Current Events > Cyberpunk 2077 Tweets Transphobic Joke, Studio Apologizes 'To All Those Offended

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3
thelovefist
08/22/18 10:25:23 AM
#51:


CyricZ posted...
ThyCorndog posted...
they draw attention away from actual transphobia

This is part of actual transphobia. It may be a small part of it, but unaware and insensitive attitudes are the bedrock that allows the crueler aspects to exist. Same with any other kind of discrimination. Foster and normalize flippant or negative attitudes, worse things will follow.

No, I'm not going to parade an effigy of CDPR around as a bunch of bigots, but this is a bad look.

thelovefist posted...
That is in no way, shape, or form, a transphobic comment.

---
"honestly the worst thing about Shaun King is how pro-cop he is" - averagejoel
... Copied to Clipboard!
CyricZ
08/22/18 10:26:54 AM
#52:


thelovefist posted...
That is in no way, shape, or form, a transphobic comment.

Thank goodness the expert weighed in.
---
CyricZ
... Copied to Clipboard!
#53
Post #53 was unavailable or deleted.
gunplagirl
08/22/18 10:34:44 AM
#54:


chrono625 posted...
gunplagirl posted...
They apologized for all those who found it offensive

Which is distinctly different from apologizing in a way that acknowledges it is offensive

Which is to say, they don't think it's offensive and by being unable to do such, they have yet to acknowledge any wrongdoing meaning the apology is worth less than the piece of gum I just walked past.

l Dudeboy l posted...
A joke about a group of people being easily offended resulting in that group of people easily being offended only perpetuates that they are easily offended.


Okay, so let's use a parallel. There's stereotypes that african american people are more violent than white people. A white person makes a joke about black people's skin. The white person doesn't think it's racist. An African american who heard the joke tells the guy to fuck off. Then the white guy says "I was just joking" as though joking absolve him of any wrongdoing or the implications of making fun of people based upon their skin color following centuries of violence towards people of African descent in america.

Back to this. It isn't about it being a joke, it's that the line itself is used to make fun of trans people who advocate for themselves by correcting others when misgendered. No trans person has ever seriously said "did you assume my gender" and if you use some tumblr post that isn't evidence at all. So then, because of people intentionally and accidentally misgendering trans people and trans people self advocating to be identified correctly, people made up this line. Meaning that now any time a trans person self advocates, in the minds of people who despise us, it causes them to think "see trans people are easily offended" when in reality it's that the people making these types of "jokes" are reinforcing the societal argument that trans people are invalid and unworthy of being defended or validated, and that anyone who does defend them is a joke. When taken conjunction with historic and present resistance to trans people even existing, yeah, it's offensive to make that joke. It's the overall societal context that determines impact, intent is irrelevant.
---
Pew pew!
... Copied to Clipboard!
gunplagirl
08/22/18 10:37:24 AM
#55:


CyricZ posted...
ThyCorndog posted...
they draw attention away from actual transphobia

This is part of actual transphobia. It may be a small part of it, but unaware and insensitive attitudes are the bedrock that allows the crueler aspects to exist. Same with any other kind of discrimination. Foster and normalize flippant or negative attitudes, worse things will follow.

No, I'm not going to parade an effigy of CDPR around as a bunch of bigots, but this is a bad look.


Ding, somebody who actually gets it.
---
Pew pew!
... Copied to Clipboard!
gunplagirl
08/22/18 10:38:59 AM
#56:


fenderbender321 posted...
I'm an actual, certified expert on what is and isn't transphobic. And this is not transphobic at all.

/case closed.

Jeez how many episodes is that anime up to

Season 27 episode 54

Christ
---
Pew pew!
... Copied to Clipboard!
l Dudeboy l
08/22/18 10:40:12 AM
#57:


Who keeps posting?
---
You are now breathing manually.
Lets put a little lead in the air, and see what falls over.
... Copied to Clipboard!
CruelBuffalo
08/22/18 10:41:33 AM
#58:


Oh look people ITT offended over an apology that doesn't affect them. Behaving the same way about the people they cry about. No hint of irony here.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zodd3224
08/22/18 10:44:13 AM
#59:


Wow...

