Lurker > Shonen_Bat

Yes

Gastrodon my boy

Malamar is my favorite concept here, and one of my favorites overall. But that design doesn't work for me.

People who think mental illness = weakness don't have a respectable opinion, but I'd say there are other reasons to criticize that scene. It relies on knowledge from another source to make sense, so a player who isn't familiar with that will have no idea why Samus is disturbed by Ridley this one time only.

I think the scene could've been received well if it could stand on its own, or if the game used some of its hours of bland monologuing to build it up more. But just looking at it in context it's delivered pretty badly.

Partners in Time: 9

It does slow down sometimes but I love how actually threatening the alien invasion is. The past and future Bowsers teaming up to fight you is amazing and totally justified the time travel for me.

Other M: 3. Mostly I was just bored by Samus's lifeless voice acting and the long stretches of time where nothing happens. The few moments that do stand out aren't good ones.

8

Yeah putting aside my own feelings a Mike lynch is... probably not in the cards today.

Red was one of my 'maybes' but feels a bit more sure after possibly-role fishing.

htaeD posted...

Uh.. my attention was on you because of you know what. I assume you are referring to yourself with that first sentence there.

I was referring to Banana. The way you all brought up the quiet player in almost exactly the same context rang some alarm bells.

htaeD posted...

And yeah that kind of answer that would have been better. And it may be too late now to ask this (and probably annoying too), but can you say why you specifically used the sentence about 'the actual scum'?

Honestly, it was just what came to mind for me to say. There really was no double meaning or hidden intention behind it.

MikeTavish posted...

Hmm. You literally ignored the fact I answered all the questions asked of me and moved the topic towards Banana in my last post, and not yourself.

I'm more and more confident on this Shonen lynch with every post. I'll be utterly shocked if this isn't a slam dunk.

You moving the topic to Banana and not myself is what I was talking about, I may be ignorant but not this time in particular.

So Mike, Death, and to a lesser extent Red have all tried to shift attention to someone else when they were being questioned, and to the same person at that. I obviously get why I'm the main focus today but hopefully someone noticed that?

Anyway,

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Is bat an experienced mafia player? I don't really know his profile but how is 'I don't have to tell you anything' a scum reaction. A bit on the nose

I've played one game before this. That's my experience level.

htaeD posted...

I will admit, its not really a smart reaction from scum either. But I dont know why he wouldn't address the 'slip' as well. I do agree that the slip in itself is not terrible. I know I've done it as town too. But I would just laugh it off and explain myself.

I didn't explain anything sooner because I was taking some time to cool off. Yeah the ideal response would've been "hey here's what I meant by that" but I wasn't really thinking things through that well.

It didn't occur to me at the time that I was kicking a hornet's nest and also all the hornets were on fire. All I meant to say was "Ulti is really making himself a target".

red13n posted...

So why did you slip?

I have a long and storied history of shooting myself in the foot.

htaeD posted...

Because thats what I was doing, waiting to see what Bat himself would say about the whole matter

You staying silent makes this hard to verify, we only have your word on what your thought process was.

Going to sleep soon so I'll leave this here. I'm Harchefaunt, Bodyguard.

Yes hello, it's me with a clearer head. I said something dumb without knowing it and then was an ass about it instead of explaining anything. So that's where that came from.

I do stand by my opinions on Death and Scare, even if I gave them like a clown.

UltimaterializerX posted...

If you flip town you have my word Death is dying tomorrow. Hell, I might kill him anyway. Him making a soft accusation at me when Plum and Chris were openly telling him to vote for me is such an unreal red flag. Death is hard to read, but hes not a pussy with voting unless hes scum. Thats his biggest issue as scum and he will never change this.

Yea, that's all I want to hear out of this. There are some real obvious tells from how people reacted to what I said.

Peace

You do you, I guess. Just pay attention to who jumped a mile to vote me after I flip town, Scare and Death especially.

I know that you're fishing ultra hard by voting for me, you did it with plum too. I don't have to tell you anything :p

Ulti making people want to vote him off more than the actual scum, a bold plan let's see if it pays off

I wouldn't guess his role based on this, he just likes making things difficult for whatever reason.

They didn't say much that other people weren't also saying but yeah, the vote is fair

Would be good to get more info, a passive game doesn't help much. Isn't someone like Chris usually driving discussion in these?

Scare, any reasoning on your vote?

No worries HB, see you.

I'd be fine with no lynch unless we get more discussion, it'd just be a shot in the dark otherwise.

Yeah I totally expect to wake up to topic #4 of this game

Plum's posts so far are a little odd but not much more, I think. Wouldn't personally make a call on just that.

Tag

UltimaterializerX posted...

I dont care about day one, I will never care or try on day one, and I will never have my mind changed on this. Deal with it.

See you all on day 2.

Aren't you like nightkill priority 1000 if you're town, isn't necessarily suspicious but it's weird that you don't want to make day 1 count

Red 3, standing by.

Winner: Gerudo Link

This should be a bigger deal. It's not like it'll be the last book to get banned under these pretenses.

reviews that don't touch on the good and bad of the game don't sell me, even if it is good I'm not expecting a 10/10 game with no flaws

"You are watched. You are protected. You are loved."

Alolan Marowak really gives the gen 1 duo a fight, I think it's still Arcanine though

very good for you, then!

It's alright? Definitely wasn't bad but I wouldn't call it 'very good'

It's always the pupper

Don't play the game but I've wanted to try more mafia, put me in coach

Absolutely picking up Shadow Man in the near future.

Pokemon, ehh. Maybe.

Mirror

I have no idea what I'd rate this because after like 70 hours I still hadn't gotten around to finishing it. Probably a six unless the endgame is something crazy.

I remember doing a good bit of the civil war plotline and wishing they expanded on it more, though.

Wing

Artist is one I expected to drop way earlier, happy to see it get that far.

Yoyo

Artist

Artist

Yoyo lol

Dang, water is real good. But then everything left is.

Youo

Spidey 1
Doctor Strange

Artist

Yoyo

Ninja I guess, let's get rolling

_Keeby posted...

I didnt include StartAllOvers save in the list below because I felt like they are an alt. Please let me know if I should include their save or not.

It's Preston supposedly, I know there's some kind of drama around them but I don't think they're an alt. No idea what the details are here so I can't really say yes or no.

Spider Man 1
Doctor Strange

Artist

^

Water

Metroid Dread
Little Nightmares 2
Ys IX
Sumire