while his kids watched and screamed

Fuck off with your bullshit


Cjsdowg already said that he was against him hitting her.

Why is it so controversial to say that he had no reason to hit her and that she also had no reason to throw shit at him? You don't need to point out that the guy was in the wrong because no one is actually defending him. It's more than everyone is completely overlooking that she was throwing shit at him. Why couldn't she simply say "I'm no longer going to make dinner for you until you get your ass off the computer."? Did she need to throw crap at him?


Nobody is focusing on that for the same reason nobody is focusing on him disregarding his family to play Fortnite. Which also isn't a good thing to do.

Everyone is focused on him because it escalates from an argument between them to domestic violence. That's when the line is crossed. He did that. Not her.

What happened before isn't relevant.


So if he was the wrong throwing stuff at her and she hit him you would be complaining about her ?
---
Bender: Well, everybody, I just saved a turtle. What have you done with your lives?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/10/18 11:51:41 PM
#59:


cjsdowg posted...
So if he was the wrong throwing stuff at her and she hit him you would be complaining about her ?


If it was the exact same situation with the same reactions and the roles reversed? Yes.

'Complaining' is a really weird word to use over a recorded domestic abuser.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
DifferentialEquation
12/10/18 11:52:01 PM
#60:


Darmik posted...
DifferentialEquation posted...
Vyrulisse posted...
cjsdowg posted...
In the full video we can see at least 4 things being thrown and him telling her to stop throwing stuff at him. The dude begs her to leave him alone and stop throwing stuff at him. Why are you making excuses for this shit .

Oh yeah that poor guy... he clearly had no choice but to beat the shit out of his pregnant wife while his kids watched and screamed

Fuck off with your bullshit


Cjsdowg already said that he was against him hitting her.

Why is it so controversial to say that he had no reason to hit her and that she also had no reason to throw shit at him? You don't need to point out that the guy was in the wrong because no one is actually defending him. It's more than everyone is completely overlooking that she was throwing shit at him. Why couldn't she simply say "I'm no longer going to make dinner for you until you get your ass off the computer."? Did she need to throw crap at him?


Nobody is focusing on that for the same reason nobody is focusing on him disregarding his family to play Fortnite. Which also isn't a good thing to do.

Everyone is focused on him because it escalates from an argument between them to domestic violence. That's when the line is crossed. He did that. Not her.

What happened before isn't relevant.


Was it not domestic violence (albeit to a lesser degree) when she was throwing shit at him?

Let's agree that his response was entirely inappropriate. What would have been the appropriate response? Should he just suck it up and do as she says so she stops throwing things at him? If he had (instead of hitting her) called the cops on her would you be okay with that?
---
There's no business to be taxed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/10/18 11:59:10 PM
#61:


DifferentialEquation posted...
Darmik posted...
DifferentialEquation posted...
Vyrulisse posted...
cjsdowg posted...
In the full video we can see at least 4 things being thrown and him telling her to stop throwing stuff at him. The dude begs her to leave him alone and stop throwing stuff at him. Why are you making excuses for this shit .

Oh yeah that poor guy... he clearly had no choice but to beat the shit out of his pregnant wife while his kids watched and screamed

Fuck off with your bullshit


Cjsdowg already said that he was against him hitting her.

Why is it so controversial to say that he had no reason to hit her and that she also had no reason to throw shit at him? You don't need to point out that the guy was in the wrong because no one is actually defending him. It's more than everyone is completely overlooking that she was throwing shit at him. Why couldn't she simply say "I'm no longer going to make dinner for you until you get your ass off the computer."? Did she need to throw crap at him?


Nobody is focusing on that for the same reason nobody is focusing on him disregarding his family to play Fortnite. Which also isn't a good thing to do.

Everyone is focused on him because it escalates from an argument between them to domestic violence. That's when the line is crossed. He did that. Not her.

What happened before isn't relevant.


Was it not domestic violence (albeit to a lesser degree) when she was throwing shit at him?

Let's agree that his response was entirely inappropriate. What would have been the appropriate response? Should he just suck it up and do as she says so she stops throwing things at him? If he had (instead of hitting her) called the cops on her would you be okay with that?


Sure didn't look like it in the video.

Throwing something that caused an empty can to fall over and catching an empty pizza box to throw back isn't domestic violence.

As for what he should have done? I don't know. I don't speak to my wife like that when I'm playing video games and I'm asked if I can stop and do something.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
PiOverlord
12/11/18 12:00:53 AM
#62:


If you call the cops because someone threw a cardboard box at you, you're a little bitch.

