Board 8 > Monster Mafia: The Rebootening Topic 2 - From the Shadows They Lurk.

(+) Yeah! (+)

10-3

8-4

6- 6

That is too easy for cult. It would have to be 11-2 or 10-2-1. With immune to recruitment roles.
---

6-5 not 6-6. Maybe 3 is possible. With immune town roles. Interesting.
---

Anyway masons stop doing scum's job for them. They will buy into you and assume I am town power and kill me tonight. Gotta play smart.
---

Going to bed. May be my last post of the day depending on how work is tomorrow.

I suggest everyone read sbell and ask if he sounds angry. If so why would he claim not to be? Dodgers are off tomorrow so red has no excuses not to be in this topic. Seriously.

Take deep breaths. Play smart. Dont overthink it.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

The smartest thing though if Chris is town would be to claim vanilla. As I said, why would Chris claiming Miller ever fool scum in this pool of players? Much better chance of being convincing to scum by saying you're a vanilla. Saying you are Miller is overkill that scum will never ever believe.

But in this world, scum Chris can claim Miller and use that as an excuse for scum to never kill him. Whereas real scum would kill him. Its a claim that blinds town more than it blinds scum, as I said before

You mean like last game?

Last game you didnt claim my role
---

If you look under your bed, you're sure to find... VOTALS!!

Sbell [2] - Han, Sheep,
Chris [2] - (Scare), (Ben), Ben, Sbell
Scare [1] - Plum, (Chris),
Neab [1] - FD,
Corrik [1] - (Ben,)
FD [1] - Miz,
Han [1] - Sbell,
Plum [1] - Scare,
Sheep [1] - Chris,
Ben [0] -(Scare),

Day ends Oct. 18 at 8pm MST
---

Kinda sucks that Chris can't post again. But it's okay because he's caught scum walking at this point and if he kills me off it'll only confirm his lie. So because of that I am okay with pursuing others today.

Truthfully I have not gotten any more town reads yet aside from Scare and Sheep, so that is kind of annoying because there are so many people I want more from
---

yeah I also like sheep
---

Zzzz
---

what happened to that 'scan'
---

and you still didnt answer why you decided to break your habit of not changing your claim recently
---

He already used it but I'm innocent so he's too embarrassed to reveal it.
---

ScareChan posted...

and you still didnt answer why you decided to break your habit of not changing your claim recently

What
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

He already used it but I'm innocent so he's too embarrassed to reveal it.

If I had used my scan already, I am sure I have already revealed it.
---

So you used it on Sheep? What a waste!
---

Would you look at that, my two best town reads are confirmed town.

Neab, I'm honestly not sure why I think you're scum. That's the problem. It's entirely based on a hunch, plus a few things which looked a little like drawing pressure away from scummates at the time (I doubt you intentionally did this regardless because it's rarely a good move, plus it's definitely conspiracy-ish). I'm on mobile and don't have time to go back and quote em now but remind me later.

Corrik's change of heart on me is amusing, as is Chris moving onto me when he should know I'm probably asleep.

I don't believe Chris' miller claim any more, so him doubling down on it is very interesting. Not necessarily scum actions but I'm starting to lean that way. Chris is a target for scum regardless of his claim so I honestly don't believe a miller claim would particularly help if he's town trying to not die. He probably knows that. So he's scum, or miller and masons are bluffing. Orrr, comedy option, Chris is town, playing everyone and doubling down knowing he won't be mislynched today in the hopes that he'll actually get a D2 as town for a change due to suspicion on him making him a bad kill.

Corrik didn't seem to read my stuff on the cult flavour. Very unlikely this game has cult roles, probably 3 scum and maybe an indy. Perhaps straight up 4 scum if town is strong, though it seems God does like Indy roles.
---

Sheep007 posted...

Would you look at that, my two best town reads are confirmed town.

Jeez, at this point we might as well make it a threeway
---

Seriously though I love that I nailed the exact mason pairing with literally my first sentence of the game.

