Lurker > Terra-enforcer

LurkerFAQs, Active DB, DB1, DB2, DB3, Database 4 ( 07.23.2018-12.31.2018 ), DB5, DB6, DB7, DB8, DB9, DB10, DB11, DB12, Clear
Board List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 2 - The Castle of Lust
Terra-enforcer
12/17/18 8:07:27 PM
#147
also on Reg there were a few smaller weird things I noticed like
HanOfTheNekos posted...
Reg posted...

Hbthebattle posted...
This play from red and Scare feels a lot different than last games where they only became super active once accused. I think both seem pretty Town.

Definitely agree with this. Moreso on Scare than Red, but not hugely so.


Did you follow the last mafia game?

this which just makes it seem like he was reaching to justify following the same beat as several others, but in this case if you just read these posts and consider Reg hasn't played in "5 years" this makes much less sense.

@Sheep007 you were convinced Hb was sure fire town before, but what are your thoughts now? Between his more questionable push on eaed and hiding behind the "new player" excuse, wouldn't say he looks so straightforward anymore.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 2 - The Castle of Lust
Terra-enforcer
12/17/18 8:00:41 PM
#141
Oh forgot to lay the hammer down. ##Vote: Reg
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 2 - The Castle of Lust
Terra-enforcer
12/17/18 7:59:48 PM
#140
Personally I'm still not feeling the eaed lynch, but I could definitely go for a Reg push. I didn't like his push for IGCD. It felt very weak, and he really tried making a push over the joke phase of the day. His MZero vote still doesn't make any sense to me, and almost signifies to me if Reg is indeed scum that IGCD was just a failed lynch so he wanted to look like he was putting pressure elsewhere. Which also makes me question would a scum Reg pass up the opportunity to bus eaed if he is assumed to be scum as well? It would make more sense than randomly voting an inactive late into the first half of the day when main lynches were already being formed.

Also side note, but DYL is going under the radar heavy. This is his only post so far and it's pretty bad.

Dark Young Link posted...
Just kidding.

But I will throw down a ##Vote: IGCD.

Dude is just shitting around. I feel like he's trying to follow Scare's pace. The only difference is... Scare is actually engaging people. Scare is actually giving his thoughts about players. IGCD is not.


Seems like just an excuse to bandwagon, especially since IGCD managed to start playing a bit more seriously by the time this post was made. He throws shade at IGCD for his "shitting around" when he's at least managing to post his thoughts as opposed to sitting back all day.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse
Terra-enforcer
12/17/18 4:53:07 PM
#377
Sheep007 posted...
Wait MZero is in this game

Also HB is town guys I know it's early but please don't derp and lynch him late on.

You going to give us reasons as to why we shouldn't? And I find it interesting that you randomly single him out in particular. Not as if he's been some major point of contention.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse
Terra-enforcer
12/17/18 4:50:37 PM
#376
red13n posted...
Scare should absolutely not be getting a clear from anyone btw. He basically took most of the game to commit to playing out of his box. It doesn't line up with his town or scumplay. Its a total null tell.

I'm not just referring to the most recent game. I know I've played at least one more game with scum Scare and I recall him being similarly reclusive. Here he was the first one to stick out his neck and for reasons I already said before I think it's worth crediting him for. Even since then nothing in particular lines up as "scummy" so far, so he's definitely a town lean in my book.

Obviously it's foolish to outright saw "omg must be town for sure" but I don't see what's wrong in aligning his current play with leaning on the town side more than scum.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse
Terra-enforcer
12/17/18 4:38:35 PM
#374
HanOfTheNekos posted...
Terra-enforcer posted...
Jeez the day just started and we're already 100 posts in. Y'all aren't playing huh.

Trying to watch CapCup finals so I'll be in and out. But so far seems to be the same three or four faces making all the posts right now.


Terra's first post- not damning, but I dont like the verbiage with the complaint about activity and then double excuse for activity.

Terra-enforcer posted...
Hbthebattle posted...
I thought people would be a least a little more wary of "X OF CONFIRMED TOWN" after last time

I mean it's bound to happen where you play a game where you're completely right then another where your "confirmed town list" is very wrong. Nature of the game, and it's not like last game was the first game for most of us. But this right now is just a case of Scare being Scare, though I'm inclined to believe he's town because of it.


