IGN complains about survival and mystery instead of dating sim in SMTV

Current Events

Page of 2
Current Events » IGN complains about survival and mystery instead of dating sim in SMTV




Yes. In this post-apocalyptic world, why can't we date teenagers and cancel our gym teachers? Why are these demons trying to kill me and angels trying to end the world?

Video game journalism btw
"Iwata was awesome" - Mr. Nintendo
https://imgur.com/krtFHol
This IGNoble IGNoramous has IGNited my ire.
signature cannot be displayed on account of society
7/10
Too much apocalypse
It does kind of annoy me when reviewers review SMT as if it should be Persona.

You may as well complain that Fallout isn't enough Elder Scrolls. They're different series with differing elements.
Its not an apocalypse without waifus and husbandos!
The Official Odin of the Shin Megami Tensei IV board.
"You know how confusing the whole good-evil concept is for me."
Face it, shen megami tenshen whatever is a stupid weeb name.
The greatest Warcraft hero ever my queen the black lady Sylvanas Windrunner:
https://imgur.com/J9Vhyjv
Esrac posted...
It does kind of annoy me when reviewers review SMT as if it should be Persona.

You may as well complain that Fallout isn't enough Elder Scrolls. They're different series with differing elements.
At least they're lucky they released before Persona 5, or western reviewers will be complaining why something something Persona 5
"Iwata was awesome" - Mr. Nintendo
https://imgur.com/krtFHol
The end of the world is the ideal time for dating actually. I hope the protagonist gets laid, could be his last chance.
My maid will hear about this.
It doesn't say anything about dating.

I don't really get why SMT fans are acting like this is the only series in history that is criticized for a heavy focus on combat instead of story.

Esrac posted...
You may as well complain that Fallout isn't enough Elder Scrolls. They're different series with differing elements.

Fallout was criticized for being Oblivion with Guns at the time lol

Starfield is going to be compared to both.

People complained that Fallout 76 didn't have NPC's even though it was a multiplayer game.
A Fallen Mascot
BloodMoon7 posted...
The end of the world is the ideal time for dating actually. I hope the protagonist gets laid, could be his last chance.

i disagree looking video game masterpiece FFVII. Cloud waited until after Sephiroth dropped multiple meteors on him to fuck Tifa.
The greatest Warcraft hero ever my queen the black lady Sylvanas Windrunner:
https://imgur.com/J9Vhyjv
Dakimakura posted...
Face it, shen megami tenshen whatever is a stupid weeb name.

And your name isnt?
Zikten posted...
And your name isnt?

I am just saying, non weebs are going to be turned off by the name.
The greatest Warcraft hero ever my queen the black lady Sylvanas Windrunner:
https://imgur.com/J9Vhyjv
Oh they were COMPLAINING about SURVIVAL themes
"Why is ontology so expensive?" - JH
[Is this live?][Joyless planet...]
Dakimakura posted...


I am just saying, non weebs are going to be turned off by the name.

Well the game was named by Japanese people. Japanese people aren't weebs they are just Japanese. The only other option they had was to change the title but they probably feel that the type of person to play these games like the Japanese name
True Goddess Reincarnation V.
Favorite Games: BlazBlue: Central Fiction, Street Fighter III: Third Strike, Bayonetta, Bloodborne
thats a username you habe - chuckyhacksss
Zikten posted...
Well the game was named by Japanese people. Japanese people aren't weebs they are just Japanese. The only other option they had was to change the title but they probably feel that the type of person to play these games like the Japanese name
What's the English name? Death Goddess Heaven Slash? Based on my anime knowledge, this is the translation for ShinMegumin.
My maid will hear about this.
ssjevot posted...
New Goddess Reincarnation V.