Off to school now so won't be around for a few hours but I should be available until maybe deadline once I am back since no work today.
---

I dont
I mean I've never
This is all so sudden!
---

Oh yeah so I have a slight fear that Plum is Dracula and his PM mentions me. As i said, mine mentioned him a lot. I further worry that maybe one of his goals is to seek me out. Because early in the game he randomly said he was Van Helsing, dayvig. Which seemed like trying to lure Van Helsing out.
---

ScareChan posted...

I dont
I mean I've never
This is all so sudden!

Sheep already claims to have "nailed the masons" and he didn't even get your approval yet!!! Rude
---

Yinz are weird.
---

There is nothing going on

Have to keep entertained somehow
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Oh yeah so I have a slight fear that Plum is Dracula and his PM mentions me. As i said, mine mentioned him a lot. I further worry that maybe one of his goals is to seek me out. Because early in the game he randomly said he was Van Helsing, dayvig. Which seemed like trying to lure Van Helsing out.

Then... why not claim mason without your role
---

It would not necessarily surprise me if there were three millers in the game but I do not want to lynch Chris in any regard.

As for the scum ehhhh

i am at work so will be in and out will post better thoughts in just a bit

DoomTheGyarados posted...

I suggest everyone read sbell and ask if he sounds angry. If so why would he claim not to be?

Ya know what, fuck you chris. You want mad, you fucking got it. You just have to keep goading me. I was never angry and you know it. Not sure if you are just being a dick to me for getting you killed last game or what but unfortunately for you I don't see a Town Chris pulling this type of bullshit.

Your antagonizing of me, triggering me... Plus a double countered Miller claim. That's all I need to kill you this game too except now I'm confident I won't be wrong.
---

Not interested in killing Chris today

FD on the other hand
---

Corrik posted...

For those who aren't good at mafia. Chris is Town Power who wants to live past day 1 so he claimed Town Miller because it is foolproof to claim as town even if not miller.

Like, why does this even need fucking explained?

I claimed miller as actual miller once and got lynched Day 1 because Ulti was also miller

So it's not completely foolproof!
---

I claimed Miller as guilty scanning survivor. I survived.
---

Forceful_Dragon posted...

He already used it but I'm innocent so he's too embarrassed to reveal it.

Reminder: I called out scum dowolf for using innocent instead of 'town' last game

It's a real thing!
---

I'm not sure if I have ever claimed Miller
---

Now Corrik, I don't think you scum. I've played enough games with you to get a good feel and I'd actually put you above the claimed masons in my town list only because I already felt good about you before they made that amazing reveal. With that said I'm not sure why you are so confident on Chris being town power and b) why do you think pirate is steering clear of you so far this game? Do you think it speaks more to scum or town?
---

Hi plum.
---

##unvote: Sheep
##vote: Sbell

Sneaking this in before the boss gets here, be smart though it is a day one read and I just think he should be pressured appropriately, this isn't word of god he is scum but he is different than he was last game I think!
---

While I 100% agree with you that I'm different this game, my emotions or lack there of have nothing to do with it.

I was burnt by last game being so powerful and then us imploding. Doubting my own ability to read. This game opened with a bang and I feel as though I got lost in the muck add on top of that this player base is strong. I was itching to get back into a game but found out two days ago that my order clerk was going away and now I have to do her job and mine so I can't sit at work all day playing which just means more falling behind.

Your vote on me is pointless. Trying to take me down based on a lie is just bad mafia, but that's par for the course for you this game with a fake Miller claim isn't it.

Now that I've told you to go fuck yourself (in the nicest way possible) I'm feeling rather groovy. Will do my absolute best to keep active this work day while I am at a computer. I wont let town start behind by lynching one of their own.
---

Let's lynch SBell.
---

Honestly the contrast between how he voted me this game and last game is a key difference.

