Lurker > Peace___Frog

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, DB4, DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, Database 12 ( 11.2023-? ), Clear
Board List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 8:43:13 AM
#317
Ok. It's no guilty scan. It's a lot of circumstantial evidence.

My proposition is that if you flip town, in d4 we should kill the third person that targeted red n1. If they are also town, then we kill mzero.

The only way we don't have room for 2 mislynches is if scum used their strongman n1 but saved an extra kill. In a game with Sultan's power, i doubt scum has an extra kill. So either Sultan is lying scum, or scum does not have an extra kill.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 8:39:38 AM
#314
Peace___Frog posted...
Wallz watched death, mzero, and one other person visit red n1. Dumey neighbor'd with Wallz n2. They both agree that the third person who visited red n1 is probably town and don't want to out them as power. Mzero claimed before wallz on d2 and so looks better. Thus, unless there is a ninja in the game for a limited use watch, Death probably killed red n1.
Furthermore, Death targeted me n2. I used my commute n2, and i believe that it's why no one died n2.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 8:38:24 AM
#313
UltimaterializerX posted...
Ive been sick so tell me how hes dead to rights
Wallz watched death, mzero, and one other person visit red n1. Dumey neighbor'd with Wallz n2. They both agree that the third person who visited red n1 is probably town and don't want to out them as power. Mzero claimed before wallz on d2 and so looks better. Thus, unless there is a ninja in the game for a limited use watch, Death probably killed red n1.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 7:06:19 AM
#306
Or mzero to be scum

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 7:05:51 AM
#305
Oh and duh, that scenario ALSO requires mzero to be unable to get wallz' results

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 7:05:18 AM
#304
Since wallz told Dumey the 3rd person, the ways in which town gets screwed is if one of the two things happen:
  • Scum kills them both in the same night
  • Dumey is scum and misleads town on what to do after wallz dies


I think the second one is unlikely. So the first one is the main concern.
Just going to type this path out for myself...

Assuming we started with 4 scum:
D2 9/3
Lynch death and he is town 8/3
Scum kills both wallz and dumey 6/3
Town mislynch 5/3
Scum kills sultan and he is town 4/3
Sultan misfires 3/3 gg

In that one specific scenario, town is screwed over for wallz/dumey not sharing who the third person is. It requires both death and sultan to be town, and for scum to have an extra shot that they've been hanging on to, and for Sultan to miss on a 50% shot, and for scum to take that risk in the first place.

So tldr - if you are town, Death, we have the direction of where to go next. But it's quite interesting that you're not leaving us any suggestions for tomorrow except "hey don't treat mzero as golden".

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 1:17:15 AM
#293
Thanks

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/06/23 1:03:56 AM
#291
EDumey posted...
The only thing that give me pause is the idea that Death knew Peaf was untargettable. If it was just a night kill that failed, wouldn't they just assume that there was a doctor save on Peaf because he was claimed power?
I don't know why any doctor would protect me last night. They should reevaluate their life choices if they even considered that.

But you raise a good point. They either targeted me with a roleblock on n1 or my target was, like lopen, Untargetable.
I really don't think that would be the case because that would mean that 3/15 players could be untargetable except by roleblock and strongman on any given night. That sounds so absurd.
I've considered saying who i targeted just in case i die tonight, but i think it could give a clue as to what my other ability is. I'd like to avoid that for a while longer, if it pleases the court.

EDumey posted...
Not sure how much leniency to give drunk posting.
What is this in reference to?

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 11:43:29 PM
#283
Especially since a mass right now gives town nothing and scum everything. We already have death dead to rights.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 11:43:01 PM
#282
I'd prefer to keep my last card close to my chest for tonight if only on the chance that i can screw up scum again.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 11:38:33 PM
#280
Corrik7 posted...
Death is telling the truth. He went to you. Unfortunately, he was the scum night kill so it was blocked.
Yeah this is the right answer here. I'm over thinking too much again.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 11:25:33 PM
#276
TheSultanOfSlam posted...
Ohhh okay thst makes sese.
Unless the doc also visited peaf if there is one okay death probably just scum.
Nobody could visit me last night. The only ways to prevent my Commuter action are roleblock or strongman. I am alive and death was told i was Untargetable so I'm assuming neither one happened.

I would not be surprised if Death is telling the truth, if there is no doctor. Commuter is a sort of Protection.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:52:56 PM
#265
Though I'm not sure if i would call him my biggest scum read. I would lynch ctes, Death, and maybe even chris before lynching marth.

In case scum has a way of getting me killed tonight, assuming that's their aim again, that would be my suggested order.