The appropriate response is to get off the damn game, you're not an 8 year old anymore who has to kick and scream because mommy wants you to do your chores real quick instead of getting to play a game all day.
---
Number of legendary 500 post topics: 26, 500th posts: 20; PiO ATTN: 3
RotM wins 1, https://i.imgtc.com/Ejs0WrG.jpg
... Copied to Clipboard!
SwordMaster13X
12/11/18 12:02:45 AM
#63:


Boogie is a moron
---
Check out my funny youtube channel I guess...
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCh4BPUqx-fUnHjHVgiB-Kbw
... Copied to Clipboard!
QwelzaarKane
12/11/18 12:03:34 AM
#64:


Throwing an empty puzza box isn't abuse jfc and he deserves worse than that for being a deadbeat dad/husband.
---
http://error1355.com/ce/QwelzaarKane.html
Ain't no love shown but to those who down til we die
... Copied to Clipboard!
Nazanir
12/11/18 12:06:22 AM
#65:


BigSmoke2988 posted...
I just looked at his twitter

Dudes having a fucking meltdown it looks like and keeps calling people who give him shit "incels"

lol he has a lot in common with some people on this board.

I think it's hilarious that he dares call others incels.

Atleast incels can see their own dicks.
---
XboX GT/Steam/Wii-U - Nazanir
... Copied to Clipboard!
SSMajinVegeta2
12/11/18 12:10:22 AM
#66:


Touya999 posted...
Outer_space posted...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXhqmRYoR3k" data-time="


That guy has real problems. Why does he hate Boogie? How does anyone hate anyone that much?
He needs to take a breather and go lift some weights lol
---
On my business card, I am a corporate president. In my mind, I am a game developer. But in my heart, I am a gamer.
Satoru Iwata, 1959 - 2015 RIP GP God bless
... Copied to Clipboard!
DifferentialEquation
12/11/18 12:11:33 AM
#67:


PiOverlord posted...

The appropriate response is to get off the damn game, you're not an 8 year old anymore who has to kick and scream because mommy wants you to do your chores real quick instead of getting to play a game all day.


At that point it's not about the game anymore. Verbal nagging is one thing, but you can't let your partner get their way by throwing shit at you (especially doing so in front of the kid). He should have walked out of the house for a while.
---
There's no business to be taxed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
PiOverlord
12/11/18 12:15:17 AM
#68:


DifferentialEquation posted...
PiOverlord posted...

The appropriate response is to get off the damn game, you're not an 8 year old anymore who has to kick and scream because mommy wants you to do your chores real quick instead of getting to play a game all day.


At that point it's not about the game anymore. Verbal nagging is one thing, but you can't let your partner get their way by throwing shit at you (especially doing so in front of the kid). He should have walked out of the house for a while.

He should have been like "Oh, my pregnant wife needs me? I'll put down the game for a little bit because I'm an adult, not a little kid"

If the game starts to become more important to you than your real life, then you got a problem. Twitch streaming allows you to be able to put down the game for a bit.
---
Number of legendary 500 post topics: 26, 500th posts: 20; PiO ATTN: 3
RotM wins 1, https://i.imgtc.com/Ejs0WrG.jpg
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 12:15:25 AM
#69:


You also shouldn't be playing Fortnite 8 hours a night when you have a toddler to raise.

Nobody is saying that the relationship isn't toxic. But the damning evidence weighs heavily against this dude when it comes to being an outright piece of shit.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
12/11/18 12:18:51 AM
#70:


Darmik posted...
Throwing something that caused an empty can to fall over and catching an empty pizza box to throw back isn't domestic violence.

In what world is violently throwing things in anger not domestic abuse?
---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 12:21:03 AM
#71:


CM_Ponch posted...
Darmik posted...
Throwing something that caused an empty can to fall over and catching an empty pizza box to throw back isn't domestic violence.

In what world is violently throwing things in anger not domestic abuse?


When the things I've bolded aren't present.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
12/11/18 12:21:32 AM
#72:


Darmik posted...
CM_Ponch posted...
Darmik posted...
Throwing something that caused an empty can to fall over and catching an empty pizza box to throw back isn't domestic violence.

In what world is violently throwing things in anger not domestic abuse?


When the things I've bolded aren't present.

So she was throwing things peacefully and calmly?
---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 12:24:06 AM
#73:


CM_Ponch posted...
So she was throwing things peacefully and calmly?


Are those the only two possibilities?

What would you call throwing things to disrupt his stream?
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
12/11/18 12:25:11 AM
#74:


Darmik posted...
CM_Ponch posted...
So she was throwing things peacefully and calmly?


Are those the only two possibilities?

What would you call throwing things and screaming to disrupt his stream?

Throwing things violently and in anger
---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
JadeBaby
12/11/18 12:28:04 AM
#75:


I think the children need to taken out of the house and put in the care of close relatives.