Then this post which is... fluff defense of book of confirmed town? Or explanation for failure? Then just kinda handwave for Scare and puts a loose Townread on him.

Before I made my posts on Reg and Eaed, I felt more confident on Terra, so I think my gut is more convinced than my brain. But my gut is usually right so *shrug*

No complaints, just an observation. And explanation doesn't equal an excuse.

And to the second point, deeming that post fluff doesn't make much sense. I was justifying the principal of making a reads list, and that no one but scum knows each player's alignment so you're almost guaranteed to be wrong at some point, this much is fact. And I thought the Scare read was more evident since most of us here have played with him, but at the time it was a reference to him actually reaching out and playing and scum hunting rather than lurking and waiting to respond to someone taking the initiative first as I've seen him frequently do as scum. To a lesser extent the referenced "book of confirmed town" which is definitely a pretty bold action coming from him this early as scum are often slower to pull the trigger on "confirming" others as town.

Red looked better to me upon rereading for similar reasons. He actually seems invested from the jump unlike the times I've seen him as scum. Plus early breadcrumbing and of a very specific character definitely give him a pretty big edge.

IGCD people are definitely looking too much into. Fluff and shitposting in the early game are nothing new to him in particular. And if you actually read his posts, they're interspersed with some level of intent to play as we should such as calling out eaed and plum. Doesn't help that none of the votes on him look particularly good to begin with.

I can feel the eaed vibes because of how defensive he's being and his rather weak logic while voting someone, but I'm going to have to mill over that one some more.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse
Terra-enforcer
12/16/18 10:05:18 PM
#141
Hbthebattle posted...
I thought people would be a least a little more wary of "X OF CONFIRMED TOWN" after last time

I mean it's bound to happen where you play a game where you're completely right then another where your "confirmed town list" is very wrong. Nature of the game, and it's not like last game was the first game for most of us. But this right now is just a case of Scare being Scare, though I'm inclined to believe he's town because of it.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse
Terra-enforcer
12/16/18 9:16:42 PM
#99
ScareChan posted...
Hbthebattle posted...
I mean I dont blame him after last game


this is in reference to what

The "mason buddies" thing from last game where one of you ended up being scum, and I'm sure you of all people know how that ended.
---
TopicPersona 5 Mafia Topic 1 - Enter the Metaverse
Terra-enforcer
12/16/18 9:14:58 PM
#97
Jeez the day just started and we're already 100 posts in. Y'all aren't playing huh.

Trying to watch CapCup finals so I'll be in and out. But so far seems to be the same three or four faces making all the posts right now.
---
TopicArti Presents: greengravy294's Persona 5 Mafia
Terra-enforcer
12/16/18 7:59:09 PM
#127
Oh good I'm not late this time lol. Don't go onto gamefaqs as much anymore so I always forget to check in when the game starts.
---
TopicArti Presents: greengravy294's Persona 5 Mafia
Terra-enforcer
12/15/18 8:32:45 PM
#114
Confirmmy
---
TopicArti Presents: greengravy294's Persona 5 Mafia
Terra-enforcer
12/15/18 4:26:42 PM
#84
IfGodCouldDie posted...
So my son got run over today.