Anyways, game looks great!
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
CyricZ
08/22/18 10:44:29 AM
#60:


gunplagirl posted...
Jeez how many episodes is that anime up to

Season 27 episode 54

Christ

I'm still reading the manga as it's being localized, but I actually donated my collection because I knew for damn sure I was never going back to that series again.

I have Volumes 65-67 sitting on my shelf. No damn way I'm going back to this series and reading it from the beginning, so there was no point in hanging onto the books.
---
CyricZ
... Copied to Clipboard!
ThyCorndog
08/22/18 10:49:15 AM
#61:


CyricZ posted...
ThyCorndog posted...
they draw attention away from actual transphobia

This is part of actual transphobia. It may be a small part of it, but unaware and insensitive attitudes are the bedrock that allows the crueler aspects to exist. Same with any other kind of discrimination. Foster and normalize flippant or negative attitudes, worse things will follow.

No, I'm not going to parade an effigy of CDPR around as a bunch of bigots, but this is a bad look.

I mean, I get it. I just don't agree. It comes down to how much value you place over jokes and language vs intent and whatnot. I'm against transphobia but I'm not on the same page with you with regard to what constitutes it. Like, I dont think south park level jokes are a societal issue at all
---
Hey what's going on in this thread https://imgur.com/6fpKRW8
https://imgur.com/RNZi0gk
... Copied to Clipboard!
The Catgirl Fondler
08/22/18 10:58:30 AM
#62:


Lol'd at "supposedly fragile egos".

I think this was a hard confirm.
---
N/A
... Copied to Clipboard!
Unknown5uspect
08/22/18 11:00:24 AM
#63:


This is fucking stupid. Stop giving attention to a handful of loud jackasses on Twitter.

No one actually gives a fuck. Stop pretending that the joke was an actual problem.
... Copied to Clipboard!
CyricZ
08/22/18 11:00:33 AM
#64:


ThyCorndog posted...
I mean, I get it. I just don't agree. It comes down to how much value you place over jokes and language vs intent and whatnot. I'm against transphobia but I'm not on the same page with you with regard to what constitutes it. Like, I dont think south park level jokes are a societal issue at all

You're entitled to that perspective, but, and I'm going to use a dirty word here, you're also privileged to have that perspective as well. Can you say you've been exposed to a discrimination the way trans people have? If not, then how can you say what effect these kinds of jokes have?

As gunplagirl said earlier, making flippant jokes about black people, gay people, etc. have fallen out of style and get called out these days.
---
CyricZ
... Copied to Clipboard!
Mystery_Mission
08/22/18 11:04:59 AM
#65:


thelovefist posted...
gunplagirl posted...
They apologized for all those who found it offensive

Which is distinctly different from apologizing in a way that acknowledges it is offensive

Which is to say, they don't think it's offensive and by being unable to do such, they have yet to acknowledge any wrongdoing meaning the apology is worth less than the piece of gum I just walked past.

Shut the fuck up.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Anisoptera
08/22/18 11:07:42 AM
#66:


It's good that they apologized even if it wans't that offensive of a joke. Gives them good publicity. Not too many companies are eager to respond so quickly. Got to keep a nice appearance for publishers and sponsors. It may not be a big deal to you, but it is a big deal for the company.
---
I want to make music that gives people a warm and fuzzy, happy feeling inside. That's what the music I love does for me.
... Copied to Clipboard!
sylverlolol
08/22/18 11:13:39 AM
#67:


YellowSUV posted...
Anyone who wants a good laugh can look at this 40+ resetera topic

https://www.resetera.com/threads/cyberpunk-2077-twitter-account-makes-transphobic-joke-read-op.63305/

lmfao this is gold
---
This is my signature. There are many like it, but this one is mine.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Dark_twisted
08/22/18 11:32:04 AM
#68:


Game looks and sounds fantastic. Day 1 buy for me.
---
#TeamKick
... Copied to Clipboard!
Fight_The_Power
08/22/18 11:37:46 AM
#69:


gunplagirl posted...
They apologized for all those who found it offensive

Which is distinctly different from apologizing in a way that acknowledges it is offensive