We've already seen too many stories about and even seen how arguments like this escalate from verbal to deadly in a split second. We don't need anymore children being hurt or even killed as a result of the actions of their worthless parents.
---
Would've, could've, should've. Would of, should of, and could of ARE INCORRECT!!!!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 12:29:38 AM
#76:


When was she screaming before he hit her?
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
KillerKhan420
12/11/18 12:31:40 AM
#77:


Boogie is a disgusting king of lard. 300 pounds with now a hanging turkey neck. He wouldn't take sides on it cause he probably knows all about it. He won't hit a woman but he'll manipulate them. Wonder what happened to that goth escort he was parading around recently
---
"I know how the business works because I'm a wrestling fan"-hulkhogan1
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
12/11/18 12:33:35 AM
#78:


Darmik posted...
When was she screaming before he hit her?


Or you're right, she doesn't scream at him until she's already been throwing things at him for 40 seconds
---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sativa_Rose
12/11/18 12:35:26 AM
#79:


Who?
---
[This signature was deleted at the request of a moderator or administrator]
... Copied to Clipboard!
DifferentialEquation
12/11/18 12:36:46 AM
#80:


PiOverlord posted...
DifferentialEquation posted...
PiOverlord posted...

The appropriate response is to get off the damn game, you're not an 8 year old anymore who has to kick and scream because mommy wants you to do your chores real quick instead of getting to play a game all day.


At that point it's not about the game anymore. Verbal nagging is one thing, but you can't let your partner get their way by throwing shit at you (especially doing so in front of the kid). He should have walked out of the house for a while.

He should have been like "Oh, my pregnant wife needs me? I'll put down the game for a little bit because I'm an adult, not a little kid"

If the game starts to become more important to you than your real life, then you got a problem. Twitch streaming allows you to be able to put down the game for a bit.


I agree he shouldn't be playing so much with kids. All I'm saying is allowing someone to get their way by throwing shit at you isn't going to lead to a healthy relationship either.
---
There's no business to be taxed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 12:37:28 AM
#81:


CM_Ponch posted...
Darmik posted...
When was she screaming before he hit her?


Or you're right, she doesn't scream at him until she's already been throwing things at him for 40 seconds


No. She just says
"I told you to come off an hour ago"
"Now"
"One. Two."

And that's the last thing you hear before he gets up and slaps her.

Looks like your theory that she's violently throwing things in anger while screaming doesn't hold much weight.

No idea why people are constantly trying to justify his actions. It's disgusting.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
thronedfire2
12/11/18 12:38:03 AM
#82:


The fact that she says dont hit me in the face instead of just dont hit me makes me think him hitting her is not something new
---
I could see you, but I couldn't hear you You were holding your hat in the breeze Turning away from me In this moment you were stolen...
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
12/11/18 12:46:38 AM
#83:


Darmik posted...
No. She just says
"I told you to come off an hour ago"
"Now"
"One. Two."

And that's the last thing you hear before he gets up and slaps her.

Yes after throwing things at him for 40 seconds

Darmik posted...
No idea why people are constantly trying to justify his actions. It's disgusting.

Where was I justifying his actions?
---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 12:58:18 AM
#84:


CM_Ponch posted...
Yes after throwing things at him for 40 seconds


Violently and in anger?

CM_Ponch posted...
Where was I justifying his actions?


Oh nah you're not trying to justify his actions. You're just saying that the pregnant woman he slapped abused him first!

Righto lol
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
12/11/18 12:59:40 AM
#85:


Darmik posted...

Violently and in anger?

Was she throwing them peacefully and calmly

Darmik posted...
Oh nah you're not trying to justify his actions. You're just saying that the pregnant woman he slapped abused him first!

No, I've never even commented on the video itself. I'm taking issue with you claiming throwing things in anger when you don't get your way isn't domestic violence.
---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 1:06:53 AM
#86:


You literally tried to claim she was screaming and throwing things at him angrily which wasn't true. The most danger the guy got in was when an empty can fell over. Calm down.

Yes you can throw things at people to annoy them and not to be violent. Children do it constantly.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
PleaseClap
12/11/18 1:07:15 AM
#87:


Could you guys maybe not make excuses for the wife beater? Thanks
---
Please
... Copied to Clipboard!
DavidWong
12/11/18 1:10:09 AM
#88:


SSMajinVegeta2 posted...
Touya999 posted...
Outer_space posted...
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oXhqmRYoR3k" data-time="

---
COOK WITH A GEORGE FOREMAN GRILL JUST TO DRINK OUT THE DRIP TRAY
... Copied to Clipboard!
CM_Ponch
12/11/18 1:15:12 AM
#89:


Darmik posted...
You literally tried to claim she was screaming and throwing things at him angrily which wasn't true. The most danger the guy got in was when an empty can fell over. Calm down.