Wait...what?
---
TopicViolent rapist escapes from prison while the guard was watching porn + baseball.
Terra-enforcer
12/15/18 10:28:05 AM
#11
Now this is a story you dont hear every day.
---
TopicSpiderVerse is DEFINITELY a better film than Homecoming, and I loved the Latter.
Terra-enforcer
12/15/18 12:03:34 AM
#4
Yeah I loved the movie. The animation and artstyle are both sublime and worth watching just for that alone. The likeable characters and story (whilst admittedly generic) only further the appeal. Would definitely recommend to anyone. Hopefully Miles's interpretation in the MCU is done just as well.
---
TopicBlack South African politician urges followers to kill whites.
Terra-enforcer
12/14/18 10:53:55 PM
#224
And the bait topic worked lol
---
TopicPSA: The host I use for imgtc has decided to shut it off
Terra-enforcer
12/14/18 11:18:34 AM
#63
Wow that's some BS. Thanks for your hard work tho TC
---
TopicRunning from battle should be 100% guaranteed and instant.
Terra-enforcer
12/13/18 1:19:40 PM
#32
Facts. Being forced to commit literally does nothing to add to the experience and is more of a time waster than anything else.
---
TopicJust finished my Calc 3 exam and am currently dead inside, AMA
Terra-enforcer
12/12/18 8:13:13 PM
#15
Took Calc 3 four years ago and I don't remember a damn thing lol. At least it's over and unless you're a math major you probably won't deal with it again in your life.
---
TopicArti Presents: greengravy294's Persona 5 Mafia
Terra-enforcer
12/12/18 5:44:49 PM
#22
P5? Hell yeah. I'm in.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia ENDGAME
Terra-enforcer
12/10/18 4:52:51 PM
#37
DoomTheGyarados posted...
Yes, you do, considering I caught two scum hopping to the town inactive but you (and no one else) seemed bothered to realize it was a town/scum lynch which meant votals matter. But tell me more how nothing could have been learned from that lynch.

That was definitely mentioned several times. I know I specifically had it in my notes, but I didn't have a chance to say it because someone had already made the point.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/10/18 6:44:36 AM
#480
DoomTheGyarados posted...
Sixthly, which my word processor tells me is not a word, if you don't have time to play don't sign up. Town lost this game because Terra could not play properly. I am not saying Terra made bad decisions, but it is unacceptable for so much time to pass and for a player to be unavailable. It's just not. If Terra counters that same day Pen dies, flips Untrackable, and Bat is confirmed because Untrackable is the counter to his role and the game plays out much differently. Instead a slot goes silent and town makes a poor decision because of it.

It was definitely my bad for not being here (as I said in game I literally COULD NOT post here at the time) but I call bullshit on town losing solely due to that. There were a lot of weird decisions from town this game, and you don't lose by a single action at the tail end of the game. I was clearly more active in the early game, it was only towards the end of last week where I became more busy than expected, so it's not like I was coasting the whole game and expected to be this absent. And at the time someone mentioned there was no replacing out so I assumed there was some board rule against it until I saw Harris do it.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/10/18 6:36:24 AM
#479
Wait wait, I was the one who was lynched? lol what even

Town played a really weird game this go around. As I said several times in the game I was busy irl so it is my bad for not being as engaged as I would have liked to be, but my lynch, Han's, and Pirate's choices were all so weird.

But overall GG of course. Couldn't plas as much as I wanted to, but this game was interesting to say the least. If we have another game in a week or so after I'm done with finals I'll definitely be more active as I usually like to be.

Also props to Geno for that weird flavor meta claim that really worked out in your favor. Your activity was way less than I expected from you, but I basically had you written off because of the claim.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/09/18 5:46:28 PM
#270
TheSultanOfSlam posted...
So my claim basically was trying to help pirate decide who to scan so I was like you're between these people you can narrow it down one beacuse I am Miller and it come back inconclusive. And I thought nothing of Geno already claiming Miller beacuse I thought it's very possible to have 2 millers I've been on games where they have 2 of the same role before

I am Pokeman trainer Veteran Miller

Two millers though? It's extremely uncommon at best, and I'm finding it harder to believe you over Geno when you didn't seem to bat an eye to his claim.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/09/18 5:42:47 PM
#269
Okay I'm not going to be able to be around much again, so I want to make sure my vote is in so some nonsense doesn't happen like yesterday (which is a lot due to my own fault for not being here to post but can't do much about that now).

##Vote: Pendragon
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/09/18 10:07:32 AM
#255
Pendragon71037 posted...
Lolo, Sultan, Terra, and Geno.

Huh, so Lolo and/or Sultan are most likely scum. Thanks for sharing so we get something out of this lynch since I'm probably dead tonight.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/09/18 10:06:04 AM
#254
Forceful_Dragon posted...
Terra-enforcer posted...
I don't this is the case, but major props to the scum team if they seriously decided against nk'ing one night so I'd falsely assume I protected the claimed cop and subsequently waste all my shots protecting a fakeclaimed cop. Harris's picks for scans are almost too coincidentally bad.


