Board 8 > Monster Mafia: The Rebootening Topic 2 - From the Shadows They Lurk.

(+) Yeah! (+)

Day Ends Oct. 18 at 8pm MST

Player List
Sheep007
DoomTheGyarados
ScareChan
benjamin3740
Leafeon13N
HanOfTheNekos
Corrik
Obellisk
Pirate_Harris
Forceful_Dragon
Neablis
MZero11
masterplum

Please use at 450 of the previous topic.
---

How would one change their role once they receive it.

Making a claim, true or fake, is still a claim. Scare stop being basic.

Anyway I am miller. Sticking with it. Kill me if you believe them tbh.
---

You guys realize a game with a role as ridiculous as miller masons could totally have 3 millers right
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

How would one change their role once they receive it.

Making a claim, true or fake, is still a claim. Scare stop being basic.

Anyway I am miller. Sticking with it. Kill me if you believe them tbh.

Having said that I dont like this post
---

anyways

##Unvote

Neablis kind of reminded me a while ago that chris kind of resolves hisself. I was hoping to see more happen if I left my vote there, but it doesnt seem like anyone wants to bite. I dont want to make the whole day about him, may return to him later, but we have time

##Vote: plum

will vote sbell probably later but plum is actually here right now
---

Believe us. Our first assumption was that maybe Chris was town power fake claiming, so we didnt counter. Well, Scare never thought Chris wasnt scum. If he's sticking with it he's definitely scum. There's not 3 millers
---

wanted to hold the miller in our pocket in case someone else tried to counter miller
---

##unvote: Scare
##vote: Sheep

Wake up and talk some more.

Also Plum actually not liking something I say day 1 is probably a good sign he is town. He isn't playing the 'I am town plum' script to a tee.
---

unvote vote chris

traped foo
---

Also in a world where I am town power who fake claimed miller, Ben, did you expect me to say "Oh geesh I am sorry I lied, I am actually x."

?
---

ScareChan posted...

anyways

##Unvote

Neablis kind of reminded me a while ago that chris kind of resolves hisself. I was hoping to see more happen if I left my vote there, but it doesnt seem like anyone wants to bite. I dont want to make the whole day about him, may return to him later, but we have time

##Vote: plum

will vote sbell probably later but plum is actually here right now

What
---

Also this is like the third mason pairing I have outed as town in the past 2 years and people don't catch on that town chris who is engaged and thinking about how people are thinking and senses something wrong is a great indicator of my alignment!
---

ALSO ALSO I was trying to bait someone to agree with me on Scare but you guys are just the worst ~_~
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Believe us. Our first assumption was that maybe Chris was town power fake claiming, so we didnt counter. Well, Scare never thought Chris wasnt scum. If he's sticking with it he's definitely scum. There's not 3 millers

But why tho

Why is 3millers any more insane than miller masons.
---

Wouldn't even be the first 3 miller game on board 8.

But they probably aren't millers tbh. Betting that Scare cooked this up because he is saying "I am sure he is scum, Ben! Just trust me. This will make it easier."
---

masterplum posted...

ScareChan posted...

Oh cool so Chris and Corrik literally scum

Town is not Town town is Humans

O_o

*checks role pm*

I totally missed this. Why did you know it off the top of your head?

masterplum posted...

Forceful_Dragon posted...

Chris flavor being Miller does not jibe with my own flavor as town.

Why do you believe anything that has been said

I claim vanhelsing day vig.

Two cases of showing he wasnt aware of town's name

masterplum posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

ScareChan posted...

Oh cool so Chris and Corrik literally scum

Town is not Town town is Humans

Ooooh. I likey. Scare is town. Well not TOWN, but you know what I mean. I know what he means ;)

BOOK OF CONFIRMED TOWN
Scare

This is a terrible town confirming

I think its more likely that scare is scum who knew the alignment because it was explicitly spelled out to him then he is town who thinks this is a slip

Immediately tries to shade me for paying attention to the situation
---

masterplum posted...

Neablis posted...

ScareChan posted...