Yes you can throw things at people to annoy them and not to be violent. Children do it constantly.

Was she throwing things peacefully and calmly?
---
SW-8316-3213-4720
... Copied to Clipboard!
Prestoff
12/11/18 1:26:21 AM
#90:


Boogie and the streamer are pieces of shits
---
It's what all true warriors strive for!
Switch FC: SW-0575-4758-7878
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 1:29:16 AM
#91:


CM_Ponch posted...
Darmik posted...
You literally tried to claim she was screaming and throwing things at him angrily which wasn't true. The most danger the guy got in was when an empty can fell over. Calm down.

Yes you can throw things at people to annoy them and not to be violent. Children do it constantly.

Was she throwing things peacefully and calmly?


I don't know. She's off camera. It's possible.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
dave_is_slick
12/11/18 1:44:07 AM
#92:


Nidhoggr posted...
Darmik posted...
Thanks for posting this. Haven't tagged anyone in a while.

What ever will I do?

Stop being a piece of shit.
---
The most relaxing version of Aquatic Ambiance I've ever heard:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl61y1XM7sM
... Copied to Clipboard!
dave_is_slick
12/11/18 1:48:35 AM
#93:


PleaseClap posted...
Could you guys maybe not make excuses for the wife beater? Thanks

Who the fucking hell is making excuses? Oh right, no one! Except maybe DE, I kinda tune his posts out so I don't know for sure. But all anyone is doing is calling abuse, abuse.
---
The most relaxing version of Aquatic Ambiance I've ever heard:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl61y1XM7sM
... Copied to Clipboard!
dave_is_slick
12/11/18 1:49:08 AM
#94:


Darmik posted...
I don't know. She's off camera. It's possible.

No it's not dude, this is an awful look for you.
---
The most relaxing version of Aquatic Ambiance I've ever heard:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl61y1XM7sM
... Copied to Clipboard!
SpiritSephiroth
12/11/18 1:51:36 AM
#95:


Just watched the video. The wife literally goaded him knowing hes in front of how many people for 5 mins straight.

Yeah he shouldnt have slapped her but this isnt some clear cut case of just one person being an asshole is it? It seems like a really toxic relationship.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 1:52:00 AM
#96:


dave_is_slick posted...
Darmik posted...
I don't know. She's off camera. It's possible.

No it's not dude, this is an awful look for you.


Throwing things to be annoying isn't the same thing as throwing things at someone violently.

Amazing I need to explain this.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
PiOverlord
12/11/18 1:52:33 AM
#97:


She didn't goad him to slap him in the face. She was trying to get him to stop streaming and be a parent and husband.
---
Number of legendary 500 post topics: 26, 500th posts: 20; PiO ATTN: 3
RotM wins 1, https://i.imgtc.com/Ejs0WrG.jpg
... Copied to Clipboard!
dave_is_slick
12/11/18 1:53:57 AM
#98:


Darmik posted...
dave_is_slick posted...
Darmik posted...
I don't know. She's off camera. It's possible.

No it's not dude, this is an awful look for you.


Throwing things to be annoying isn't the same thing as throwing things at someone violently.

Amazing I need to explain this.

Bullshit. I don't know what fucked up house you grew up in, but throwing things at people is not okay.
---
The most relaxing version of Aquatic Ambiance I've ever heard:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl61y1XM7sM
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 1:56:08 AM
#99:


I never said it was okay.

I'm saying it's not domestic abuse and that it's not violent.

His kid is capable of doing everything the Mother did in that video.
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
SpiritSephiroth
12/11/18 1:57:46 AM
#100:


PiOverlord posted...
She didn't goad him to slap him in the face. She was trying to get him to stop streaming and be a parent and husband.


She tries to hit him and throw shit at him. He slaps her like an idiot. She says "look he hit me" or something along those lines to the streamers. She continues doing the same thing.

I dunno i could be wrong but to me it sounds like a toxic relationship considering it sometimes takes two people to be in that position.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Darmik
12/11/18 1:58:57 AM
#101:


SpiritSephiroth posted...
PiOverlord posted...
She didn't goad him to slap him in the face. She was trying to get him to stop streaming and be a parent and husband.


She tries to hit him and throw shit at him. He slaps her like an idiot. She says "look he hit me" or something along those lines to the streamers. She continues doing the same thing.

I dunno i could be wrong but to me it sounds like a toxic relationship considering it sometimes takes two people to be in that position.


He swears at his infant daughter in another video
---
Kind Regards,
Darmik
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3