Which is to say, they don't think it's offensive and by being unable to do such, they have yet to acknowledge any wrongdoing meaning the apology is worth less than the piece of gum I just walked past.


lmao

You seriously have to be a gimmick. There's just no way
---
TheJahManCometh. What will he do next?
"Whatever the f*** I want." 3DS FC: 0018-0111-4675.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Awesome
08/22/18 11:38:29 AM
#70:


these same people who are bashing cd for this will still be getting the game when it comes out, typical hypocrites.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
thanosibe
08/22/18 11:38:38 AM
#71:


Ok I get that the line was used by the twitter account to say hey not only guys worked on developing this game so the men and women will get recognition for their work. They were trying to be Inclusive and people got upset? I dont get it.
---
I think I need a drink. Almost everybody does only they don't know it. -- Charles Bukowski
... Copied to Clipboard!
Anisoptera
08/22/18 11:39:30 AM
#72:


It's Rockstar. this isn't some indie game company who doesn't care about having their game on Steam. They have to apologize or risk having their game delayed or cancelled.
---
I want to make music that gives people a warm and fuzzy, happy feeling inside. That's what the music I love does for me.
... Copied to Clipboard!
CyricZ
08/22/18 11:40:24 AM
#73:


thanosibe posted...
I dont get it.

We know.
Anisoptera posted...
It's Rockstar.

CD Projekt Red.
---
CyricZ
... Copied to Clipboard!
AcFan87
08/22/18 11:56:37 AM
#74:


nemu posted...
I hate when they apologize. Don't do that. It's not offensive at all.

That's a symptom of a pussified easily butt-hurt society. Welcome to 2018, where everyone's a "victim".
... Copied to Clipboard!
l Dudeboy l
08/22/18 11:57:33 AM
#75:


Anisoptera posted...
It's Rockstar. this isn't some indie game company who doesn't care about having their game on Steam. They have to apologize or risk having their game delayed or cancelled.


... What?
---
You are now breathing manually.
Lets put a little lead in the air, and see what falls over.
... Copied to Clipboard!
#76
Post #76 was unavailable or deleted.
thanosibe
08/22/18 12:01:33 PM
#77:


CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
I dont get it.

We know.
Killer response bro. I guess you got me.
---
I think I need a drink. Almost everybody does only they don't know it. -- Charles Bukowski
... Copied to Clipboard!
Sayoria
08/22/18 12:01:55 PM
#78:


Idiots. And I know a lot of trans people. No one has ever said "did you assume my gender?"... If that happened at all, it was by one, possibly genderqueer person whose line has stained on the right and became associated with anyone or any type of transgender.

I think the line is atrocious and outright stupid as Hell.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Anisoptera
08/22/18 12:04:24 PM
#79:


l Dudeboy l posted...
Anisoptera posted...
It's Rockstar. this isn't some indie game company who doesn't care about having their game on Steam. They have to apologize or risk having their game delayed or cancelled.


... What?


Causing an uproar is a good way to get your budget cut. Publishers don't want to support a game company that angers people.
---
I want to make music that gives people a warm and fuzzy, happy feeling inside. That's what the music I love does for me.
... Copied to Clipboard!
NinjaBreakfast
08/22/18 12:17:07 PM
#80:


'assume their gender' and 'haha TRIGGERED!!!' jokes are unreservedly awful though and almost universally spouted by total gimps
---
https://imgur.com/nGZeEqw
Do you really think you can beat me?
... Copied to Clipboard!
l Dudeboy l
08/22/18 12:23:30 PM
#81:


Anisoptera posted...
l Dudeboy l posted...
Anisoptera posted...
It's Rockstar. this isn't some indie game company who doesn't care about having their game on Steam. They have to apologize or risk having their game delayed or cancelled.


... What?


Causing an uproar is a good way to get your budget cut. Publishers don't want to support a game company that angers people.


