Current Events > Were you turned off in the last jedi by them casting more minorites and women..

Topic List
Page List: 1
Smallville
12/16/17 8:16:58 AM
#1:


.....than most big hollywood blockbusters? Did this turn you off?
---
"I've always wanted there to be nothing between us. Now there's not"----smallville
... Copied to Clipboard!
BigSLM1993
12/16/17 8:18:48 AM
#2:


Their race or gender didn't even make it a relevant part of their character, people would've complained if it did.

So if it didn't impact anything, why does it matter if we had minorities or not? Should we have just made them white?
... Copied to Clipboard!
_Schwarzlicht_
12/16/17 8:18:56 AM
#3:


I was turned off by them casting more dumbass CGI animals
---
I'm a loner, Dottie. A rebel.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Smallville
12/16/17 8:21:35 AM
#4:


BigSLM1993 posted...
Their race or gender didn't even make it a relevant part of their character, people would've complained if it did.

So if it didn't impact anything, why does it matter if we had minorities or not? Should we have just made them white?

exactly, but i read a lot of people screamed "sjw bullshit". And i think this is even worse as it applies to asians than to black people
---
"I've always wanted there to be nothing between us. Now there's not"----smallville
... Copied to Clipboard!
#5
Post #5 was unavailable or deleted.
BigSLM1993
12/16/17 8:26:41 AM
#6:


Smallville posted...
BigSLM1993 posted...
Their race or gender didn't even make it a relevant part of their character, people would've complained if it did.

So if it didn't impact anything, why does it matter if we had minorities or not? Should we have just made them white?

exactly, but i read a lot of people screamed "sjw bullshit". And i think this is even worse as it applies to asians than to black people


Which is what mystifies me about the outrage. Like I'd be on board with people being bugged if Finn was taking knees to protest the anthem or had a "hands up dont shoot moment" or if we had a girls are better than boys moment with Rey, but none of that happened.

Having competent females doesn't make a movie misandrist, if you argue Rey is a mary sue then that's more of a symptom of bad writing. The mere inclusion of other ethnic actors doesn't make a movie "SJW," race doesn't even matter in the Star Wars verse either. But I guess it was also pandering when Lando was Black right?
... Copied to Clipboard!
DifferentialEquation
12/16/17 9:05:40 AM
#7:


BigSLM1993 posted...
Having competent females doesn't make a movie misandrist, if you argue Rey is a mary sue then that's more of a symptom of bad writing.


It doesn't make it misandrist, but they have to make her OP in order to avoid allegations of misogyny.

In TFA, it would have made sense for her to lose to Kylo or have to retreat, but that can't happen because it would have been sexist for to lose to a man.

And I haven't seen TLJ yet, but I would bet that unlike Luke or Anakin in previous trilogies, she doesn't lose a limb or get maimed because there would be backlash about the movie "promoting violence/brutality against women".
---
There's no business to be taxed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
k darkfire
12/16/17 9:09:32 AM
#8:


Yeah it's ridicous they included so many. Finn, Rey and poe should not have existed.
... Copied to Clipboard!
Smallville
12/16/17 9:10:16 AM
#9:


poe is a minority?
---
"I've always wanted there to be nothing between us. Now there's not"----smallville
... Copied to Clipboard!
TheCyborgNinja
12/16/17 9:11:24 AM
#10:


I dont care as long as everything works and I dont feel like Im watching some hippie give a lecture. What bothers me the most about SW is that the Empire loses.
---
"message parlor" ? do you mean the post office ? - SlayerX888
... Copied to Clipboard!
Topic List
Page List: 1