you forgot Archer in there too for pretty much the same reasons as Gil. how he jobbed out there in the first route i don't think anybody knows. likewise i don't think anybody knows all the runes lancer had either.
Archer lost because of God Hand. Remember that God Hand nullifies anything- physical attacks, magic, even Noble Phantasms- rank C or lower, how he becomes completely immune to an attack after he regenerates to his next life, and how Archer's projection's are dropped an entire rank when he projects them. He'd have to resort to just nuking with different A or EX rank projections, which I don't really think he'd have too many of, plus he's already injured early on in.
And Lancer? I really, really doubt he has 10 instant kill runes out there or he'd have used some of them (Gae Bolg works once, considering it's B rank).
God Hand is pretty much the most hax passive Noble Phantasm out there, I think!
--
"Duel audio? You mean like rap battles?" - termina_rzident
KrahenProphet and Kana are on opposite ends of the Awesome Spectrum.