Goddess Reincarnation does sound like a badass name for a series.
A Fallen Mascot
ssjevot posted...
True Goddess Reincarnation V.
Oh. Well I was close.
My maid will hear about this.
Post #19 was unavailable or deleted.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=errvM1PvMbQ
We all live in a Yellow SUV! a Yellow SUV!
Punished_Blinx posted...
Goddess Reincarnation does sound like a badass name for a series.
Honestly, not even false. That is a pretty sick name (though lul SMT hasn't been about a goddess reincarnating for quite a long time by now)
"Iwata was awesome" - Mr. Nintendo
https://imgur.com/krtFHol
Japan : Like a Dragon

America :Yakuza

7th game title in America : Yakuza Like a Dragon
We all live in a Yellow SUV! a Yellow SUV!
YellowSUV posted...
Japan : Like a Dragon

America :Yakuza

7th game title in America : Yakuza Like a Dragon
SMTVII: True Goddess Reincarnation
"Iwata was awesome" - Mr. Nintendo
https://imgur.com/krtFHol
Post #24 was unavailable or deleted.
cuh posted...

lol @ pokemon-like

Atlus cries in Hyrdox cookie.
We all live in a Yellow SUV! a Yellow SUV!
mainline SMT is literally just persona but with less features tho

it's like if you took the mapping+exploration out of etrian odyssey or all the cutscenes out of mgs4
Mainline SMT was originally a dungeon crawler like Etrian Odyssey. People aren't buying SMT for the visual novel parts. Persona was a spin-off from SMT If... Because people liked the classroom setting. Persona 1 was still a dungeon crawler but then it became very story and character focussed in 2 and was in the modern story and characters first format by 3. SMT has a lot more focus on dungeons and combat and some people like that. It isn't a bad thing to not have constant exposition and character development. I don't want that in every game. Like did you want more story and character development in Mario Odyssey? Would that have made the game better?
Favorite Games: BlazBlue: Central Fiction, Street Fighter III: Third Strike, Bayonetta, Bloodborne
thats a username you habe - chuckyhacksss
ssjevot posted...
Mainline SMT was originally a dungeon crawler like Etrian Odyssey. People aren't buying SMT for the visual novel parts. Persona was a spin-off from SMT If... Because people liked the classroom setting. Persona 1 was still a dungeon crawler but then it became very story and character focussed in 2 and was in the modern story and characters first format by 3. SMT has a lot more focus on dungeons and combat and some people like that. It isn't a bad thing to not have constant exposition and character development. I don't want that in every game. Like did you want more story and character development in Mario Odyssey? Would that have made the game better?

There was this time where gamers, reviewers and developers did indeed think adding story, character development and 'mature' themes was something platformers should have lol
A Fallen Mascot
I feel like all reviewers use the same talking points. Dunkey got it right.

this game really makes you feel like persona 5
Punished_Blinx posted...
There was this time where gamers, reviewers and developers did indeed think adding story, character development and 'mature' themes was something platformers should have lol

Shadow the Hedgehog? Man don't remind me...
Favorite Games: BlazBlue: Central Fiction, Street Fighter III: Third Strike, Bayonetta, Bloodborne
thats a username you habe - chuckyhacksss
Punished_Blinx posted...
It doesn't say anything about dating.

I don't really get why SMT fans are acting like this is the only series in history that is criticized for a heavy focus on combat instead of story.

Fallout was criticized for being Oblivion with Guns at the time lol

Starfield is going to be compared to both.

People complained that Fallout 76 didn't have NPC's even though it was a multiplayer game.

cause it was an incredibly stupid decision, evidenced by the fact they added them in. What other multiplayer RPG doesnt have NPCs?

Typical gameFAQers are "Complainers that always complain about those who complain about real legitimate complaints."-Joker_X
Punished_Blinx posted...
There was this time where gamers, reviewers and developers did indeed think adding story, character development and 'mature' themes was something platformers should have lol
Super Mario Galaxy?
When Kaidou fails to keep up with Luffy in their next fight remember this conversation - MrDrMan
YellowSUV posted...
Japan : Like a Dragon

America :Yakuza

7th game title in America : Yakuza Like a Dragon

That's why I always call it Like a Dragon: Like a Dragon
Roxas
that's a stick
Kaiganeer posted...
mainline SMT is literally just persona but with less features tho

it's like if you took the mapping+exploration out of etrian odyssey or all the cutscenes out of mgs4

Not true, and SMT is especially not without it's own perks over Persona anyway. In SMT area design, exploration, gameplay pacing, party customization and challenge are better at the expense of some Persona's exclusive mechanics and features such as it's calendar and time frame system, and the ins and outs of the high school / free time slice of life routine between dungeons. So in SMTV you don't have to worry about doing dungeon runs in a single afternoon so you can devote more free time to grinding social links / confidants ranks, or your own social skills, like optimal play dictates, nor are you forced to wait for certain dates, weeks in the future, hours later, just for the story to finally be able to progress.
I don't get why people are mad at a reviewers opinion