Has Ulti checked in yet today? I'm not proposing that we keep the day going for the full 48 hours but 6-12 is fine as long as everyone has a chance to talk a bit.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:49:31 PM
#264
wallmasterz posted...
Is this about my post or your biggest scum reads recent behavior
The behavior

wallmasterz posted...
No wonder I forgot Peaf, I was Mishima. I died before ctes was done writing the opening post.
Yeah, it was after you and I both died. I can understand you not remembering him being there.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:28:14 PM
#258
Lol

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:16:50 PM
#255
I have no idea what your definition is of green checked but you're definitely not it

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:16:06 PM
#254
In that case, who did you target last night? So that town can have the dual info of you and me out on the table. There are now two people that scum could have shot at for us to have no kill on n2. You were going to drop that claim, end day, and just expect to live another day?

I honestly didn't think a doctor existed.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:11:54 PM
#250
... at risk of parroting Dumey, I'm not sure i buy it

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:02:10 PM
#247
wallmasterz posted...
I would feel a hell of a lot better if Dumey had played in tekken mafia. But I still lean town and at a certain point you have to wonder when a gambit just stops being worth it (out your roleblocker, dont target the likely doctor when scum couldve just sent death ((assuming death is scum)) as a sacrificial lamb if they dont have a ninja)
... he did. He subbed in for hb and lived one extra day.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 9:01:33 PM
#246
Re: ctes. Topic 1, page 3, back to back posts

ctesjbuvf posted...
I think Lopen looks too opportunistic. Believing red and suggesting power ups is what it is. Suggesting to rush it though is not a good look imo.

ctesjbuvf posted...
I think Dumey trying to work out what it says about other players if Lopen is scum before seemingly having gotten to Lopen being scum is weird.

Now that we know lopen's alignment, I think these look horrible together for ctes. Barring any power revelations tomorrow, I want him to be under the microscope.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:59:10 PM
#243
Also can we pour one out for lopen real quick? The man has the worst luck as scum on n1.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:57:32 PM
#241
wallmasterz posted...
Again, I lean town on Dumey and think it was not a scum slip, but need to document this in case I die
Makes sense. Thanks for documenting.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:56:42 PM
#240
UnderUrMattress posted...
##Vote: Death

Very busy, won't be available until later.
1 hour ago

And now you're advocating for day to end with two hours of talking time.
?????

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:54:58 PM
#237
Wallz i love the out of the box thinking here but did dumey not just bury the fuck out of lopen yesterday?

Dumey is a good player but i don't see him doing that without influence from chris. If dumey is scum then so is chris.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:49:51 PM
#234
ctesjbuvf posted...
that has still got to be kt
What is a kt

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:49:29 PM
#233
Final D1 Votals
[8] BCT - (Sultan), Ulti, SBell, Death, Lopen, Ctes, Peaf, Chris, Red
[2] Sultan - (BCT), (Lopen), MZero, (Ulti), (Lopen), Wallz, (Marth), (Death)
[0] Death - (Peaf), (Lopen), (Marth), (Wallz), (Lopen) --> fixed number from host's list at EOD
[1] Wallz - (Lopen), (Chris), Sultan
[1] Peaf - BCT
[1] Ulti - (Lopen), (Sultan), (Marth), (Marth), Marth
[0] Dumey - (Marth), (Corrik), (Peaf)
[0] SBell - (Dumey), (Ulti)
[0] Chris - (Dumey)
[0] Marth - (Corrik)
[0] MZero - (Sultan), (Lopen)
[0] Lopen - (Wallz)
[0] Red - (Dumey), (SBell)

Final D2 Votals
[7] Lopen - Dumey, Ulti, (Marth), Peaf, Sultan, Corrik, Wallz, Death
[1] Death - (Wallz), (Peaf), Chris
[1] Dumey - Lopen
[0] Chris - (Ulti)
[0] Marth - (Peaf), (Lopen)

Notice something interesting about those day 2 votes? No ctes anywhere on them at all. And yet at the end of the day, he gave me shit for "keeping options open." I replied directly to him about it, but at the time didn't even make the connection that he had no vote down. Even his day 1, all he did was vote bct in the same flurry that I did.

Lopen/death/ctes for sure, and i think the 4th is in the sultan/marth/chris trio.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:44:01 PM
#229
Funny that ctes is all about this rush. He's actually who i was going to go after today in the absence of any wallz/dumey contributions

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:43:12 PM
#228
Is that -1? Jfc OK can we please have at least 6 hours today to discuss things

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 7:15:59 PM
#181
Haven't caught up but if no one died i think my gambit worked.

A little busy right now, will be here more later.

Tldr - I'm NES, not super like lopen, and one of my abilities is a limited number of Commuter actions (so you can see the similarity there). My other ability is active, but also has a limited number of uses. I tried to play it up to wallz towards end of day that i was protection-adjacent so scum would target me last night, assuming that they used their strongman on red n1.