Oh cool so Chris and Corrik literally scum

Town is not Town town is Humans

This is a good catch...i didnt pay attention to that

Which is why it isnt a good catch at all. Chris and Corrik could have also not paid attention to that

tries to curry favor with Chris and Corrik and at the same time make his own mistake of not paying attention not be a big deal
---

Like the fun thing about being town is I can see through logical strands very well. I recognize the lie here really easily. My miller reason is way too different from theirs, and I bet town has powerful people on their side like those two so yeah!

No go Scare, <_<
---

Like I get it. Day is half way over, Scare's blood is PUMPING and he is ready to take down the mythical scum Chris. If you are really sure I am scum there's no harm in a little bit of a fake claim. No harm, I'll flip scum no big deal. Ben isn't sure about the plan but Scare hypes him, they feed off their hype and just go FUCK IT.

Yeah this is exactly what happened hah.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Fuck you not changing my claim.

Chris isn't a miller. I kind of suspected it when he said "why" he would be miller with the Satan thing added in. It reeked of no really it makes sense and this is how. He did the same thing in wrestling mafia when lying.

However, the quote above seals it.
---

I have been neutral on you since last night, we have been using you as bait but game has been sludge

I would say Ben is more confident in you being scum right now actually . Still leaning scum but I amgiving you room to wiggle. Show me something to say this is town Chris
---

Corrik posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Fuck you not changing my claim.

Chris isn't a miller. I kind of suspected it when he said "why" he would be miller with the Satan thing added in. It reeked of no really it makes sense and this is how. He did the same thing in wrestling mafia when lying.

However, the quote above seals it.

I was asked.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Corrik posted...

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Fuck you not changing my claim.

Chris isn't a miller. I kind of suspected it when he said "why" he would be miller with the Satan thing added in. It reeked of no really it makes sense and this is how. He did the same thing in wrestling mafia when lying.

However, the quote above seals it.

I was asked.

That changes nothing.
---

Yes, don't let facts get in the way of your opinions. Works so well for you.
---

ScareChan posted...

I have been neutral on you since last night, we have been using you as bait but game has been sludge

I would say Ben is more confident in you being scum right now actually . Still leaning scum but I amgiving you room to wiggle. Show me something to say this is town Chris

I don't trust your barometer on that at all, given past history. I trust... very few people with that, actually. See last game where 5 different town members swore it wasn't town Chris. People just suck.
---

Ugh I hate that I cant be active right now. I've been hinting that I have info against Chris all day since he claimed
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Ugh I hate that I cant be active right now. I've been hinting that I have info against Chris all day since he claimed

]benjamin3740 posted...

Awww man. I guess Chris is Miller!

All day.
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Yes, don't let facts get in the way of your opinions. Works so well for you.

No it doesn't. It means you actively tried to figure out how your flavor could fit as miller and for an explanation for it.

When the truth is, there does not even have to be a flavor reason why you are a miller. Anyone can be a killer just if the host says they are. Yet, you knew for your role you needed a why it fits.

You are not a miller. You might as well just claim your real role. Even if it is just a miller power or something else. Because you are beating a horse on a fakeclaim everyone knows is fake and you alrdy confirmed as such. Remember wrestling mafia a lot of your issue was your kept riding your fake miller claim too long.

DoomTheGyarados posted...

Fuck you not changing my claim.

---

you're dealing with town scare, not scum scare

I can take a step back and reevaluate
---

I cant stop rolling my eyes about scares case on me
---

No, IGCD told me why I was miller <_<. I was just paraphrasing my flavor really briefly when

Ride till I die #rolltide

Anyway Scare we may have more common ground than you might imagine. Sbell, who you said you will switch to, reacted quite badly to your posting earlier which immediately pinged me and then when he was like 'I am not angry' I was like "you seem super anger."
---

Can't believe I got "you mad, bro" 'd. And then got attacked for saying I wasn't mad.

This game has serious shit going on but me literally not being mad about literally nothing is a forefront.