",I didn't feel any incentive whatsoever to keep playing " is completely valid

And if you're one of those "I don't care about story or characters! I just want gameplay. " people then you still get the information you want from the review

I felt the same way about Monster Hunter World. It's so boring and the fans say "Well that's by design!"
^ Hey now that's completely unfair!
https://imgur.com/yPw05Ob
Dakimakura posted...
BloodMoon7 posted...
The end of the world is the ideal time for dating actually. I hope the protagonist gets laid, could be his last chance.

i disagree looking video game masterpiece FFVII. Cloud waited until after Sephiroth dropped multiple meteors on him to fuck Tifa.

Dropping meteors? Sephiroth sounds like a ripoff of Madara from the Naruto series.
OpWarpSpeed posted...
Dropping meteors? Sephiroth sounds like a ripoff of Madara from the Naruto series.
Didn't Naruto also wait until after the war to pound Hinata? They may be on to something.
My maid will hear about this.
Post #38 was unavailable or deleted.
Fo a batch he talks about no one caring about IGN, you guys sure do love bringing their reviews up all the time. Especially if you so much as disagree with them in some way. Jesus.
I'm a little teapot blowing off steam.
https://imgur.com/pmc9XsI https://imgur.com/p6Wfowq
Dakimakura posted...
Face it, shen megami tenshen whatever is a stupid weeb name.

it basically translate to Goddess's Neo Genesis.

anyway Atlus USA is partly blame for this.
they piggybacked SMT title to market Persona 3 in the US.
Persona is part of Shin Megami Ibunroku series in Japan, not SMT.
You have the right to remain silent. Anything you posted will be misquoted, then be used against you.
http://error1355.com/ce/Ricemills.html
Geez another topic about this whining?

At least the other topic had the sense to post the entire review, not just quotes that specifically made their eyebrows catch fire.
CyricZ He/him
UnfairRepresent posted...
I don't get why people are mad at a reviewers opinion

",I didn't feel any incentive whatsoever to keep playing " is completely valid

And if you're one of those "I don't care about story or characters! I just want gameplay. " people then you still get the information you want from the review

I felt the same way about Monster Hunter World. It's so boring and the fans say "Well that's by design!"
thank you, oh my lord.
Ghosts are cool.
Ricemills posted...
it basically translate to Goddess's Neo Genesis.

No it really doesn't. The series was Megami Tensei, a novel originally. Goddess Reincarnation. Then when they wanted to separate themselves from the novel for the SFC games (the novels went in a different direction even from the original FC games) they called it . True Goddess Reincarnation. The opening for the SFC game has Steven writing code and he changes the romaji shin input first to (new) then (god) then finally to (true). Since they are all pronounced shin in Japanese you often have to change multiple kanji before you get what you want, but this was also a bit of a pun as well. Anyway from SMT onward there is no connection to the books or even goddess reincarnation, but the gameplay is similar so that's how it is.
Favorite Games: BlazBlue: Central Fiction, Street Fighter III: Third Strike, Bayonetta, Bloodborne
thats a username you habe - chuckyhacksss
it really makes you feel like persona 5
How to play Monster Hunter
Step 1: Hit the monster. Step 2: Don't get hit.
Can't believe it's not Persona. I guess you'll never see it coming.
My maid will hear about this.
so this game is like Persona without the high school social part?
ZevLoveDOOM posted...
so this game is like Persona without the high school social part?

No Persona is SMT with added social aspects from P3 onwards. But yes kind of.
A garbage pod!? It's a smegging garbage pod!
Persona is a watered down SMT with dating sim mechanics. You get shittier dungeons, worse designed bosses, worse battle system, less demon variety (though I guess this is give or take), less complex story. Persona does have more relatable and better developed characters, but that's a side benefit of the dating sim.
"Iwata was awesome" - Mr. Nintendo
https://imgur.com/krtFHol
IGN gave it an 8/10 and people are still mad.
This is just like the 8.8 incident
Background_Guy posted...
IGN gave it an 8/10 and people are still mad.
This is just like the 8.8 incident
lol
^ Hey now that's completely unfair!
https://imgur.com/yPw05Ob
Current Events » IGN complains about survival and mystery instead of dating sim in SMTV
Page of 2