this was a rewatch for me and I ended up feeling kind of the same about it? I didnt remember most of it (like i completely forgot that bit about the priest being Ray's first job) but i had it at a 7/10 and i think that rating's going to stay for now. like the only thing i vaguely remembered was that it was supposed to be really funny? and there were humorous moments for sure but also a bunch of times where i didn't find the intended comedic elements that funny. this might have been distracting overall since i diverted part of my attention to look for the funny moments lol. so yeah maybe i went in with a mindset that was a bit one-dimensional.
like obviously there's more to the movie than the comedic elements but i just got hung up on that for some reason