Board 8 > A Dance With Dragons Mafia - Topic 12: The Mummer's Farce Is Almost Done

(+) Yeah! (+)

Meow1000 posted...

IfGodCouldDie posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Neablis posted...

Scare why do you believe my claim and want me to go, buddy me by helping explain whatvi mean and then put me in a one of these is scum...

Thats weird way to play as town?

What did you claim anyway

He claimed watcher on Chris d1, you d2 and death instead of Sbell d3.

The crap why watch scum lean Death over obvious town SBell

This is why I have him as one of the other scum.
---

Shaduln posted...

Also was trying to bury you a decent amount iirc.

Red only mentioned me 3 times.
---

Don't even ask me how I just remembered both of those numbers offhand I didn't copy the list.
---

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Also was trying to bury you a decent amount iirc.

Red only mentioned me 3 times.

Then I didn't remember correctly!
---

Meh while i understand that and hindsite is 20/20 I admit was sub optimal but meh

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Also was trying to bury you a decent amount iirc.

Red only mentioned me 3 times.

Then I didn't remember correctly!

MI (and he was town obviously) was a 1, I was a 3, Scare was a 0.

Dowolf and Plum were low-ish or something like that.
---

Something I would like to say while I have it in mind

Blade went out of the way to tell us a story about how he claimed he thought his character jack was a guy in a previous game but it was a girl and that made it obvious he was town that game because he is more careful as scum

Blowing up about pirates dead vote felt very fake to me. I dont know if its because how much I hounded pirate that I knew what his role said anyways but for it to be in blades mind this whole game that dead town had a vote is bullshit. He would absolutely know that modkill wouldn't reward town. So when he saw dowolf clail who he has been shading for days he went full theater because "lol blade doesn't make that mistake"
---

Oh and by the way don't NL ever, even at 4.

Last game was decided by a last-second scum EK and we have no evidence of a scum poison being used. Don't take the risk of a double kill night instantly ending the game/
---

ScareChan posted...

Something I would like to say while I have it in mind

Blade went out of the way to tell us a story about how he claimed he thought his character jack was a guy in a previous game but it was a girl and that made it obvious he was town that game because he is more careful as scum

Blowing up about pirates dead vote felt very fake to me. I dont know if its because how much I hounded pirate that I knew what his role said anyways but for it to be in blades mind this whole game that dead town had a vote is bullshit. He would absolutely know that modkill wouldn't reward town. So when he saw dowolf clail who he has been shading for days he went full theater because "lol blade doesn't make that mistake"

^

This is scum Scare remember this guys.
---

Also I literally brought that up on day 1 when Sheep asked me to self-meta it's amazing that you're using that as another reason to call me scum.

Just how desperate are you to mislynch me
---

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

But yeah Shad you also know as soon as I'm done having fun with this I'm probably not going to bother showing up again until at least after work tomorrow

I think that's fair, dunno why this is an issue?

Just reminding you that you'll have to put some actual work in today

Hey I did yesterday. Just, at the end.

Also, I should look back at that red list I had again. See who is still alive and completely dodged by red.

Oh look Red mentioned Scare literally 0 times.

"lol"

I gave you a game where scum red avoided me as town and left me til endgame already

"Read the game "
---

I am incredibly eager to lynch scum as we haven't done it yet
---

Nah I'm content in making sure you get lynched after I do.

But please, keep it up.
---

ScareChan posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

But yeah Shad you also know as soon as I'm done having fun with this I'm probably not going to bother showing up again until at least after work tomorrow

I think that's fair, dunno why this is an issue?

Just reminding you that you'll have to put some actual work in today

Hey I did yesterday. Just, at the end.

Also, I should look back at that red list I had again. See who is still alive and completely dodged by red.

Oh look Red mentioned Scare literally 0 times.

"lol"

I gave you a game where scum red avoided me as town and left me til endgame already

"Read the game "

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.
---

ScareChan posted...

I am incredibly eager to lynch scum as we haven't done it yet

And we won't until we lynch you tomorrow!
---

Shaduln posted...

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.

IGCD is town's voice of reason we are so ****ed
---

Well ok I technically won't be part of the "we" but yeah.
---

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.

IGCD is town's voice of reason we are so ****ed

Hey if IGCD and you are town, couldn't it maybe be me?
---

But yeah, leaning more towards the Scare is scum side of this Scare/Blade fight.

Comedy option is both are scum.

Double comedy is both are town and we really are so fucked.
---

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.

IGCD is town's voice of reason we are so ****ed

Hey if IGCD and you are town, couldn't it maybe be me?

"Oh"

Also, what's sad is, no one even bothered to ask me the hint I thought I picked up from Plum. No due diligence at all for why I'm not giving him a free town pass anymore. Bad form. I said right away to be wary of him if he claimed vanilla, did anyone even flinch from that either or is everyone just that bad
---

Shaduln posted...

