Board 8 > Contest Stats and Discussion - Part 1345

(+) Yeah! (+)

Yuri_LowelI posted...

84%

Even though Black Flag is a lot stronger and probably the most popular AC game or at least slightly behind AC2.

Persona/Witcher is probably a 55-45 but you can bet your fucking ass that Match is gonna have rallies. From Both sides but definitely PErsona 5 sides.

Hype machine, gogogo.

I think Witcher 3 wins that one easily, but I hope I'm wrong. P5 is my GotD.

---

TheCodeisBosco posted...

Portal 2 for sure.

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/poll/6069-best-game-ever-day-5-portal-2-vs-sonic-the-hedgehog-2

Yeah. Sonic Mania isn't doing shit on Portal 2.


---

Didn't BT say he was bowing out after Overwatch flubbed?

Why is he still making dumbass predictions and acting like he's a genius with all that crow in his mouth?

RDR2 finally made a big percentage jump
---

plasmabeam posted...

Hype machine, gogogo.

I think Witcher 3 wins that one easily, but I hope I'm wrong. P5 is my GotD.

If only P5 had gotten a Switch port by now.

---

BT has no self-awareness that's how
---

AC2 sure would beat a Civ game by a lot more in its peak. No way Black Flag somehow resisted the franchise dying and is stronger than it

Seriously, AC is worth nothing no more on a site like this. Doesn't matter if it was once big, beating them is not very impressive.

---

LeonhartFour posted...

RDR2 finally made a big percentage jump

Of course it did. We've seen what these Rockstar Games can do. They need to be stopped.

---

UltimaterializerX posted...

What even is that game?

@UltimaterializerX Ys VIII is basically Kingdom Hearts on coke, with a 3D Metroidvania-style map, and S-tier music. One of the most pleasant surprises I've come across in ages.

---

UshiromiyaEva posted...

Didn't BT say he was bowing out after Overwatch flubbed?

Why is he still making dumbass predictions and acting like he's a genius with all that crow in his mouth?

Crow in his mouth? I thought he was supposed to be eating a hat.

---

Maybe the 394679438567956 rallies increased our votals to a point where something like Ys isn't that strong and people are going for the more mainstream option?

I'm assuming he hasn't eaten the hat because he hasn't been able to swallow down the crow yet.

ctesjbuvf posted...

AC2 sure would beat a Civ game by a lot more in its peak. No way Black Flag somehow resisted the franchise dying and is stronger than it

Seriously, AC is worth nothing no more on a site like this. Doesn't matter if it was once big, beating them is not very impressive.

Theyre still big name games and Black Flag is one of the most respected.

ITs also not a game thats going to garner antivotes. AC isn't your multiplayer Shooter...its an action adventure that still appeals to hardcore gamers.


---

Yuri_LowelI posted...

Theres a reason Ys 8 got into this bracket and wasn't a 16 or 15 seed.

This isn't your shitty Hyperdimension game or anything. Ys is popular.

Sonic Mania seems to me getting votes purely based on Nostalgia for old Sonic games.

Yeah, I nom'd Ys VIII, so I'm thrilled what Sonic is doing for it right now. More people need to play that series. It's a crime that Ys has been around so long, yet nobody's heard of it.

---

Why is Mario Maker not on this? It would have been an actual match if it had been against sonic mania

---

UshiromiyaEva posted...

Didn't BT say he was bowing out after Overwatch flubbed?

Why is he still making dumbass predictions and acting like he's a genius with all that crow in his mouth?

I'm glad hes around. He makes me look like a decent user.

---

Yuri_LowelI posted...

I'm glad hes around. He makes me look like a decent user.

let's not get carried away
---

plasmabeam posted...

Yeah, I nom'd Ys VIII, so I'm thrilled what Sonic is doing for it right now. More people need to play that series. It's a crime that Ys has been around so long, yet nobody's heard of it.

Well you aren't going to be noticed when you're notable games are delegated to PSP and Vita.

ys 8 at the end of the day...is a Vita game that got a bunch of ports.

We need a Ys game with bigger budget to be released on PS4/ and or switch with some good marketing.

---

It's great to see Ys redeemed!

---

Being a big name game doesn't necessarily matter here, we've seen that every contest, this one included.

AC surely gets antivoted for their games preferring quantity over quality for a while. AC2 didn't fall off a major cliff between 2010 and 2015 for no reason.

---

Wow Sonic!

And also kinda Animal Crossing

---

Yuri_LowelI posted...

Theyre still big name games and Black Flag is one of the most respected.

ITs also not a game thats going to garner antivotes. AC isn't your multiplayer Shooter...its an action adventure that still appeals to hardcore gamers.

And according to GameFAQs Persona 5 is three times better than it.

---

either way Persona is overperforming here..i think most people were predicting around 70%

ctesjbuvf posted...

Being a big name game doesn't necessarily matter here, we've seen that every contest, this one included.

AC surely gets antivoted for their games preferring quantity over quality for a while. AC2 didn't fall off a major cliff between 2010 and 2015 for no reason.