##unvote
##vote:chris

Don't believe 3 miller's for. Second and unlike Corrik I don't think you could be town hiding something else.
---

There is not 3 millers.
---

Corrik posted...

There is not 3 millers.

I feel like insta claiming miller as scum in a monster themed mafia is a horrible idea and scum chris would have accounted for that.

I just dont think its worth lynching day 1 over.
---

masterplum posted...

Corrik posted...

There is not 3 millers.

I feel like insta claiming miller as scum in a monster themed mafia is a horrible idea and scum chris would have accounted for that.

I just dont think its worth lynching day 1 over.

Who said Chris is scum?
---

DoomTheGyarados posted...

benjamin3740 posted...

Ugh I hate that I cant be active right now. I've been hinting that I have info against Chris all day since he claimed

]benjamin3740 posted...

Awww man. I guess Chris is Miller!

All day.

Okay, i'm back. And this. This was clear sarcasm to show that I knew you really werent miller
---

The way you made up a flavor, said you liked your role, the way you reacted to me asking if you were faking, and the way that you are denying I am Miller shows that you are actually trying to sell Miller as your role and not just gambiting. That is why I was okay with coming out with the info now, because you're trying to stand by the fake claim. And it is fake. There's no way you are also Miller in such a small game
---

Like sure maybe Miller has happened before...but not in a game this small. Occam's Razor HEAVILY suggests you're scum. And buddy this is not a gambit. Your fate is sealed, especially after I flip
---

Chris is Town Doctor. Leave him alone.
---

For those who aren't good at mafia. Chris is Town Power who wants to live past day 1 so he claimed Town Miller because it is foolproof to claim as town even if not miller.

Like, why does this even need fucking explained?
---

The smartest thing though if Chris is town would be to claim vanilla. As I said, why would Chris claiming Miller ever fool scum in this pool of players? Much better chance of being convincing to scum by saying you're a vanilla. Saying you are Miller is overkill that scum will never ever believe.

But in this world, scum Chris can claim Miller and use that as an excuse for scum to never kill him. Whereas real scum would kill him. Its a claim that blinds town more than it blinds scum, as I said before
---

benjamin3740 posted...

As I said, why would Chris claiming Miller ever fool scum in this pool of players? Much better chance of being convincing to scum by saying you're a vanilla. Saying you are Miller is overkill that scum will never ever believe.

This is both dumb and wifom.
---

It's a dumb move if Chris is town, I agree. And I've been told to believe Chris always makes the smartest plays.

Chris when you did it did you NOT expect to get counterclaimed?
---

Claiming miller as not miller is completely moronic
---

Also my role mentions having a feud with Dracula and that he is the main enemy of the humans. So Dracula is the strongest scum role i guess
---

Corrik posted...

Sheep is probably scum.

Corrikiyo what happened here?
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Corrik posted...

Sheep is probably scum.

Corrikiyo what happened here?

Sheep is town.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

The smartest thing though if Chris is town would be to claim vanilla. As I said, why would Chris claiming Miller ever fool scum in this pool of players? Much better chance of being convincing to scum by saying you're a vanilla. Saying you are Miller is overkill that scum will never ever believe.

But in this world, scum Chris can claim Miller and use that as an excuse for scum to never kill him. Whereas real scum would kill him. Its a claim that blinds town more than it blinds scum, as I said before

You mean like last game?
---

If their is a cult there is only 1 or 2 scum right now and they will recruit. I'd guess if there was 3 millers, maybe the cult can only recruit actual humans who aren't Miller's. And if so, you guys are giving the game away in your rush to claim millers.
---

Let's just toss in pointless fun meta.

Dracula cult leader.
Alucard or blade innocent scanning cult backup leader.

Can recruit 1 per night.

Serial killer?

10-2-1

Night 1. Mislynch sk hits town. Cult recruits right.

7-3-1

Night 2 mislynch sk hits town cult recruits right.

3-3-1

Yeah it would end too early unless there are people immune to recruitment.

10-2-1 3 immune town and immune sk to recruitment.

If we wanna go with 3 millers that is where I am.
---