But yeah, leaning more towards the Scare is scum side of this Scare/Blade fight.

Comedy option is both are scum.

Double comedy is both are town and we really are so fucked.

If Scare is town I promise I will torture him with "comedy option" in the future trust me.
---

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.

IGCD is town's voice of reason we are so ****ed

Hey if IGCD and you are town, couldn't it maybe be me?

"Oh"

Also, what's sad is, no one even bothered to ask me the hint I thought I picked up from Plum. No due diligence at all for why I'm not giving him a free town pass anymore. Bad form. I said right away to be wary of him if he claimed vanilla, did anyone even flinch from that either or is everyone just that bad

I was reading while trying to get my daughter to sleep and forgot you said that. Please elaborate.
---

About to sleep but leaning towards siding with blade currently. But ill read and reread tommorow

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.

IGCD is town's voice of reason we are so ****ed

Hey if IGCD and you are town, couldn't it maybe be me?

"Oh"

Also, what's sad is, no one even bothered to ask me the hint I thought I picked up from Plum. No due diligence at all for why I'm not giving him a free town pass anymore. Bad form. I said right away to be wary of him if he claimed vanilla, did anyone even flinch from that either or is everyone just that bad

I was reading while trying to get my daughter to sleep and forgot you said that. Please elaborate.

Plum very late on day 1 made a sudden post of a single word in bold, that I took as a hint. This is the town read I repeatedly refused to specify on.

Pirate

That was the post. A single word.

Go to day 2, and Pirate is under fire. I specifically ask Plum what he thinks of Pirate, and Plum defends Pirate while Pirate is under fire. I was under the impression that Plum was some sort of scanner who had scanned Pirate, and it's part of why I distanced myself from that lynch. I never explained this town read because if Plum ever claimed vanilla I was immediately revoking it, and I didn't want Plum to know that in case he was scum.

Oh gee it took me having to literally ask someone to ask me what a great town.
---

Seriously that question should've been asked and answered over an hour ago.
---

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.

IGCD is town's voice of reason we are so ****ed

Hey if IGCD and you are town, couldn't it maybe be me?

"Oh"

Also, what's sad is, no one even bothered to ask me the hint I thought I picked up from Plum. No due diligence at all for why I'm not giving him a free town pass anymore. Bad form. I said right away to be wary of him if he claimed vanilla, did anyone even flinch from that either or is everyone just that bad

I was reading while trying to get my daughter to sleep and forgot you said that. Please elaborate.

Plum very late on day 1 made a sudden post of a single word in bold, that I took as a hint. This is the town read I repeatedly refused to specify on.

Pirate

That was the post. A single word.

Go to day 2, and Pirate is under fire. I specifically ask Plum what he thinks of Pirate, and Plum defends Pirate while Pirate is under fire. I was under the impression that Plum was some sort of scanner who had scanned Pirate, and it's part of why I distanced myself from that lynch. I never explained this town read because if Plum ever claimed vanilla I was immediately revoking it, and I didn't want Plum to know that in case he was scum.

Oh gee it took me having to literally ask someone to ask me what a great town.

I mean, you also should've just explained it without being all high and mighty, but that's ok.
---

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

Meow1000 posted...

Shaduln posted...

I'm not saying he doesn't ignore town.

I'm saying he does ignore scum mates.

Also why I'm feeling ok with IGCD.

IGCD is town's voice of reason we are so ****ed

Hey if IGCD and you are town, couldn't it maybe be me?

"Oh"

Also, what's sad is, no one even bothered to ask me the hint I thought I picked up from Plum. No due diligence at all for why I'm not giving him a free town pass anymore. Bad form. I said right away to be wary of him if he claimed vanilla, did anyone even flinch from that either or is everyone just that bad

I was reading while trying to get my daughter to sleep and forgot you said that. Please elaborate.

Plum very late on day 1 made a sudden post of a single word in bold, that I took as a hint. This is the town read I repeatedly refused to specify on.

Pirate

That was the post. A single word.

Go to day 2, and Pirate is under fire. I specifically ask Plum what he thinks of Pirate, and Plum defends Pirate while Pirate is under fire. I was under the impression that Plum was some sort of scanner who had scanned Pirate, and it's part of why I distanced myself from that lynch. I never explained this town read because if Plum ever claimed vanilla I was immediately revoking it, and I didn't want Plum to know that in case he was scum.

Oh gee it took me having to literally ask someone to ask me what a great town.

I mean, you also should've just explained it without being all high and mighty, but that's ok.

Yeah I would've if anyone had ever bothered asking me.
---

And aside from Scare immediately using it as more fodder to call me scum did anyone else other than Plum even acknowledge it at all
---

Oh and town Scare asks why before using it as immediate mislynch fodder.
---

Hmmm, I have some thoughts on plum's claim:

Stone Man? After reviewing, it appears the "Stone Men" are a group. According to the wiki:

They are rumoured to have a leader, the Shrouded Lord

Why wouldn't Suprak give the role "Shrouded Lord" instead? I know this is flavor meta, but, this would be like doing Lord of the Rings mafia and giving a role titled "Ent" instead of "Treebeard".