Who is going to cut their budget? CD Projekt Red are developing and publishing their game themselves.
---
You are now breathing manually.
Lets put a little lead in the air, and see what falls over.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Questionmarktarius
08/22/18 12:29:53 PM
#82:


l Dudeboy l posted...
Who is going to cut their budget? CD Projekt Red are developing and publishing their game themselves.

Also it's Poland, where being told what to do and how to think has generally been frowned upon since the dockworker's strike in 1988.
... Copied to Clipboard!
#83
Post #83 was unavailable or deleted.
Anisoptera
08/22/18 12:46:58 PM
#84:


Steam once delisted Huniepop.
---
I want to make music that gives people a warm and fuzzy, happy feeling inside. That's what the music I love does for me.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Ivynn
08/22/18 12:49:58 PM
#85:


... Copied to Clipboard!
ArliePocket
08/22/18 12:54:08 PM
#86:


Yet even more proof the large majority of Liberals and the Left are doing more harm than good.
... Copied to Clipboard!
CyricZ
08/22/18 12:55:12 PM
#87:


thanosibe posted...
CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
I dont get it.

We know.
Killer response bro. I guess you got me.

We have multiple trans people in this topic explaining why it's not cool. You "not getting it" is willful ignorance.
---
CyricZ
... Copied to Clipboard!
YellowSUV
08/22/18 2:15:08 PM
#88:


Someone on Resetera got perma banned for this...

Dude's form Poland, it's an entirely different mentality over there than in the US, specifically ERA. The thought that this might be considered offensive by some people probably didn't even cross his mind.

I get that the tweet pissed off a lot of people, but you really need to stop insinuating that belitteling and mocking a minority was the sole purpose behind that tweet.

---
We all live in a Yellow SUV! a Yellow SUV!
... Copied to Clipboard!
GiftedACIII
08/22/18 2:27:11 PM
#89:


CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
I dont get it.

We know.
Killer response bro. I guess you got me.

We have multiple trans people in this topic explaining why it's not cool. You "not getting it" is willful ignorance.

No we don't. Literally just gunplagirl who's a known radical extremist who wants children of the bourgeoise to be killed and think there's nothing wrong with false rape accusations towards men.
On the contrary, we have Sayoria and Kisai in the resetera topic saying how bogus the situation is.
---
</topic>
... Copied to Clipboard!
CyricZ
08/22/18 2:29:10 PM
#90:


GiftedACIII posted...
On the contrary, we have Sayoria and Kisai in the resetera topic saying how bogus the situation is.

Sayoria posted...
Idiots. And I know a lot of trans people. No one has ever said "did you assume my gender?"... If that happened at all, it was by one, possibly genderqueer person whose line has stained on the right and became associated with anyone or any type of transgender.

I think the line is atrocious and outright stupid as Hell.

I haven't played in the other topic, but maybe Sayoria is just against the resetera response?
---
CyricZ
... Copied to Clipboard!
thanosibe
08/22/18 2:31:41 PM
#91:


CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
I dont get it.

We know.
Killer response bro. I guess you got me.

We have multiple trans people in this topic explaining why it's not cool. You "not getting it" is willful ignorance.
It's almost like intent bears no discussion in this incident. The intent was never to be offensive. In fact, the intent was to correct the poster that assumed all the people that worked on the game were not just men, thereby being inclusive to the women that did. So I am really not sure out of looking for a reason to be upset on the behalf of a group that didn't even weigh in on the tweet (from what was in the OP) other than your own complex. Sure it could have been said better. But ignoring intent to puff your chest out is being pretty willfully ignorant yourself.
---
I think I need a drink. Almost everybody does only they don't know it. -- Charles Bukowski
... Copied to Clipboard!
CyricZ
08/22/18 2:45:59 PM
#92:


thanosibe posted...
It's almost like intent bears no discussion in this incident.

As a former mod, I've lost count of the number of moderation disputes I handled where the person who was modded said "But I didn't mean to flame/troll/be offensive."

In short, there are times where intent doesn't bear discussion.

