Lurker > Corrik7

PunishedBen posted... It's not that he's host confirmed, I just don't think Kirby would ask the question he did as scum

3 scum would mean game is lost on two mislynches which seemed way too low to me. Plus the way the host said At least one role was removed I thought implied more than one, and if you remove cop you might as well remove godfather and vice versa. So I thought it was 2 scum and I'm the only power role

PunishedBen posted... I'm not into the idea at all. If we're so sure scum can find the cop why can't they just as easily find the doctor? It will be even easier to find one with one person claimed to be not doctor and as soon as the doctor dies scum knows exactly who the cop is. The math makes zero sense to me

PunishedBen posted... Discussing what power roles are in the game I don't think is a good idea this early. But I do think it's 2 scum. Isquen is probably town for assuming otherwise

UltimaterializerX posted... I dont think Kirby is town, but the self vote defeatism isnt something I like seeing in mafia and we need to go back to not allowing that junk. Its an extra layer of chaotic nonsense that games dont need.

I like Stu as town. Hard read. I think hes already made more posts this game by himself than him + IGCD combined total in the last one.

Are you referring to me asking about the hammer? Listen, I'm a bit of a prankster, but I'd like to think I'm not a completely idiot. You'd know that about me more than anyone else.

I'd be totally down to vote myself for the meme, but not at town's expense. I wanted to make sure I didn't accidentally hammer. As far as I could tell, the number of votes needed for a hammer wasn't in the opening post at all.

Eh...

Again I think we can deal with this if it happens. Seems extremely unlikely

And you would have another scan that could nail scum and Ben is also scum

I think Ulti is a good enough player that trying to meta his list of possible scum isn't worthwhile. Not sure I understand the second question. Are you referring to today? Because I think there has been enough day left that we can't infer what Ulti would actually do as scum yet.

And you would have another scan that could nail scum and Ben is also scum

And if both you and Ben are alive tomorrow then I think its counter claim time.

But I think the odds that this resolves itself are good enough that a counter here is a bad idea, because if there is a counter it means there is definitely at least one goon left that isn't the doctor claim which means your scans are still valuable which means we want the doctor protecting you in secret at least one more night

I don't think this is worth worrying about at this point. Knowing exact numbers doesn't change the optimal play today

Completely agree with this. If Ben is scum then claiming doc here to try to bait out a doc counter makes a ton of sense, but with this being open setup this is pretty cut and dry. Scum can't leave Corrik alive and if Corrik dies tonight then Ben is scum.

Ben, if you don't save Corrik you are getting insta lynched. If you are town, don't try to overthink this.

Oh,

DO NOT COUNTER THIS DOC

If Ben is lying and there is a Doc out there countering here is super stupid for a host of reasons. Feel free to counter this tomorrow.

Not liking Sbell backstabbing me here and I feel like his last post was trying to fish out my claim. What else you want from me, Sbell?

Yeah its Stu/Plum/Sultan. Me/Ben reeks of a town/town manipulative lynch to set up for a scum win tomorrow.

My vote only goes to one of those three players. Not switching to Ben even for self preservation reasons.

You know what bothers me?

When did self voting become unband?

Ctes godfather sure wouldn't surprise me just saying!

That is actually a good point does not help i have both in my scum pile but I lean more Ulti..

Also for those voting Ben why?

Tbh the self vote is the only thing that makes me think he is not scum

Btw, if Ulti is scum, Kirby is town.

Ulti said he is tired of seeing this TOWN self-vote defeatism in games. Just fyi.