LogFAQs > #941483879

Church Pick is like B leaning C, that's why I say to just be a little bit wary. It is fun to look at, and the stats can actually be fairly good -- the damage is also deceptively good because of the bonus damage modifiers. And while you did enjoy the move set, I really think the move set is actually the weakest aspect of this weapon.

The (sometimes boring) reality is that the best weapons in bloodborne are the ones that very quickly hit the space right in front of you with enough poise damage to stun the enemy you're fighting. That's the situation you're going to be in 90%+ of the time. It's even better if the weapon has a good transformation attack to help out with extra stagger against medium and large enemies, or, alternately, a solid charged R2 for spacing, knockdown, and crowd control.

Church Pick is lacking in almost all of these qualities. It has a slightly delayed swing and attacks at irregular angles. I have a lot more I could say about why extra reach on weapons isn't really that great, but I figure I'll just leave it at this. I doubt anyone wants to hear me continuing to lecture on this stuff with an even greater level of detail. At the end of the day, whatever "feels" good is going to be "best" for most players.

tl;dr church pick is decent. it can be usable. but it's closer to a C tier weapon than it is to an A tier weapon, so be careful about getting your hopes up. especially with how long it'll take to even find the thing.

---

all the rest weren't so unfortunate
https://imgur.com/yv2eC4n