LogFAQs > #968051329

You know I actually think you might be right

Roshan is just a device to sow paranoia. Corrik's role implying Roshan exists doesn't mean crap when you've got death millers in the setup. This many extra kills is way more balanced if it's 11/4 and not 10/4/1. SBell's role could actually exist as a "roshan miller" in that sense.

Now that being said n1 extra kill being available to scum, Roshan existing or not, is still a bad setup that I don't think gets off the floor. Logic is the same. It's not good setup math.

Start of game 11/4
Town mislynch - 10/4
Scum shot - 9/4
Roshan hater targets scum - 8/4
Scum EK - 7/4

So then

Town mislynch - 6/4
Scum shot - 5/4

Okay it's not literally impossible like it was because day 2 lylo is impossible, but Corrik played really scummy day 1. I do not think he makes sense as a scum EK. At all.