Han, we are lynching him for the wrong reasons I think.
---

Dont worry that was just VOTALS that woke you up

Sbell [3] - Han, Sheep, Chris,
Chris [2] - (Scare), (Ben), Ben, Sbell
Scare [1] - Plum, (Chris),
Neab [1] - FD,
Corrik [1] - (Ben,)
FD [1] - Miz,
Plum [1] - Scare,
Han [0] - (Sbell),
Sheep [0] - (Chris),
Ben [0] - (Scare),

Day ends Oct. 18 at 8pm MST 11hrs. and 37 minutes
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Honestly the contrast between how he voted me this game and last game is a key difference.

Han, we are lynching him for the wrong reasons I think.

Umm you've been fucking "you mad bro" trolling me. And you are a countered Miller claim.

Every reason you are voting me is the wrong reason, because I'm town and you are scum.

Han... Han I just have no idea why he's trolling me with this shit. And he's yet to put an actual argument together.

I fucking hate mafia games where I have to defend myself against others stupidity. If I had at least done something to garner this, it would be something I could tolerate.
---

And apparently I'm a double voter...
---

Sbell claim
---

masterplum posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Oh yeah so I have a slight fear that Plum is Dracula and his PM mentions me. As i said, mine mentioned him a lot. I further worry that maybe one of his goals is to seek me out. Because early in the game he randomly said he was Van Helsing, dayvig. Which seemed like trying to lure Van Helsing out.

Then... why not claim mason without your role

Well that's all revealed and done, so I don't care about that. I care more about why you came up with saying you were Van Helsing at all. .... ?

Also I seem to have totally forgotten why your vote is on scare
---

Ash Williams, Vanilla

Good, Bad, I'm the guy with the oh.. Where's your gun?

It was extreme excitement when I saw the name and extreme disappointment when I saw I couldn't do shit this game.
---

Obellisk posted...

Ash Williams, Vanilla

Good, Bad, I'm the guy with the oh.. Where's your gun?

It was extreme excitement when I saw the name and extreme disappointment when I saw I couldn't do shit this game.

I see.
---

When you saw the name. ...on your safe list??? :O

Does anyone else like the meta that if a player claims to have rolled a vanilla character they love its probably because they chose it?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

When you saw the name. ...on your safe list??? :O

Does anyone else like the meta that if a player claims to have rolled a vanilla character they love its probably because they chose it?

Well i was also extremely excited to roll homer simpson in TV Crossover and then was extremely disappointed to see i was vanilla, but that didn't stop me from sending in night actions all game.
---

Well SBell's claim is predictable and boring. Not feeling any obv scum vibes yet. Really wish I had a scum SBell game for reference here, because it feels a little like he's annoyed in a similar way he was in TV Mafia where he was Town.

MZero popping in saying he doesn't want to kill Chris bugs me more than a little. Would not be opposed to pressure on him but he's probably sleeping right now.

Also Plum still hasn't unvoted literal mason.
---

Sheep007 posted...

Well SBell's claim is predictable and boring. Not feeling any obv scum vibes yet

If its predictable wouldn't you then have scum vibes for me?

This sounds way to much like Scum knowing i'm town and afraid to put the pressure on me for how he'll look when I flip.

Consider yourself moved to the scum lean list Sheep.

However I agree with you, what is Plums deal this game? I'm trying to get a better feel for him. I should really be able to pick up if he's scum or town by now but i feel like all he's done this game is shit on other peoples meta/theories and thats literally it. He's ignored a few posts i've directed to him and i'm having trouble figuring out if this means hes scum and he's trying to shy away from his tell of interacting with me as scum or if he's just bad town.
---

Of course there's some scum vibes, if there weren't I wouldn't be voting for you. There's just nothing which absolutely screams "scum" in your play, but neither is there anyone else I currently feel is more likely to be scum. Neab, Chris and MZero are all decent votes but no better than you. I'm not quite sure how you can say I'm hesitant to put pressure on you when I literally decided to vote you solely for pressure earlier.
---