Theres being Antivoted and then theres Call ofDuty/Fortnite

My point is AC is still a game/series that was once very popular on Gfaqs. Altair and Ezio also don't do too badly in contests. Although that might be more to their design than their games but still.

I'm just saying AC aren't what they use to be....but when you compare them to games like Stanley Parable or Subnautica or low fodder indies like Obra Dinn its clearly a step above all of those games.

---

Persona 5 will probably drop some percentage over the course of the day.

---

Sharinnegan posted...

either way Persona is overperforming here..i think most people were predicting around 70%

I was predicting 95% so to me this is a major disaappointment, total Turd of the Round, its gonna look worse than Suoer Meat Boy next round.

---

Not_Wylvane posted...

And according to GameFAQs Persona 5 is three times better than it.

Well 3 times more popular than it. IF we use the "its better than" then portal 2 should be Quadrupling KH3.

---

I'm in the leaderboard!!! Turns out I wasn't far behind from yesterday, clutch for #50!

---

Okay Sonic doubling SMB is the single most stunned I've been at any result of the contest so far! Wowza. Guess Ys VIII had some strength after all.

---

Not_Wylvane posted...

I was predicting 95% so to me this is a major disaappointment, total Turd of the Round, its gonna look worse than Suoer Meat Boy next round.

Are you imitating Black Turtle? you're doing a bad job. He isn't as obvious.

---

ctesjbuvf posted...

Persona 5 will probably drop some percentage over the course of the day.

Persona 5 only lost .3% against Heavy Rain once the first hour ended.

although I'm impressed that Portal 2 is still gashing KH3 for big percentage gains
---

Portal has gone up with basically every update.

---

Yuri_LowelI posted...

Theres being Antivoted and then theres Call ofDuty/Fortnite

My point is AC is still a game/series that was once very popular on Gfaqs. Altair and Ezio also don't do too badly in contests. Although that might be more to their design than their games but still.

I'm just saying AC aren't what they use to be....but when you compare them to games like Stanley Parable or Subnautica or low fodder indies like Obra Dinn its clearly a step above all of those games.

Oh I agree with this, though Call of Duty also used to be worth something here and Altair and Ezio sure isn't what they used to be. Ezio being the AC representative last contest probably speaks about what we think of the newer games though.

So the point is just that I don't think there's enough of a difference between Odyssey and Black Flag for Persona 5 vs. Witcher to be close. Persona 5 will likely have no trouble getting there and will lose no trouble too.

---

LeonhartFour posted...

Persona 5 only lost .3% against Heavy Rain once the first hour ended.

although I'm impressed that Portal 2 is still gashing KH3 for big percentage games

AC is more well known than HR

Then again Royal is out and has active users. P5 is going to draw more votes compared to if Royal didn't exist.

---

Sharinnegan posted...

either way Persona is overperforming here..i think most people were predicting around 70%

Yeah, this is a fantastic performance by Persona 5. Even if we think Black Flag is trash, this is still worth 77% on Civ 5 and Civ 5 managed to break 33% on 2015 Dark Souls (which should be stronger now).

The only thing is that I don't think it matters. It'll win its division and then lose to Witcher 3, so it's trajectory is set.

---

UltimaterializerX posted...

I can't believe I picked Kingdom Hearts here, over a game I love no less. I guess that series really is dead here.

Nah, I'm sure KH1 and KH2 would still be really strong. KH3 is just very divisive.
---

LeonhartFour posted...

Persona 5 only lost .3% against Heavy Rain once the first hour ended.

Well, I don't know about Heavy Rain I suppose, but I just expected AC to be worst early.

---

I don't about really strong when you lose to FFIX but I guess

---

FF9 is strong as well.
---

ctesjbuvf posted...

Oh I agree with this, though Call of Duty also used to be worth something here and Altair and Ezio sure isn't what they used to be. Ezio being the AC representative last contest probably speaks about what we think of the newer games though.

So the point is just that I don't think there's enough of a difference between Odyssey and Black Flag for Persona 5 vs. Witcher to be close. Persona 5 will likely have no trouble getting there and will lose no trouble too.

Thats true. But Lets use the term "Rallies not permitting"

---

Well, I'm just saying that just because Persona 5 is frontloaded doesn't mean it'll necessarily tank percentage beyond the first hour. It lost 5% from the freeze to the end of the first hour and then mostly held steady.

It hasn't lost much percentage from the freeze this round though.
---

squexa posted...

Yeah, this is a fantastic performance by Persona 5. Even if we think Black Flag is trash, this is still worth 77% on Civ 5 and Civ 5 managed to break 33% on 2015 Dark Souls (which should be stronger now).

The only thing is that I don't think it matters. It'll win its division and then lose to Witcher 3, so it's trajectory is set.

At the very least i want it to trash Sonic next round.

---

I'm not sure Sonic Mania would beat Black Flag, so Persona 5 should wreck it.
---

Portal 2 over 63%, literally over 6% gained from the freeze
---

SAHNlC!!!

---

Go SAHNIC!!!

---