I've noted the stated intent, certainly, but that doesn't change that the person running the CDPR Twitter was apparently ignorant of how it could be taken. I can understand the average CEman not knowing, but a PR person should be a bit more aware.
---
CyricZ
... Copied to Clipboard!
dave_is_slick
08/22/18 3:02:42 PM
#93:


CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
I dont get it.

We know.
Killer response bro. I guess you got me.

We have multiple trans people in this topic explaining why it's not cool. You "not getting it" is willful ignorance.

You have one and they're a troll.
---
The most relaxing version of Aquatic Ambiance I've ever heard:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=bl61y1XM7sM
... Copied to Clipboard!
catboy0_0
08/22/18 3:18:01 PM
#94:


CyricZ posted...
thelovefist posted...
That is in no way, shape, or form, a transphobic comment.

Thank goodness the expert weighed in.

lol
---
I obviously like you at least a little to even talk to you -cornman
one day I hope to post a message so great it ends up in someones sig -Two_Dee
... Copied to Clipboard!
chrono625
08/22/18 4:18:49 PM
#95:


CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
It's almost like intent bears no discussion in this incident.

As a former mod, I've lost count of the number of moderation disputes I handled where the person who was modded said "But I didn't mean to flame/troll/be offensive."

In short, there are times where intent doesn't bear discussion.

I've noted the stated intent, certainly, but that doesn't change that the person running the CDPR Twitter was apparently ignorant of how it could be taken. I can understand the average CEman not knowing, but a PR person should be a bit more aware.


Gamefaqs over protective TOS and the mods failure to actually interpret it fairly shouldnt be the litmus test of how words and jokes are perceived or taken.
---
https://imgur.com/Rqk1DYV - Super Bowl XXI/XXV/XLII/XLVI Champions - NY Giants
Eli Manning SB tracker: 2/2 Superbowls 2/2 SBMVP's
... Copied to Clipboard!
gunplagirl
08/22/18 4:32:34 PM
#96:


Fight_The_Power posted...
gunplagirl posted...
They apologized for all those who found it offensive

Which is distinctly different from apologizing in a way that acknowledges it is offensive

Which is to say, they don't think it's offensive and by being unable to do such, they have yet to acknowledge any wrongdoing meaning the apology is worth less than the piece of gum I just walked past.


lmao

You seriously have to be a gimmick. There's just no way


Scenario: I kick you in the balls. If I said "I'm sorry I hurt you" that's acknowledging the fault lies on my part. "I'm sorry your balls are so fragile" on the other hand puts the onus of fault on your own anatomy. Which is to say, it's not an apology.
---
Pew pew!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Alpha218
08/22/18 4:45:47 PM
#97:


CyricZ posted...
thelovefist posted...
That is in no way, shape, or form, a transphobic comment.

Thank goodness the expert weighed in.

Lmao
---
I'm Commander Shepard, and this is my favorite user on the Citadel.
Now Playing: Rainbow 6: Siege, Mario Kart 8, Super Smash Bros 4 (3DS) WarioWare Gold
... Copied to Clipboard!
Axiom
08/22/18 4:52:27 PM
#98:


I cringe whenever I see this online along with that attack helicopter thing. It's not funny or clever
... Copied to Clipboard!
Funbazooka
08/22/18 4:52:34 PM
#99:


This is why Trump won
---
"Don't trade your authenticity for approval." -Kanye West
... Copied to Clipboard!
gunplagirl
08/22/18 4:58:11 PM
#100:


dave_is_slick posted...
CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
CyricZ posted...
thanosibe posted...
I dont get it.

We know.
Killer response bro. I guess you got me.

We have multiple trans people in this topic explaining why it's not cool. You "not getting it" is willful ignorance.

You have one and they're a troll.


You know an awful lot about the aggressions and invalidations launched against trans identities, as you're an active enforcer of said aggressions. You're just a bigot and you refuse to consider that what you think is wrong. You're like a rich person who asks why poor people don't just buy more money. You're like that "how much could a banana cost, $10" line, you have zero fucking idea of what being trans is like so you don't think that lines like that which are used against us regularly are actually offensive to us.
---
Pew pew!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2, 3