Current Events > Do you believe Jesus existed?

Topic List
Page List: 1, 2
MrResetti
10/10/19 2:41:45 PM
#1:


A 24oz beer is a tall boy, a 16oz beer is a pounder

Get it right.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
SquantoZ
10/10/19 2:42:10 PM
#2:


... Copied to Clipboard!
#3
Post #3 was unavailable or deleted.
Mistere Man
10/10/19 2:44:25 PM
#4:


I have personally met them so yes.

Heck I have met lots of Jesus's
---
Water+Fall=Radiation.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zikten
10/10/19 2:46:42 PM
#5:


I never bought the "historical evidence" of him. Im kinda inclined to believe that no, he was not a real person. or maybe he's based on multiple people who existed possibly. but I don't think an actual individual Jesus existed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Questionmarktarius
10/10/19 2:50:36 PM
#6:


Mary and Joseph wandered back to Bethlehem for a census. Yeshua bin Nazareth is documented to have existed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 2:56:34 PM
#7:


Zikten posted...
I never bought the "historical evidence" of him.


You must not buy a lot of established history.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Zikten
10/10/19 2:57:40 PM
#8:


I do. there is scant historical evidence of Jesus.
... Copied to Clipboard!
ThyCorndog
10/10/19 2:58:34 PM
#9:


i'm not sure. I think there could have been a jewish reformist in the time and region that the jesus figure was later based on. I'm pretty agnostic on the idea of jesus existing beyond that
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 2:59:46 PM
#10:


Zikten posted...
I do. there is scant historical evidence of Jesus.


As much as there is for a ton of historical figures. The only reason people question Jesus is the tie to religion.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Machete
10/10/19 3:01:35 PM
#11:


Zikten posted...
I never bought the "historical evidence" of him. Im kinda inclined to believe that no, he was not a real person. or maybe he's based on multiple people who existed possibly. but I don't think an actual individual Jesus existed.


That's how I see it. He's more of an archetype and his life story is probably a compilation based on many people and events.
---
#TrashyTrump #LockTrumpUp
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 3:03:48 PM
#12:


Machete posted...
That's how I see it. He's more of an archetype and his life story is probably a compilation based on many people and events.


While there's "scant evidence " for the life of Jesus, there's no evidence for that.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Dyinglegacy
10/10/19 3:04:15 PM
#13:


Absolutely.

His divine nature is the questionable aspect. I won't say he isn't the king of kings, but I cannot lie about my skepticism. This is understandable, as one of the 12 was a skeptic. Upon hearing about the resurrection of Jesus, Thomas literally said something along the lines of unless I put my hand in his wounds, I will not believe. As one of the 12, his eyes bore witness to everything Jesus did, yet he still doubted.

How much more of a stretch is it to imagine that someone born some 2000 years later, and didn't witness Jesus at all, would have doubts?

---
Voted worst user on CE 2012, 2013, 2014, 2015, 2016, 2017, and 2018.
Current e-argument streak: 0 wins. 100000 losses.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Machete
10/10/19 3:10:59 PM
#14:


vigorm0rtis posted...
Machete posted...
That's how I see it. He's more of an archetype and his life story is probably a compilation based on many people and events.


While there's "scant evidence " for the life of Jesus, there's no evidence for that.


I mean it's basically how mythology works. Different people and events are compiled into archetypes and exaggerated to become larger than life. There are an absurd number of examples throughout mythology of many regions. I just see Christianity as "mythology that is still practiced currently by some"
---
#DisastrousDonald #LockTrumpUp
... Copied to Clipboard!
paerarru
10/10/19 3:36:30 PM
#15:


Yes. There's very little historical evidence but that's about what you'd expect for some random preacher.

Were some facts of his life exaggerated or even outright fabricated after his death? Possibly. The Gospels actually contradict themselves, so. Still, some parts may well be true.
---
Hottest K-Pop Girl Group
http://challonge.com/96st4ysk
... Copied to Clipboard!
#16
Post #16 was unavailable or deleted.
#17
Post #17 was unavailable or deleted.
A_A_Battery
10/10/19 3:41:10 PM
#18:


Yeah he existed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Wewillrocku
10/10/19 3:47:21 PM
#19:


no because nobody who has such legends written about him existed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Questionmarktarius
10/10/19 3:48:47 PM
#20:


Wewillrocku posted...
no because nobody who has such legends written about him existed.

I'm reasonably certain Chuck Norris is an actual person.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Wewillrocku
10/10/19 3:50:09 PM
#21:


Questionmarktarius posted...
Wewillrocku posted...
no because nobody who has such legends written about him existed.

I'm reasonably certain Chuck Norris is an actual person.

are you just as certain that jesus' life is a joke?
... Copied to Clipboard!
Questionmarktarius
10/10/19 3:51:55 PM
#22:


Wewillrocku posted...
Questionmarktarius posted...
Wewillrocku posted...
no because nobody who has such legends written about him existed.