This is nearly exactly how I feel about Shonen. Unfortunately it was a trap, but alas.

And just to clarify, Terra, you are titled pi spells, not you are actually a doctor yes?

Because that's still a ****ing LOT of protection. Like a lot. And we haven't even seen evidence of a scum power outside of the jack.

I am doctor. The "doctor" is in parenthesis after the title I claimed before (PSI Shield).
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/09/18 10:02:00 AM
#252
@Pirate_Harris posted...
Terra-enforcer posted...
Pirate_Harris posted...
Pend is obvious scum and it would be a waste of a scan if I did it on him

What was your reason for not voting him yesterday then??? I don't see obvious scum and go for the claimed scanning role instead.

Because I bought his doc claim which by the way you didn't counter at all as ben was claiming you did...

This makes no sense wtf? That's literally the point I was making. Is he "obvious scum" or is he "doc"? You can't play both cards and act like you knew the entire time when your vote was on the claimed scanner. If you bought his claim then you should have scanned him or me to confirm.

Aaaaand I'm just reading that he replaced out. Wow what timing.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 2:19:37 PM
#217
Pirate_Harris posted...
Pend is obvious scum and it would be a waste of a scan if I did it on him

What was your reason for not voting him yesterday then??? I don't see obvious scum and go for the claimed scanning role instead.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 10:57:03 AM
#202
Pirate_Harris posted...
##vote: pend

I scanned ben he was obviously innocent... smh

How the heck are you choosing your picks for scanning? At first I thought you had good reason for your picks, but this pattern just looks like you take names from a hat. How the heck did you not scan Lolo who most people suspected? Hell, I wouldn't have batted an eye if you chose me or Pend since that's a logical choice given you seemed not convinced on lynching him yesterday. Ben wouldn't be a bad pick, but he shouldn't have been higher priority over several others.

I don't this is the case, but major props to the scum team if they seriously decided against nk'ing one night so I'd falsely assume I protected the claimed cop and subsequently waste all my shots protecting a fakeclaimed cop. Harris's picks for scans are almost too coincidentally bad.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 10:50:13 AM
#201
hombad46 posted...
Voting now only gives others a chance to """accidentally""" hammer which we don't need happening just yet.


I just noticed this part of Terras message while I was typing that last one. What do you mean by we dont need it happening just yet? Why would the town ever need it to happen? I really dont want to take a side in Terra vs Pen without a scan, but with a slip like that... hm.

Allowing something to occur =/= needing it to happen. We've had hammers this game already. Hammers aren't inherently bad, but it was bad in that scenario when we were just beginning the day and in before any of the roles were able to report their actions iirc.

But yeah you're right on calling me out on the vote. There's far fewer players required to lynch now and I didn't realize how many people were on it at the time.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 10:45:33 AM
#200
hombad46 posted...
Terra-enforcer posted...
Also chill with the Pend votes now. I think we're already at L-1.


You say this yet you dont remove your own vote. Hm....

I mean as long as no one else votes we're fine, but you're right in that we're better safe than sorry.

##Unvote
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 10:18:19 AM
#190
Also chill with the Pend votes now. I think we're already at L-1.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 10:17:30 AM
#189
geno4smash4 posted...
I'll also vote Sultan for obvious reasons.
##Vote:Sultan
Pend is like 99% scum at this point but Sultan is 100% scum for me.

You have a counterclaim for a fake doctor and you go for a pure gut read? Come on man. Even if Sultan looked bad, Pend has looked bad for far longer and there's no way in hell we have two docs, roleblocker, and BG. It's no 99%, it's 100%.

I was in the middle of something when Pend fake claimed so I was more impulsive and reactionary than I should have been, but it's pretty clear that like I said, it was an act to bait out the actual doc so they can get a clean shot.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 6:10:21 AM
#181
oh and of course ##Vote: Pendragon
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 9: Invasion Of The Clones
Terra-enforcer
12/08/18 6:10:09 AM
#180
Sorry for going silent most of yesterday. As I said before I was just really busy irl (it's finals week) and it was too late by the time I realized I couldn't post again.

