Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 5 - Mementos: Path of Aiyatsbus

(+) Yeah! (+)

Player List (17)
1. Ashethan
2. benjamin3740
3. Corrik
4. Dark Young Link
6. garetha200
8. Hbthebattle
9. htaeD
10. IfGodCouldDie
11. Johnbobb
12. masterplum
13. MZero11
14. Neablis
15. red13n
17. ScareChan
18. Shaduln
19. Sheep007
20. DoomTheGyarados (replaced Terra-enforcer)

Knocked out
5. eaedwards6400 - Sojiro Sakura, TOWN Vanilla (LD1)
16. Reg - Goro Akechi, MAFIA Detective Godfather (KN1)
7. HanOfTheNekos - Tae Takemi, TOWN Doctor (KN1)

Votals, as of Topic 4
DYL [4] - Sheep, Neablis, Ben, Scare
Sheep [3] - Hb, Doom, DYL, (Scare)
Plum [2] - Shad, Corrik
Doom [1] - IGCD
MZero [1] - plum
Red [1] - (Scare), Johnbobb
IGCD [0] - (Doom), (Death)
Shad [0] - (Plum)

With 17 players alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch. Day ends at 8:00 PM EST on Friday, December 21st, approximately thirty minutes from now.
---

My only inclination is my usual reservation towards lynching someone who hasnt claimed yet.
But DYL looks the worst right now

and there are the votals
---

He hasnt been online in 24 hours
for pete'se sake DYL
---

Also if the last few people could give me a yes or no that'd be great.
---

What if DYL is one of the two who needs to be replaced???
---

I'm confirmed I don't think I have a need to answer
---

I dont think DYL or Garetha are gonna give a yes or no
---

Ok, back for a bit. Whats the case on DYL? He just hasnt been around?
---

ScareChan posted...

I'm confirmed I don't think I have a need to answer

I forget why you are even confirmed.
---

he isn't
---

ScareChan posted...

I'm confirmed I don't think I have a need to answer

You are not immune give an answer.
---

This is pretty dumb. Holidays are hard
---

Death, by DYL looking the worst what do you mean? Because I feel like I'm the only one really arguing hard against him other than saying he voted for Ed
---

htaeD posted...

What if DYL is one of the two who needs to be replaced???

htaeD posted...

I dont think DYL or Garetha are gonna give a yes or no

ugh

so we'd literally be lynching someone looking for a replacement?

:/
---

Having trouble navigating on phone. Is there an actual case on DYL
---

Johnbobb posted...

htaeD posted...

What if DYL is one of the two who needs to be replaced???

htaeD posted...

I dont think DYL or Garetha are gonna give a yes or no

ugh

so we'd literally be lynching someone looking for a replacement?

:/

It was announced we are looking for 2 replacements?
---

masterplum posted...

Ok, back for a bit. Whats the case on DYL? He just hasnt been around?

Also did a bad vote on Ed, suspected me vocally then followed me onto Ed anyway, had a few crappy sounding posts, and everyone else just generally looks a lot better to me. He has absolutely nothing at all that looks good (which is often my measure for finding scum).

Scare was apparently confirmed because he voted after Anonymous in the tiebreaker and wasn't modkilled iirc
---

masterplum posted...

It was announced we are looking for 2 replacements?

In the signups.
---

Sheep007 posted...

masterplum posted...

Ok, back for a bit. Whats the case on DYL? He just hasnt been around?

Also did a bad vote on Ed, suspected me vocally then followed me onto Ed anyway, had a few crappy sounding posts, and everyone else just generally looks a lot better to me. He has absolutely nothing at all that looks good (which is often my measure for finding scum).

Scare was apparently confirmed because he voted after Anonymous in the tiebreaker and wasn't modkilled iirc

Why would this confirm Scare? He voted the same way as the anonymous vote.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Death, by DYL looking the worst what do you mean? Because I feel like I'm the only one really arguing hard against him other than saying he voted for Ed

I should add, the worst of the ones who voted Eaed
Sheep I can at least see voting eaed through a town train of thought...
---

##extension
---

There's probably others who've been around little enough to have possibly requested replaces. Terra was around at deadline yesterday yet still requested a replace.
---

##Unvote
##Vote:DYL
---

oh, sign up does ask for two replace.

Well this sucks.
---

I dont know if that works, but I second an extension.
---

masterplum posted...

Sheep007 posted...

masterplum posted...

Ok, back for a bit. Whats the case on DYL? He just hasnt been around?

