Board 8 > Friends Mafia Topic 1 - The One In Memory of Matthew Perry

(+) Yeah! (+)

This is a weird post.

why would it be a clever fake miller claim?

I did wonder if Dumey shifted the conversation to sitcoms because he felt selfconscious about his post.
I also would like to know if Blade actually backed off from Dumey back there.

I was thinking you were town but this post is more speculative than nft's.

My new approach to this game is that if the post makes no sense, then its a reference, or the post is from Sultan.

Btw Sbells question is good and Dumey should answer it.

Why would you think this?

if all of Town are ex lovers

Town roles are all love interests of the main characters at some point in the series, big or small

where is this coming from

Oh I just outted myself not reading the first post nice

Which part?

The part I qouted.

actually, after reading Sultans response i decided to just google her myself and Its not that great of a question if you know the source material i suppose.

Phoebes Twin, dated Joey, not a great person, she's an opposite of phoebe and if all of Town are ex lovers (dated Joey) then it would stand to reason that Scum is going to be actual Friends, however we have no evidence to that other than speculation. So to say that Ursula is a clever fake miller claim seems to imply soemone KNOWS that the scum team is made up of main cast friends...

So while i started this post by thinking its not such a great question afterall and i wanted to damage Death since he is acting like it really is, I think i ended up with a secure feeling that Dumey is scum.

Let me clarify. The part about thinking death is town, or the part about him being overly speculative?

I am also curious why you felt the need to type that all out, Sbell

If you still think Dumey is scum for it, seems more like you wouldn't want to give him excuses..even if you dont fully accept them already.

If its a question that Dumey cant answer without being scummy for it, I would not call it a bad question really.

I did wonder if Dumey shifted the conversation to sitcoms because he felt selfconscious about his post.
I also would like to know if Blade actually backed off from Dumey back there.

actually, after reading Sultans response i decided to just google her myself and [snip]

I did wonder if Dumey shifted the conversation to sitcoms because he felt selfconscious about his post.

I also would like to know if Blade actually backed off from Dumey back there.

I think these are both great points.

and for IGCD to post it so quickly would be a pretty bold plan for scum

Peaf, even if Death is being speculative (I'm not sure I agree with that characterization), what is inherently scummy about that? Like what makes scum speculate early D1 where Town doesn't?

Also F you for thinking me trying to engage with people in the first page when we had barely any posts is me "running" from my initial post. When have I ever run from a chance to argue about myself as either alignment? Y'all know me better than that! No one asked about why I thought it was clever before, so I didn't feel the need to force an argument about Miller role meta. I've literally gotten criticized before as town for focusing too much on Miller conversation early in the day. What do you want from me!?!?

IGCD first post'd a miller claim.

This is how you claim Miller as Town and how you fake it as Scum.

What are you even talking about?

Oh and I love open ended questions or theories. Especially if I am proven right postgame..

Then again I always forget to come back to them when postgame does come.

If it were a fake claim from scum, they may not know the flavor split. They may not have known that all of town were love interests. For scum to pick a fake claim off their safe list, post it right away, AND have it match the host-given info would either be lucky or quick thinking.

No insult to IGCD, but I don't think this is something he would have had time to discuss eith a scum board before doing so,

For scum to pick a fake claim off their safe list, post it right away, AND have it match the host-given info would either be lucky or quick thinking.