---
~Peaf~
TopicBest Disney Song Ever Tournament - Sweet Sixteen - Day 32 (BDSE)
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 3:48:46 PM
#18
Mythiot posted...
Let it Go
You'll Be in My Heart


---
~Peaf~
TopicGame of Gen 8 CHAMPIONSHIP: Persona 5 vs. Hades
Peace___Frog
05/05/23 8:05:43 AM
#54
Hades

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:57:44 PM
#130
I personally don't think there is a standard doctor, given how we did not have a standard cop, and we have other weirdo roles claimed too.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:56:27 PM
#128
Maybe the bg can make a good guess, or maybe there isn't a doctor, or maybe scum is worried about hitting a vanilla in that pile, or maybe scum wants to kill a player who basically everyone agrees is town. Let's not be defeatist about it.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:48:36 PM
#123
wallmasterz posted...
Peaf seems to think Im the likeliest candidate to be murdered overnight despite me having depleted my bag of trick without an s (cmon sheep, even the real virtual boy had what, 22 games?) so with us -1 away from a hammer, if its the end of the road just want to say it was fun playing with you all as always. Good luck, town.
You had some top tier jokes this game, and that's actually why lea had to replace out. You were upstaging her.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:34:55 PM
#119
Corrik7 posted...
He untargetable. He isn't an untargetable roleblocker. Cmon now.
Duh, you're right.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:32:04 PM
#115
In either scenario, scum can kill who they want and they will need to weigh their options with respect to unknown town powers wallz and peaf.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:26:33 PM
#107
I understand him not being strongman (he would have been seen by wallz unless also ninja), but I'm unclear how he can't be rb.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:23:51 PM
#104
htaeD posted...
Man now I am hoping Lopen flips roleblocker or strongman ninja
Remember how stoked we were when wallz flipped worse sister, and the monkey's paw got us good the next day?

Be careful what you hope for!

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:17:09 PM
#101
Marth trying to be so controlling of things is really sketchy.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 3:16:38 PM
#100
I'd personally prefer a few more hours so that those who are at work can weigh in, but I think we've covered plenty of good ground today.
I'll do what I can to help with things tonight but we'll see where that goes!

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 1:25:53 PM
#35
And by the way, this is the disingenuous post i had in mind (2.221):

Lopen posted...
I expect town Death to be pushing for something right now or at least voting.

No follow-up that I can see on his mulling over Sultan to me is a red flag. Feels like lipservice.
Death notoriously holds his vote close to his chest as either alignment. I've come to learn that it's nai. What you have to pay attention to with death is what he says and how he says it. The timing and count of his votes are rarely relevant.

This makes death... look... better??? Somewhat. But lopen is talented enough to throw shade all over the place if he wants to.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 1:12:51 PM
#33
After red half-claimed, the two names lopen threw out to do a speedrun on were Sultan and corrik. If lopen is scum, i would expect zero to one of them to be scun as well but definitely not both. Dumey asked about this (t1.061) and i ignored him then because i had no opinion on it at that time. I still think it's generally NAI from lopen except that it is unlikely that all three players (lopen, Sultan, Corrik) are scum.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 12:18:47 PM
#21
I'm not sure where you're going

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 12:18:02 PM
#20
wallmasterz posted...
Im going somewhere with this. Can scum nk scum?
Yes but why would they, especially on n1?

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 12:07:44 PM
#14
... who?

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 12:05:03 PM
#12
ctesjbuvf posted...
I find it a bit hard to believe there are no scum om this Lopen lynch. But we can look at that tomorrow. If Lopen has just disappeared completely then I guess there's no point in running for 48 hours even though it would fit my weekend plans nicely.
At risk of perjuring myself here, why would you explore that idea and do nothing with the bct votals?

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 11:47:31 AM
#2
[5] Lopen - Dumey, Ulti, (Marth), Peaf, Sultan, Corrik
[2] Death - Wallz, (Peaf), Chris
[1] Dumey - Lopen
[0] Chris - (Ulti)
[0] Marth - (Peaf), (Lopen)

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia - Topic 4: 2D or not 2D
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 11:42:07 AM
#477
https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/80433002

Am on phone so forgive the inconsistent formatting

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia Topic 5 - Running on Batteries
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 11:41:25 AM
#1
Player List

1) Peace___Frog
2) UltimaterializerX
3) htaeD
4) MZero
5) Corrik7
6) wallmasterz
7) ctesjbuvf
8) Obellisk
9) EDumey
10) TheSultanOfSlam
11) SirChris
12) Lopen
13) UnderUrMattress

With 13 alive, it takes 7 to lynch. Day ends at 7PM EST on Friday, ~31.3 hours from now.

---
~Peaf~
TopicVideo Game Console Mafia - Topic 4: 2D or not 2D
Peace___Frog
05/04/23 11:38:35 AM
#473
wallmasterz posted...
Oh I thought you meant opening my heart to the third person not being doctor. You meant opening my heart to there not being a doctor at all. Uhhhh I guess?
Both, or either :)

---
~Peaf~
Board List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5, 6, 7, 8