I'm reasonably certain Chuck Norris is an actual person.

are you just as certain that jesus' life is a joke?

That was Brian of Nazareth. Totally different guy.
... Copied to Clipboard!
gamer167
10/10/19 3:56:09 PM
#23:


God in human form that was conceived by the virgin Mary and died for our sins only to rise from the dead and eventually ascended into Heaven? Probably not

I do believe there could have been a guy possibly named Jesus during the same time period that was spreading the same message though.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Wewillrocku
10/10/19 3:56:33 PM
#24:


ecks dee, you and your zingers.
... Copied to Clipboard!
hockeybub89
10/10/19 4:00:28 PM
#25:


He's really no more established then a lot of randos who lived before good recordkeeping. It's mostly later second and third hand mentions of some dude that may have preached and been killed.

So maybe?
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 5:03:03 PM
#26:


Machete posted...
I mean it's basically how mythology works. Different people and events are compiled into archetypes and exaggerated to become larger than life. There are an absurd number of examples throughout mythology of many regions. I just see Christianity as "mythology that is still practiced currently by some"


No, I get it. You don't know the difference between how we establish what is real and what isn't in the practice of history.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Tonyjaa
10/10/19 5:09:59 PM
#27:


I believe 100% Jesus existed and died for our sins and no one will ever be able to convince me otherwise
... Copied to Clipboard!
hockeybub89
10/10/19 5:11:37 PM
#28:


Tonyjaa posted...
I believe 100% Jesus existed and died for our sins and no one will ever be able to convince me otherwise

That's the issue with beliefs to be honest.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 5:17:02 PM
#29:


Wewillrocku posted...
no because nobody who has such legends written about him existed.


Someone hasn't heard of every sacral king in history.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Machete
10/10/19 5:20:59 PM
#30:


vigorm0rtis posted...
Machete posted...
I mean it's basically how mythology works. Different people and events are compiled into archetypes and exaggerated to become larger than life. There are an absurd number of examples throughout mythology of many regions. I just see Christianity as "mythology that is still practiced currently by some"


No, I get it. You don't know the difference between how we establish what is real and what isn't in the practice of history.


No, you don't get it. You are shitposting and trolling for some reason. You're dismissed.
---
#TrollishTrump #LockTrumpUp
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 5:28:55 PM
#31:


Machete posted...
No, you don't get it. You are shitposting and trolling for some reason. You're dismissed.


I was a paleographer in my previous life. Paleographers and archaeologists are the forensic pathologists of history. I have a really good idea about how and why historians believe what they do. You obviously don't.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Machete
10/10/19 5:52:00 PM
#32:


vigorm0rtis posted...
Machete posted...
No, you don't get it. You are shitposting and trolling for some reason. You're dismissed.


I was a paleographer in my previous life. Paleographers and archaeologists are the forensic pathologists of history. I have a really good idea about how and why historians believe what they do. You obviously don't.


Define "previous life"
---
#DamagedDonald #LockTrumpUp
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 5:54:02 PM
#33:


Machete posted...
Define "previous life"


Until about 15 years ago when I started making more money in the side hustle and decided to ditch paleography. It was more interesting, but I wasn't going to go for my Ph.D. so my advancement options were limited.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Machete
10/10/19 5:58:34 PM
#34:


Oh. Back to dismissed.
---
#TroglodyteTrump #LockTrumpUp
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 5:59:06 PM
#35:


Machete posted...
Oh. Back to dismissed.


Enjoy amateur hour.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Thunder_Armor
10/10/19 5:59:16 PM
#36:


The idea of a prophesied Messiah had been established hundreds of years before Jesus. Do I think there was a Jewish man who gained a following circa 30 AD for being the prophesied Messiah?

Yeah, I think that probably happened. Notwithstanding how many of the Biblical stories were embellished on after the fact.

---
I should go.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Politics
10/10/19 5:59:38 PM
#37:


I made a topic about this a few weeks ago. I assume he in a literal sense didn't but it might of been loosely based on something idk
... Copied to Clipboard!
Hotel_Security
10/10/19 6:02:08 PM
#38:


He quite likely existed. This isn't really disputed. Christianity didn't just pop up out of nowhere and there's even mention of various rabble going on in Jerusalem in ancient Roman writings,

It's just the whole "he's the Son of God" thing that is more in question.

no because nobody who has such legends written about him existed.