But yeah, since we're to that point, Pend is 100% lying because I'm Ness VETERAN PSI Shield. One reason I alluded to before but wasn't here to expound upon was that I believed Shonen more after his seemingly weird claim of "Sleep" instead of "Rest" is because my ability is also similar to a move my character has in Smash without exactly being part of his moveset. Subtle, but I did think it helped his case.

I've also been leaving heavy hints towards being the doc since the jump. One of my most used words this game has been doc/doctor, and some of my responses to Harris the night he was fearful of being killed were directly responsive as coming from a doc. I was also slightly ticked and vocalized my frustrations in this thread when Death died N2 being N1 I tried to protect him since he was a much stronger town read while I felt much less certain about Chris. I also said something to the effect that if I were protection I wouldn't have protected Chris N1 either in response to Han not doing so either so I could breadcrumb my actions a bit more.

So yeah, if you look back I've hinted towards Death N1, and Harris every day since. Harris is almost certainly not scum. I protected him when there was no nk, so unless scum intentionally skipped a day, it doesn't add up.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 8:19:11 PM
#158
Lolo_Guru posted...
Rather than yelling to the rooftops that you want the game to think you're doctor, Terra, couldn't you answer my question, please?

That's not what I'm doing, I just don't want the actual doc to fall for the counterclaim since we have shit like Harris claiming cop because he thought he was smooth and able to push Scare into a corner.

And I've had Ben firmly in my mixed category, and even openly stated that aside from specific instances I almost wanted to put him into town lean. So not sure where you see the scum bud connection in my reads. I will admit that you are among my weaker reads that I plan to expound upon later if given the chance, but I stand by the scum lean (just not as much as Scare when he was around or Pend currently). I've just been inactive because of irl stuff coming at me from all sides recently.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 8:08:21 PM
#155
Man, I'm really mad at myself for not posting in this thread this literal event happening before hand because I halfway expected something like this to occur. Pend pushed against the wall and scum can't progress without safely killing our scanner, so they counter claim doc since Pend is halfway on the scaffolding anyway so they can off our remaining protection. Better move than the Scare response I will admit, but I hope the result doesn't turn out to be the same.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 8:02:50 PM
#154
hombad46 posted...
TheSultanOfSlam posted...
Blah it's a confusing situation I feel like this scum team must be pretty dumb not to kill a doctor if they knew he was doctor and they would have assumed he would protect pirate.... ugh this is so confusing

Wait where are you getting that scum knew he was Doctor?

This is also partly my question. But more to Pend since he seems to think most people assumed his was doctor, which clearly isn't the case based on how many people scum read him and considering the number of votes on him at the moment.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 7:58:59 PM
#152
Pendragon71037 posted...
All right, first off, Im sorry. I waited until after work because I wanted several hours in a row to defend myself further, but turns out Im going to a family dinner so thats not gonna happen, and with one thing and another I wouldnt have that sort of opportunity until tomorrow afternoon. So, sorry, but this is gonna he a post-and-run.

Im not Yoshi, VETERAN Vanilla
As some of you have begun to suspect, Im Yoshi, VETERAN Egg Lay (Doctor).
N1, I tried to protect Chris. I say tried, because SOMEONE decided to roleblock me. Although, looking at Scares flip, it may not have mattered anyway- if I were Scum, I would absolutely strongman him N1. But still.
N2 and N3, I protected Harris. Youre welcome.

If you look back on the previous days, youll see that I didnt really try to defend myself against people who said I was scummy. That was intentional (although, admittedly, them finding me scummy in the first place wasnt). Essentially, my plan was, if Scum thought Town thought I was Scum, theyd leave me alive, and I could continue to protect.

And now, I have to leave again. Sorry.

This is so bad. He's clearly trying to bait out the actual doc into a counterclaim. How desperate lol. I hope no one falls for such a terrible ruse.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 7:17:35 PM
#145
hombad46 posted...
Actually I guess that's an important point, are scum allowed to talk to their scummates post-mortem in games on this forum?

Normally they are, yes. But that prospect hardly hinges on Scare communicating with them.

