Current Events > ITT: I rate the Assassin's Creed series from best to worst.

(+) Yeah! (+)

NOTE: Only rating ones I played.

Black Flag
Unity
Syndicate
Ezio Collection
III
Brotherhood
China
Russia
India
Liberation
Revelations
Assassin's Creed
---

Wait, Unity is awful
---

The-Apostle posted...

Ezio Collection

The fact that the collection that has two of the best ones isn't at the top says everything.
---

I haven't playd them all but I would probably rate it

II
Rev
IV
III
Bro
Freedom Cry
1
Lib

I know Rev and III being so high is going to be controversial, but once the major glitches were patched, III was fine, boring protag aside.

Meanwhile, Rev was freaking great and as long as you keep an eye on your notoriety you'll never have to do a single base defense after the tutorial. Plus, it was the first AC game to have any resolution whatsoever. Would lose points for the first person stuff but that amounts to like one hour of the game so nbd tbh.
---

Where's Rogue?
---

DevsBro posted...

I haven't playd them all but I would probably rate it

II
Rev
IV
III
Bro
Freedom Cry
1
Lib

I know Rev and III being so high is going to be controversial, but once the major glitches were patched, III was fine, boring protag aside.

Meanwhile, Rev was freaking great and as long as you keep an eye on your notoriety you'll never have to do a single base defense after the tutorial. Plus, it was the first AC game to have any resolution whatsoever. Would lose points for the first person stuff but that amounts to like one hour of the game so nbd tbh.

I hate Revelations because it's clunky and that God-aweful stalker mechanic is so terrible. I'll be focusing on something and BAM stabbed out of nowhere. At least with Chronicles you know he's there. It's why Ezio Collection isn't at the top.
---

Unity lol

The-Apostle posted...

I'll be focusing on something and BAM stabbed out of nowhere.

So you're extremely unobservant and deaf. Not the game's fault.
---

I got 3 & 4 for free woot
---

The-Apostle posted...

Syndicate

I really wanted to like this one but they put training wheels on the free running and it drives me insane.

2 is still my personal favorite, but they're all pretty solid games even though some of the later ones feel soulless.

Rogue deserves more love
---

dave_is_slick posted...

The-Apostle posted...

I'll be focusing on something and BAM stabbed out of nowhere.

So you're extremely unobservant and deaf. Not the game's fault.

Maybe I like letting my character stand there while the bank collects money. You can't generate money while the game is off.
---

Lol, imagine having an opinion like this. Unity is also the broken mess and the black sheep of the family. Also how can you have 'Ezio collection' and have brotherhood and revelation separate?

Exactly what are you counting among Ezio collection? Just the second game?
---

OEIO999 posted...

Lol, imagine having an opinion like this. Unity is also the broken mess and the black sheep of the family. Also how can you have 'Ezio collection' and have brotherhood and revelation separate?

Exactly what are you counting among Ezio collection? Just the second game?

I forgot to add the second one. I played the Ezio Collection as well as the three games individually so that's why they're seperate.

And I felt Unity was awesome so that's why it's so high.

Anyway, I added the second one.
---

A proper list:

AC2
AC3
AC Brotherhood
AC Black flag
AC 1
The rest are irrelevent.
---

The-Apostle posted...

OEIO999 posted...

Lol, imagine having an opinion like this. Unity is also the broken mess and the black sheep of the family. Also how can you have 'Ezio collection' and have brotherhood and revelation separate?

Exactly what are you counting among Ezio collection? Just the second game?

I forgot to add the second one. I played the Ezio Collection as well as the three games individually so that's why they're seperate.

And I felt Unity was awesome so that's why it's so high.

Anyway, I added the second one.

You say you forgot to add the second one, but you still added 'ezio collection' and added the other two, separately, how does that make sense in your head?
---

OEIO999 posted...

The-Apostle posted...

OEIO999 posted...

Lol, imagine having an opinion like this. Unity is also the broken mess and the black sheep of the family. Also how can you have 'Ezio collection' and have brotherhood and revelation separate?

Exactly what are you counting among Ezio collection? Just the second game?

I forgot to add the second one. I played the Ezio Collection as well as the three games individually so that's why they're seperate.

And I felt Unity was awesome so that's why it's so high.

Anyway, I added the second one.

You say you forgot to add the second one, but you still added 'ezio collection' and added the other two, separately, how does that make sense in your head?

Check the edit in OP. I added it seperately.
---

The-Apostle posted...

Maybe I like letting my character stand there while the bank collects money.

Assassin's Den. So hard.
---

Spidey5 posted...

Rogue deserves more love

Forgot I played that one.

You know you've played to much of a series when you start forgetting some of the games you've played.
---