LogFAQs > #963334978

PunishedBen posted...

Cool. Yeah I was holding back a little bit because I wanted to see who would defend Corrik. But look - this is the truth of it. Shonen's role ONLY allowed him to bodyguard me, and did not give him the option to not be bodyguarding me. Corrik claiming to have bodygaurded no one each night is a "convenient" lie to avoid having to explain why he didnt protect the players he should have. And it is just that - a lie. Backup takes the exact abilities of the power is it backing up. It cant just interpret Mason Bodyguard as a bodyguard and ignore how his role actually works. What was it supposed to do if I was lynched day 1? It would have to take my Mason role. So there is no reason it cant take a Mason role.

Why did Corrik make such a flawed claim? Who the heck knows. Either scum did not interpret my explanation of what Shonen does correctly, or maybe Corrik just wanted to say he would never claim something this dumb. It's a great argument. But it is flawed for the simple reason that the host wouldnt do something this dumb.

Also using process of elimination Corrik was basically confirmed scum today anyway. So that is why he had to quickly claim something so polarizing and couldn't just claim vanilla.

By the way, funnily enough, Shonen who has not said anything in Mason chat since he was lynched, just showed up to say that its crazy that anyone is believing anything he's saying today, and that even he can see Corrik is scum. Shonen has spoken!

We all know how his role worked. We talked about how scum probably shot both masons too. For someone confirmed Town you are sure dropping logic a lot. Be better, Ben.

And POE? There is literally one confirmed town right now. You are playing lazy.