Also, with the dead town chat. This is something that comes from MU, right? I don't see anything on the MU wiki related to Incapacitated as a role used. Again, this doesn't mean Suprak couldn't have thought it up, but it seems weird. And useless.
---

Shaduln posted...

Why wouldn't Suprak give the role "Shrouded Lord" instead? I know this is flavor meta, but, this would be like doing Lord of the Rings mafia and giving a role titled "Ent" instead of "Treebeard".

scum have a safelist.

...Shad, you should know this? Like, I'm not going insane in my old age -- you've played a lot, right?
---

Shaduln posted...

Hmmm, I have some thoughts on plum's claim:

Stone Man? After reviewing, it appears the "Stone Men" are a group. According to the wiki:

They are rumoured to have a leader, the Shrouded Lord

Why wouldn't Suprak give the role "Shrouded Lord" instead? I know this is flavor meta, but, this would be like doing Lord of the Rings mafia and giving a role titled "Ent" instead of "Treebeard".

Also, with the dead town chat. This is something that comes from MU, right? I don't see anything on the MU wiki related to Incapacitated as a role used. Again, this doesn't mean Suprak couldn't have thought it up, but it seems weird. And useless.

My flavor is "Sons of the Harpy" which I am going to assume is some sort of group.
---

they are.

they're literally the KKK.

as in, they're terrorists who took to violence because they can't have slaves anymore.
---

dowolf posted...

they are.

they're literally the KKK.

as in, they're terrorists who took to violence because they can't have slaves anymore.

Welp goodnight everybody
---

dowolf posted...

Shaduln posted...

Why wouldn't Suprak give the role "Shrouded Lord" instead? I know this is flavor meta, but, this would be like doing Lord of the Rings mafia and giving a role titled "Ent" instead of "Treebeard".

scum have a safelist.

...Shad, you should know this? Like, I'm not going insane in my old age -- you've played a lot, right?

Of course they do but that doesn't mean they always use it. But like I said, it was just flavor meta. It's useless but something that was bugging me.

Meow1000 posted...

My flavor is "Sons of the Harpy" which I am going to assume is some sort of group.

...This shows you how much I pay attention to flavor in claims normally.
---

im at a comp now so going to go archiving again
---

Here we witness the scum in the wild trying to corner it's quarry. For days he has stalked and waited for the right moment, desperately seeking another meal. So far his attempts have been unsuccessful, and thus he tries a more direct approach. Time is running out, his energy fades with each passing hour without a meal; he may have only one more attempt left. He has to make it count.
---

Ok I actually am going to sleep now I was just amusing myself going all NatGeo on Scare considering the guy's been trying to lynch me since day 2.
---

Can you stay for a bit more blade
---

reportquote
IfGodCouldDie 9/28/2018 2:58:08 PM#211
benjamin3740 posted...
Obellisk posted...
refresh my memory benj.... mostly i'm trying to get work done and dont have the time to go fish the posts back out.

Chris told IGCD that he thinks he's scum and asked IGCD what he thought about that. IGCD said he didnt care and that he'll figure him out eventually. But then an hour or so later with IGCD still awake he was saying that he's still up because he wants to clear up people's suspicions of him before he goes to bed. Which is a contradiction in thought process

WHOA NELLY

That is a definitely vote worthy post.

##Vote:Ben

That a a gross misrepresentation of the events from last night and now you get to play a game called show your proof.

good igcd post and vote from day 1. Still thinking he is town
---

okay Im fucking stupid

##Unvote
---

Additionally, ben admitted to intentionally posting after when he knew deadline would be. I would like to genuinely thank him for his honesty. Unfortunately, this means he has been modkilled.

so scum knew that Red was going to vote right away

the only other people to post besides Ben and Red was Chris and Blade

If Blade were scum he should have been modkilled for the same reason that Ben was

Blade is 100% town and if he is not then this game doesnt even matter
---

I am not sure what to do today now because I was rule 1ing the fuck out of blade and that played into everything I was thinking
---

this took all my energy for rereading right now

if someone is around I'll chat but otherwise

I dont even know
---

Is this as simple as Scare seeing general consensus against him and deciding not to go after blade?
---

this was scare going back to build his case and remembering that blade posted something at end of day I wanted to look at and realizing that I fucked up my read
---

I asked blade to stick around to talk to him about it but looking at everything together as a package I was just super wrong and blade has to be town
---

as scum I have no reason to give up more info about my role like I did today and I just sit on blade. I dont confirm the best player alive
---

Is blade as is the best player alive? I agree on his game blade is, but current mood blade?

Likely just whatever, but just saying.
---

that would be more reason just to sit on him
---