LogFAQs > #978124971

Tears probably beats BotW head to head, even if, outside of that direct matchup, BotW would be ahead of it in the X-Stats. Someone can let me know if that would be the same thing as with Ultimate (taking the Tears slot) and Melee (taking the BotW slot).

I've not, and likely will never play BG3, but I think this result is 100% down to its strength, especially on the back of winning multiple GotY awards. Likely it slips back a little bit in the coming years but it also seems like a game that will stand the test of time. In my mind, I'd put it in that Skyrim, Witcher 3, Dark Souls range; not enough to beat the top nostalgia games here but otherwise capable of winning against almost anything else.