Also did a bad vote on Ed, suspected me vocally then followed me onto Ed anyway, had a few crappy sounding posts, and everyone else just generally looks a lot better to me. He has absolutely nothing at all that looks good (which is often my measure for finding scum).

Scare was apparently confirmed because he voted after Anonymous in the tiebreaker and wasn't modkilled iirc

Why would this confirm Scare? He voted the same way as the anonymous vote.

Because if he was scum he would've known the anonymous vote was going in and could've been modkilled for it, or wouldn't have needed to incriminate himself by voting Ed in the first place.
---

@Corrik and @DoomTheGyarados

20 min till deadline

if you guys are still around now's a good time to weigh in
---

No extensions.
---

I'd love an extension but I think the game was planned around having a double night D3 for Christmas and that might screw with that.
---

well there you go
---

Chris do you approve of DYL's .... (what's it called in P5 again when you change someone's heart? I'm looking for a specific word...) ? ANyway, his lynch
---

given our options, I'd rather go plum or sheep than DYL

if there are replacements coming we can get something out of those
---

ScareChan posted...

I'm confirmed I don't think I have a need to answer

Scare you need to get back here.
---

masterplum posted...

Sheep007 posted...

masterplum posted...

Ok, back for a bit. Whats the case on DYL? He just hasnt been around?

Also did a bad vote on Ed, suspected me vocally then followed me onto Ed anyway, had a few crappy sounding posts, and everyone else just generally looks a lot better to me. He has absolutely nothing at all that looks good (which is often my measure for finding scum).

Scare was apparently confirmed because he voted after Anonymous in the tiebreaker and wasn't modkilled iirc

Why would this confirm Scare? He voted the same way as the anonymous vote.

##unvote
##vote: plum
---

Of course scare votes me. He is trash at this game
---

If DYL was the replacement, then I feel like this game is not even in our control.
---

Switching to plum now is even less helpful!
---

literally the most experienced players are absent at last minute

I'm not lynching DYL. Simple as that. I'm not gonna lynch someone looking for a replace.

##unvote
##vote: Plum

Plum, sheep

please convince me
---

masterplum posted...

Of course scare votes me. He is trash at this game

You were literally PART OF THE REASON that there is precedent from previous games that makes me confirmed

Get your bullshit out of here
---

Scare I'm reiterating I need answers because right now I'm running on the assumption Shad is 100% confirmed town.
---

no offense death, you're experienced enough too
---

No seriously, I dont get how Scare is confirmed.
He looks good, but not 100 % good.
---

So uhh....Johnbobb why are you assuming DYL is even asking to be replaced?

Also does anyone here know f DYL has ever replaced before?
---

##unvote
##vote:Scare
---

red13n posted...

Scare I'm reiterating I need answers because right now I'm running on the assumption Shad is 100% confirmed town.

Ugh

I dont believe i am
---

I'm going to remind people the last 3 votes were Sheep, Shad, IGCD.

I'm not willing to touch Shad.

I still think IGCD is probably scum for the last minute vote. Scum have been doing that for awhile now, just vote and let town try to overpower your voting power.
---

ScareChan posted...

masterplum posted...

Of course scare votes me. He is trash at this game

You were literally PART OF THE REASON that there is precedent from previous games that makes me confirmed

Get your bullshit out of here

YOU DIDNT ACT IN A WAY THAT MAKES YOU LOOK GOOD

ITS NOT THE SAME
---

Johnbobb posted...

literally the most experienced players are absent at last minute

I'm not lynching DYL. Simple as that. I'm not gonna lynch someone looking for a replace.

##unvote
##vote: Plum

Plum, sheep

please convince me

Well, Plum over Sheep. So I dont have to do any convincing I guess
---

Votals, as of #45
DYL [4] - Sheep, Neablis, Ben, (Scare), IGCD
Plum [4] - Shad, Corrik, Scare, Johnbobb
Sheep [3] - Hb, Doom, DYL, (Scare)
Scare [1] - plum
MZero [0] - (plum)
Red [0] - (Scare), (Johnbobb)
Doom [0] - (IGCD)
IGCD [0] - (Doom), (Death)
Shad [0] - (Plum)

With 17 players alive, it takes 9 votes to lynch. Day ends at 8:00 PM EST on Friday, December 21st, approximately fifteen minutes from now.
---

Do I now have to build a case on plum in 15 mins? I really wanted to clear up DYL's slot today but eh

Can we get votals?
---