I'll give you that such a conclusion is very logical, but for now I'm choosing to take it at face value, partly for personal reasons. But regardless, if scum has no strongman or ability to overcome a doc or a roleblock, Harris pretty much has free reign. Plus Shonen's actions will catch up to him if he chooses to target according to what would make sense for a scum team to target over what lines up with the reads he vocalizes.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 7:12:59 PM
#144
TheSultanOfSlam posted...
No one wants to pressure terra with me well okay... terra since you are around who do we go after in your opinion who isnt Pen

Not only have I made that pretty clear multiple times throughout day 2 and 3, a mere four posts above this question I pretty clearly restate the next person in my line of sight.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 5:46:40 PM
#138
Hbthebattle posted...
For the record, Geno has never fully explained why he suspects me beyond his claim is weird. I dont know why hes so suddenly fixated on me.

tbf, that is a valid complaint. As I've reiterated upon, our team seems stacked and not every claim is out there yet. If Pend and Lolo both turn out to be scum, my first thought would be to reread the claimed PRs if the game doesn't end there.

Or I might go back to ben \_()_/
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 5:42:29 PM
#137
The people seriously defending Pend are beyond me. Some of the excuses are a bit ridiculous. He was already a high priority lynch pick who hasn't contributed to much, and his role claim just incriminated him further. I'm not voting anyone else and not Shonen of all people.

TheSultanOfSlam posted...
##vote:Terra

I want to see his claim I think this is our other scum member

Ouchie that hwurt :(

My guy, even if I were scum I wouldn't have the slightest fear in my mind about you considering Pend basically gave himself up for offering. Already said my role is confirmable, so calm down there. I'm in no rush whatsoever.

And @Pirate_Harris why don't you just choose someone who has been on multiple people's scum lists if you can't decide for yourself? I want to drop names, but I almost feel like the scum team might have a forger. That, or Hb is lying (which goes entirely against my current read of him). I didn't even mention vig before when talking about how stacked we are, and they seemingly lack roleblocker and even a secondary kill, so they have to be packing something. My other thought as a significant buff would be something like an arsonist, but no one has claimed to be doused, and even something like bomb isn't a significant blow against a team this stacked if we're blindly assume everyone is who they claim to be.

Oh yeah, and to the people who pointed out the roleblocker comment, obviously I'm not referring to a simple ass one shot and done roleblocker. I mean a dedicated role since that's something that can consistently deal a blow to us.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 5:22:44 PM
#134
Forceful_Dragon posted...
What do you mean the chance of scum Shonen "getting it right"?

Given the context I thought it was clear. I mean "get it right" as in "predict who the true doctor is" assuming he were scum.

benjamin3740 posted...
Why would scum sleep with pirate the same night they're killing him?

Don't even know how I forgot about this. You're right, I was pretty sure before due to the claim, but now Shonen is pretty much confirmed town.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 11:25:31 AM
#5
Also for a scum team that seemingly lacks a roleblocker, town seems stacked as hell by comparison. Lightning Rod, two scanners, roleblocker, BG, protection of some kind, and whatever else has yet to be claimed.
---
TopicSmash Ultimate Mafia Topic 8: FREE FOR ALL
Terra-enforcer
12/05/18 11:19:55 AM
#4
Lolo_Guru posted...
Yeah, Shonen is confirmed prostitute.

One extra day of prostitute scanning (if Shonen's scum) won't matter very much. Let's put it this way: if Shonen outs the doctor by scanning one of the claimed vanillas and telling us he moved, so be it?

Although; Shonen, may I ask what was running through your head when you decided to scan Scare N2?

Still of the mind that Lolo is scum, but I had the same thought. If Pend didn't look bad enough before, his botched claim should be the end of him. There's still quite a few vanillas/unclaimed roles out there so chances of a scum Shonen getting it right are still relatively low.

On another note, the "weird" part of Shonen's claim makes him more believable than anything else for me personally. Pend's botch, according to ben, is a result of him attempting to give too much information which straight up contradicted set information. But Shonen's claim only appears to be weird by flavor meta. In no circumstance would it make sense to lynch Shonen over Pend.

##Vote: Pend
---
Board List
Page List: 1, 2, 3, 4, 5