Wait a minute, the Illinois winner was from a town called Red Bud which is FAR from Urbana which is where this girl goes to college.
Unless it's possible for there to be an unannounced 4th winner it could very well be a photoshop.
Ok, she's defending herself with statements like:
"pretty sure you don't know my life and where I've been" and "went on a day road trip with my roomie"
Yep, calling shenanigans. Nothing to see here.
--
http://img.imgcake.com/whitelens/gokfriendsjpgym.jpg