Board 8 > Sir Chris' Music Mafia Topic 14: Bob Marley Man

(+) Yeah! (+)

ColZach posted...

Someone else also noted that something Han said sounded like a scum victory speech which is where that came from.

Han, buddy, youve been doing better in this leg of the game, please dont throw it away by building and finding every reason to believe Im scum when the evidence is there that Im not.

Look at how far you have to go and the loops you have to jump to have it make sense that Im scum.

Like, explain to me in any reality where, after 2 games, this is the way a Town player acts?

There aren't even any hoops to jump through! Logically, it makes plenty of sense for Zach to be Scum.

I think Zach is smart enough to know that, and his insistence that hes confirmed Town isn't being a noob, it's being lazy.
---

Colzachs reaction the pun claim reminds me of my reaction to Leo being 'scanned' by Mzero.

Anger at the fact that their golden goose Tony (Leo) is getting ratted out by an unexpected twist, and denial of the role that did it.
---

ColZach posted...

Han I dont really feel like you can say you caught tony as scum. Ive noted too he hasnt said shit but Im not waving it around as what Ive done today.

Like... this was what Zach posted when I said Tony was Scum, D1.

Very notable is that Zach didnt say I wasnt right! In fact, he almost implied I was!

With Tony claiming Watcher unchallenged, this really didnt mean a whole lot, but with Tony ACTUALLY flipping Scum, this just reads as a slip!
---

We know last role has a Janitor use.

Unscannable probably takes the place of a Godfather, at least it makes sense to me that it would.

Death wouldn't have hopped on The Plan so readily yesterday, and has seemed Townish all game to me.

FD is lawyer.

Crescent has seemed Town all game, and I dont think she could've fabricated the fight from last night with Tony.

Zach's only defense is that he'd be a jerk to bus Zam.
---

Hmm, your reaction to Puns claim was more honest and surprised-sounding.
And you had a more reasoned opinion on not trusting Puns. But you still chose to trust Tony over Puns there.
Or at least thats what it seems like.
---

htaeD posted...

Hmm, your reaction to Puns claim was more honest and surprised-sounding.
And you had a more reasoned opinion on not trusting Puns. But you still chose to trust Tony over Puns there.
Or at least thats what it seems like.

After I had fully caught up and thought about it, it just made sense that Tony was Scum. My main issue was with the claim that Dumey didnt go anywhere. It sounded at first like puns was claiming something that was odd to make his claim sound more believable.

But yeah, it was explained by Tony being Scum and I never thought puns was Scum before, so I was fine with puns after thinking about it.
---

We'll be needing a new topic soon.
---

I just cant believe tony is scum and if he honestly is, its a pretty foul use of zams ragequit as a tool in-game. Ill concede to scum if thats the route they took because they clearly want to win way more than I do.

hmm

would zach be that dirty?
---

Noted that he inevitably uses it as an excuse not to suspect Tony
---

Han, Im going to very justifiably tell you some choice words once the game is over if you lynch me assuming that I would actually do that egregious shit to Zam.

Who again, actually isnt going to be playing mafia anymore as a result.

At least with death I can assume because hes trying to save his own hide.

But I suppose if it isnt death its han, so...either way, scum is literal scum this game.

The feelings mutual.
I am gonna have some choice words for you if it turns out you are using this as a shield to not get lynched.

Its casting doubts on my certainty, that much I can say.

Enough to again wonder what the hell Tange thinks he is doing.
---

ColZach posted...

Han, Im going to very justifiably tell you some choice words once the game is over if you lynch me assuming that I would actually do that egregious shit to Zam.

Who again, actually isnt going to be playing mafia anymore as a result.

WIFOM

unfortunate WIFOM, but WIFOM nonetheless
---

htaeD posted...

The feelings mutual.
I am gonna have some choice words for you if it turns out you are using this as a shield to not get lynched.

Its casting doubts on my certainty, that much I can say.

Enough to again wonder what the hell Tange thinks he is doing.

Epic STP is epic
---

Not just a ninja, but a sametime ninja.

The holy hell..

Tange, what are your thoughts?
---

Also I really hate how Mzero picked Puns and Tony, the more I think about it.
There was no way both would have been scum.

But whats done is done, hindsight also. Just wanted to type it all out.
---

I honestly think its stupid I still have to actually defend myself as town given day 1. Its clear at this point scum took advantage of Zams weak claim and crack under pressure to make tony look good, but why in the hell (if I was his scummate) ask for that claim?

It just doesnt make any sense. I also didnt hop train onto god, I went along with the x plan (if I understand correctly I actually put myself at risk with the Mzero plan ((again why would scum do this)))

Han just wants to make his 50/50 read this game about a 30/70

Honestly, Im not liking Zach more and more as this day has gone on. Im still not 100% sure hes scum or that Han is town

Im probably leaning

Zach
Han
Death
Crescent
Ben
FD
Me
---

Like Zach

You keep pointing to Day 1 as why youre town

But what have you done OUTSIDE OF THAT which proves youre town?
---

And I dont really give you that many points for day 1 either for what its worth
---

Theres another paragraph in my post, you know

ColZach posted...

Theres another paragraph in my post, you know

Not hopping on igcd doesnt prove much though. Not going along with the x-plan would have just made you look worse (Like tony)
---

See I wont deny you had a good day1.
But you have really fallen off the radar since.
---

Crescent-Moon posted...

Did Ben really just insinuate that I hadn't been calling him very likely scum/pursuing him until the very end of the day yesterday?

It's so obviously, factually wrong I don't even know how to respond to it.

I did not. I said your fight came off as fake to me. But that's just because of the intensity of it seemed overblown
---

htaeD posted...

See I wont deny you had a good day1.
But you have really fallen off the radar since.

If he is scum, did he though?
---

Maybe not.
But I dont see how Zach was at fault for Zams meltdown anyway
---

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/76927103

DoubleTangicide posted...

Order of unconfirmed Id like lynched:

Death
Han
Zach
Crescent

DoubleTangicide posted...

Zach
Han
Death
Crescent
Ben
FD

I guess Zach is making himself look worse today. Why did Han move up above Death?
---