LogFAQs > #970429324

I mean I love he is going to be back, and yes I'll watch the episodes, but......I think it might be a mistake long term.

It's like bringing back Tom Baker in the original series, I stopped watching after him for along time cause the new doctors couldn't compare.

If you bring back tennant, you make it much harder to have a doctor that compares well against him. You could have had many doctors that would compare well to Jodie, heck the first doctor (eckleslie?) compares well to her, and you could have transitioned to a doctor like him well, drawn fans back etc.

Tennant is a really good actor who is fun to watch, and arguably the best doctor of the new series (I really liked the first doctor and was so sad there was only 1 season, but even I eventually came to feel Tenant was the better doctor).

I think part of the problem is all the doctors after him have been compared to him and found wanting.

Bringing him back is a temporary (heh time) fix, but it's going to make the problem worse going forward.