You're right. That legend about the guy who cut down the apple tree is totally fake so he must be not real.
... Copied to Clipboard!
ThanksUglyGod
10/10/19 6:03:57 PM
#39:


Sure, I see him in the face of every child.
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 6:07:23 PM
#40:


Politics posted...
I made a topic about this a few weeks ago. I assume he in a literal sense didn't but it might of been loosely based on something idk


We have about as much "reliable" info about Jesus as we do about Vortigern, but Vortigern wasn't the subject of a mystery cult that turned into a "legit" religion so people don't even try to dispute his existence. Nonetheless, we have equal parts fantasy nonsense about Vortigern-- he was the basis for the myth of King Arthur.


---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Wewillrocku
10/10/19 6:19:51 PM
#41:


a legit religion. lol.
... Copied to Clipboard!
MrToothHasYou
10/10/19 6:20:26 PM
#42:


MrResetti posted...
A 24oz beer is a tall boy, a 16oz beer is a pounder

Get it right.
This is correct

---
http://weareontherun.bandcamp.com
^^^^^ HEY! ^^^ LISTEN! ^^^^^
... Copied to Clipboard!
vigorm0rtis
10/10/19 6:40:29 PM
#43:


Wewillrocku posted...
a legit religion. lol.
Didn't see the quotes, eh? It's alright, working at Taco Bell doesn't require full literacy.

---
"Can't wait to count out your coin!" -- Bethesda, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
Wewillrocku
10/10/19 6:44:26 PM
#44:


vigorm0rtis posted...
Wewillrocku posted...
a legit religion. lol.
Didn't see the quotes, eh? It's alright, working at Taco Bell doesn't require full literacy.

lmao what?
... Copied to Clipboard!
1337toothbrush
10/10/19 6:49:34 PM
#45:


No, he was invented by the elites as an example for the underclasses to follow while the elites continued fucking them over.
---
... Copied to Clipboard!
Inferno Dive Dragoon
10/10/19 6:58:26 PM
#46:


Sure.

I rather doubt all that "born of the divine" stuff though.
---
Les aristocrates a la lanterne!
Les aristocrates on les pendra!
... Copied to Clipboard!
Machete
10/10/19 9:50:01 PM
#47:


vigorm0rtis posted...
Wewillrocku posted...
a legit religion. lol.
Didn't see the quotes, eh? It's alright, working at Taco Bell doesn't require full literacy.


Oh okay so what you're saying is you want on the list of people who troll and shitpost and got run off the board. I'll pass the word around, friendo.
---
#DepravedDonald #LockTrumpUp
... Copied to Clipboard!
EverDownward
10/10/19 9:50:44 PM
#48:


Yes. Almost all scholars believe a "Jesus Christ" existed, and even then I believe regardless because I'm a Christian.
---
take me somewhere nice
... Copied to Clipboard!
Dragonblade01
10/10/19 10:04:54 PM
#49:


It doesn't really matter to me. There could have been a single real person, or it could have been based on the stories of multiple people.

Either way, there's no evidence that Jesus existed as described in the Bible.
... Copied to Clipboard!
paerarru
10/11/19 2:23:58 PM
#50:


Thunder_Armor posted...
The idea of a prophesied Messiah had been established hundreds of years before Jesus. Do I think there was a Jewish man who gained a following circa 30 AD for being the prophesied Messiah?

Yeah, I think that probably happened. Notwithstanding how many of the Biblical stories were embellished on after the fact.

This is a good post. You have to look at the Gospels and the accounts of the Apostles and the followers of Jesus in the right light to understand what they're doing.

Yeah, there were other Messianic figures throughout history, more or less documented, even around the time of Jesus himself. That should tell you not that Jesus is a hodgepodge of Messianic figures (not historically at least), but rather that he was eventually the most successful one. To date. Nobody would just make up a Messiah, and actually gather a following, but they could make up stories about him (or not, depending on how strong and literal your faith is).

But you need the guy. He was a cult leader, the guy. A religion is a well established cult. Is there something special about this cult that sets it apart from any other cult? Well, that part is faith.

Hotel_Security posted...
He quite likely existed. This isn't really disputed. Christianity didn't just pop up out of nowhere and there's even mention of various rabble going on in Jerusalem in ancient Roman writings during Nero's reign. Heck, some try to blame Nero for killing Jesus (he's not very popular) but it's likely he had little knowledge of the details.

It's just the whole "he's the Son of God" thing that is more in question.

no because nobody who has such legends written about him existed.

You're right. That legend about the guy who cut down the apple tree is totally fake so he must be not real.

Yeah, that's silly. People make up stories about people all the time. Been doing it all through history. And back in the day when people were more superstitious (I actually don't like saying that because it's not like people were more gullible or anything, it's just that people didn't have much science) you could get away with some pretty wild stories. I actually think most of the mythological figures and pantheons throughout the world were real people and events, just very embellished after the fact. There are often real bases for "myths".
---
Hottest K-Pop Girl Group
http://challonge.com/96st4ysk
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1, 2