Board 8 > Blade Mafia 5 Topic 9: Cats on a Hot Tin Roof

(+) Yeah! (+)

'I've got the guts to die. What I want to know is, have you got the guts to live?'

Alive (5):

1. BCT
3. Ctes
11. Ulti
14. Death
15. Sheep

Recked:
Sultan: Dick Tracy, TOWN PT Cop (LD1)
Lea: (KD1)
SBell: Joseph Gordon-Levitt, MAFIA Looper (KN1)
Corrik: Mr. Satan, TOWN Neighbor (KN1)
EDumey: Beowulf, MAFIA Dragon Chaser (LD2)
Plum: A Buddhist Monk, TOWN Mindful (KN2)
FD: Mr. Ed, TOWN Neighbor (LD3)
Isquen: Small Town Sheriff, TOWN Jailmaster (KN3)
Peaf: Asbjorg Nesje, TOWN Death Diver (MKD4)
IGCD: Luigi, TOWN Semi-Competent Backup (MKD4)
Chang: Mr. Rogers, TOWN Neighbor (KN4)
Wall: Mr. T., TOWN Super Elite Bodyguard (LD5)
Red: Paranoid Gun Owner, TOWN Compulsive Vigilante (KN5)

With 5 alive, it takes 3 votes to Recksomeone. The day will end at 8pm EST on Thursday, October 17th.

[1] Ctes - Sheep

Heh recked

Hey, if I were that made up role, I'd also necessarily need to lynch Scum today or I'd lose. I'm just saying it because there's so many possibilities for third parties which we have literally zero knowledge about, and also because I think it'd be very, very funny if Scum shot me tonight because they thought I was telling the truth

Why would scum shoot for survivors tho?

BCTs RB could be because of bus drive wonkyness, even if thar was always weird. Or because he isn't truthful about his role. Ultis RB could also be because he isn't truthful about his role.

So there is no telling if you always get told.

Sheep read like trying to bait survivor or even lead himself to claiming it. I wouldn't consider it much.

"I would do x if scum" is more often than not scum trying to wifom out of things.

I assumed Ulti was joking because thats too gullible for him otherwise. Pity since I like serious Ulti more.

Also Ulti why did Sheep have to unvote Ctes before you made your reveal?

Hrm
Well my paranoia is that you wanted to avoid that the day would turn into Ctes VS Sheep due to BCT's reaction being unclear.
But again I admit that is not a useful paranoia to focus on today.

I was also curious why you havent voted Ctes yet despite everything you say.
Then again Ctes not voting Sheep yet is also unusual

General carefulness maybe...

I haven't voted because LYLO. I see no benefit to voting early. I'm not going to give scum a chance to end it because I voted wrong.

That one vote on Ctes shows that either Ctes or Sheep is scum, maybe even both. Let's go over this.

Death and Sheep are not scum together. Sheep could be a BP Survivor, seeing as he's not a roleblocker. With two scum remaining and this detail, I really think Ctes has to be one. Death does not feel like town today. He feels dodgy to me.

But I have a headache from this noxious odor so I can't think straight...

I think Sheep was too convinced it would be him vs me tbh when it feels like scum numbers are putting everyone back into consideration to some degree.

BCT I Already explained myself to you. What remains sketchy about me?

There is absolutely nothing that proves that

Roleblocked from the start of the night is weird. Sounds town aligned I think but no one is claiming it either.

I'm not entirely convinced I'm not simply being thrown off.

UltimaterializerX posted...

I re-read Sheep yesterday and JFC that shit looks awful.

*shocked Pikachu face*

Also you werent asked.

Plus do you really think Edumey would claim what he did if he knew my role existed?

UltimaterializerX posted...

Well someone needs to figure out something man.

I am trying to. But as far as I am concerned the day roleblock doesnt help us narrow things down.

Dumey's claim is literally what I have been saying for days was what made Death town. Can people start listening to Ctes more.

Dumey claimed he would be told if people could move or not. But Death role doesn't make that work.

The point is that Dumey fake claimed something that doesn't work with what Death's mechanics. So if Death was on the same team as Dumey, he would have fake claimed something else.

3 scum?

My argument has been that if Death is on the same team as Dumey, then scum deliberately chose to sacrifice Dumey. It's literally either that or Death is not scum with Dumey.

Missed a grand oppurtunity there to say "I get that calling Death scum is your only play."

I dont know if this purported dayblocker is connected to the presumably existent independent.
Because how would a dayblocker help with finding independents?
And besides that, why has nobody else claimed to have been dayblocked yet?

htaeD posted...

Missed a grand oppurtunity there to say "I get that calling Death scum is your only play."

Yeah but they certainly just need to get me lynched to win

If you are town yes, but if you are scum than he needs someone else.
The fact that he is even willing to consider anyone besides you or Sheep today is an alarm signal in and of itself.

Maybe they actually do think I'm the 3rd party they seem to be sp desperately looking and is just directing attention elsewhere in hopes everyone agrees I have to be scum

UltimaterializerX posted...

Im not. Already said we kill ctes no matter what.

I guess thats better
...
You said it was better to lynch me first before tho, and you also sounded like you agreed with Ctes about Sheep for one post.
Or is my sarcasm detector failing there?

but whatever. I cant get too lost in the confusion.
Already for my reread I can say I wish Sheep had entered the game earlier, since by the time he did show up Edumey and Sbell were already dead and buried.

Honestly at this rate I am wondering if you arent the independent after all, since you are all over the place.
That wouldnt be the worst outcome of course.

But if you arent scum, I do hope to gain your trust as well.

Pretty sure the smoke is weed since it feels like someone lit a skunk carcass on fire. Can't discern who's doing it just yet. Without evidence to evict, management can only send emails. So I have to figure out whose door smells like a sewer. Hopefully this person can be shown the curb swiftly, seeing as management can swiftly evict them for violating the non-smoking agreement they signed.

UltimaterializerX posted...

Andy, the actual issue here is if theres just you and me left vs 2 mafia and 1 indy, we cant actually win. We would basically just be deciding if mafia wins or an independent wins.

Eh? I thought a Survivor wins with town if still alive at game's end, and that town still wins. Town can still win by lynching scum today, having the Survivor be the night kill, and then lynching the other scum tomorrow.

ctesjbuvf posted...

My argument has been that if Death is on the same team as Dumey, then scum deliberately chose to sacrifice Dumey. It's literally either that or Death is not scum with Dumey.

It's a viable gambit for scum to try to town confirm Death. Sacrificing Dumey before he gets fed to the DARGON is definitely a play that would be considered. But I don't buy your logic here at all, because it's very contingent on scum knowing what Chang would do with the camera. Why don't you tell me how scum would know who Chang would watch?

ctesjbuvf posted...

So if Death was on the same team as Dumey, he would have fake claimed something else.

"he" here being Dumey? Because Death's claim isn't fake. He may be lying about his alignment, but not about his role. And again, I don't know what this has to do with anything. This is a fake claim. Scum doesn't need to think through how mechanics interact, they just need to sell a lie.

UltimaterializerX posted...

The phantom rb pretty much confirms a third party.

I don't follow this connection either.

BCT what Ctes is trying to say is: If I was scum, then EDumey made a claim (that he would scan for players that could move through their own power) that he knew could be countered by Changmas on the same day already since Changmas got the item.

Its not about what Changmas did with the item, its the fact that Changmas managed to move during the night despite not being a moving role.

And in fact Changmas did call Edumey certain scum because Edumey did not know that Changmas had not moved under his own power.

Oh and yeah, sounds rough BCT.

Meanwhile I dont even know what meth smells like.