Current Events > If you needed 11 different factors on rating a video game, what would they be?

Topic List
Page List: 1
billman1000
10/22/18 5:51:28 PM
#1:


Lets say sports games only
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 5:52:46 PM
#2:


1. Graphics
2. Options/Modes
3. Fun level
4. Sound/soundtrack
5.uniqueness/xfactor
6.variety/teams/rosters
7.replaysbility
8.?
9.?
10.?
11.?
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 5:53:14 PM
#3:


Maybe locations as in stadiums?

Controls?
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
DarkTransient
10/22/18 5:54:19 PM
#4:


I only need one criteria to dismiss sports games; the genre.
---
Proud to be part of the 1% of society that's smart enough to realise Australia is not real.
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 5:54:41 PM
#5:


DarkTransient posted...
I only need one criteria to dismiss sports games; the genre.


Same usually, but I was running out of games
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
DarkTransient
10/22/18 5:55:10 PM
#6:


billman1000 posted...
DarkTransient posted...
I only need one criteria to dismiss sports games; the genre.


Same usually, but I was running out of games


What games have you played? What games do you like?
---
Proud to be part of the 1% of society that's smart enough to realise Australia is not real.
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 5:56:22 PM
#7:


DarkTransient posted...
billman1000 posted...
DarkTransient posted...
I only need one criteria to dismiss sports games; the genre.


Same usually, but I was running out of games


What games have you played? What games do you like?


I play everything and have a nice little rating system for just about every genre, but obviously it doesnt transfer over to the sports genre so well.
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
Garioshi
10/22/18 5:56:48 PM
#8:


1. Graphics
2. Gameplay
3. Story
4. Music
5. Characters
6. Genre
7. Replayability
8. Game speed
9. Enjoyability of gameplay loop
10. Quality-of-life features
11. Controls
---
"I can't wait to get cancer" - Forgotten, 2018
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 5:58:05 PM
#9:


Garioshi posted...
1. Graphics
2. Gameplay
3. Story
4. Music
5. Characters
6. Genre
7. Replayability
8. Game speed
9. Enjoyability of gameplay loop
10. Quality-of-life features
11. Controls


Not many sports games have stories, characters kinda fall into the rosters/variety

Id agree with controls though.
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
PMarth2002
10/22/18 5:59:51 PM
#10:


11 factors is excessive unless I wanted to nitpick stuff.
---
No matter where you go, there you are.
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 6:00:53 PM
#11:


PMarth2002 posted...
11 factors is excessive unless I wanted to nitpick stuff.

Yah I agree, I was just trying to stay consistent with my other system. Its tough to think of 11 for sports.
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 6:01:51 PM
#12:


I was thinking about announcers for a catagory since like every sports game has them
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
#13
Post #13 was unavailable or deleted.
sLaCkEr408___RJ
10/22/18 6:12:38 PM
#14:


Level design
Art design
Music
Story
Sound design [including voice acting]
Multiplayer
Options
Gameplay/Controls
Extras [including DLC]
Replayability

Idk about the eleventh.
... Copied to Clipboard!
billman1000
10/22/18 6:19:50 PM
#15:


sLaCkEr408___RJ posted...
Level design
Art design
Music
Story
Sound design [including voice acting]
Multiplayer
Options
Gameplay/Controls
Extras [including DLC]
Replayability

Idk about the eleventh.


Those all sound good especially comparing to the Indy game Im playing right now, but who would you use your ratings for a game like madden when basically there arent levels or a story, or voice acting unless youre considering the announcers?
---
My Work
www.flickr.com/maksim09
... Copied to Clipboard!
SkittyOnWailord
10/22/18 6:24:13 PM
#16:


This would apply to me for almost any game, not just sports.

(In no order)

Controls
Art style
Length of main game
Jiggle physics
Customization of characters(s)
Music and sound effects
Difficulty
Future DLC
Controller customization
Multiplayer netcode
Diverse characters
---
I'm here! I'm furry! I'll try not to shed! =^_^=
i7 5820K|Rampage V Extreme|32GB DDR4 Ripjaws 4|EVGA 2080 Ti XC Ultra|HAF 932|Sony 55inch 4K HDR
... Copied to Clipboard!
sLaCkEr408___RJ
10/22/18 6:48:32 PM
#17:


billman1000 posted...
sLaCkEr408___RJ posted...
Level design
Art design
Music
Story
Sound design [including voice acting]
Multiplayer
Options
Gameplay/Controls
Extras [including DLC]
Replayability

Idk about the eleventh.


Those all sound good especially comparing to the Indy game Im playing right now, but who would you use your ratings for a game like madden when basically there arent levels or a story, or voice acting unless youre considering the announcers?

Same applies just like any other game. Sports games will often see a repeat rating on level categories since there isn't much variety. If Madden has no story, then low rating. If it has great sound (including announcers) then it gets a high rating.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1