Board 8 > Dota 2 Mafia 2 Topic 7 - Oh my God it's a BLACK HOOOOLE (of host humor)

(+) Yeah! (+)

he said it's jailkeeper

You haven't played miller how you'd expect
You haven't played watcher how you'd expect (why on earth watch me night 2)

I cannot comprehend that we're ignoring every interaction in the game to do setup meta and then setup meta so utterly terrible.

You don't lynch your only claimed protection. You don't lynch your only claimed scanner. Someone has been suggesting both today.

For the record I'm not necessarily saying buy items to use them on me, but you could absolutely fake me out by visiting the shop in daylight. The point is to throw off the number guessing math. You have to be sure I won't just guess the right number.

Fun fact I am saying lynch neither of you due to setup meta

You don't let bad claims live simply because they claim strong roles.

Are you ever come around and tell me why this is so obviously the right answer to you?

1. Ulti has been trying to townconfirm himself all game
2. Corrik hinted Thanos
3. He waffled on Hb
4. He is trying to take credit for a Sultan lynch he put basically no work into

1. My role caught him in a lie, I know for a fact no visitors either night.
2. Crusade to lynch a second miller claim doesn't make sense if he's the third miller-- would have claimed miller sooner to help himself, or have said "maybe 3 millers"
3. Using this claim as a way to avoid interacting with the game.

Red how exactly does your role work.

kirby are you feeling swayed by ctes at all or just waiting to cast the pre-hammer hammer to give mzero a chance to weigh in, etc.

I want to wait for MZero. I feel like knowing his role will help us solve the puzzle of the third party and what exactly they're capable of.

I hammer.

You can't just list some reasons to act like you also didn't claim good roles couldn't exist.

I didn't say that as the core of my argument. This is entirely to help figure out Roshan. You were caught in a lie, Ulti has been being built for days.

To whomever that is either on me now or saying they will be and is town; if I die like this, take a deep breath before joining me in dead town chat.

• If town, Lopen is scum, so...
• Ulti can protect whoever he wants, assuming he's actually town
• I just goof off and do nothing productive
• If scum, Lopen is town, so...
• Ulti protects Lopen to confirm himself
• I do illusion stuff for Lopen to see, confirming myself

• If town, ctes is scum so...
• Ulti just protects whoever he wants
• I goof off and do nothing
• If scum, ctes is town so...
• Ulti and ctes can coordinate to visit the same person
• I can coordinate with ctes to make an illusion
• ... But how are we gonna do that if we won't know who is truthful before the flip happens?

Perhaps Corrik will roast the rest of us for being absolute morons. Perhaps he'll roast you for not bringing up your Miller identity earlier.

Consider why Ctes would watch me night 2

That's really all you need to know he's not watcher

And a third miller wouldn't keep going for the head of the second miller when the first miller had flipped

That's really all you need to know he's not miller

We are not killing Lopen today, and I very much trust you guys to kill him tomorrow if ctes flips town.

Consider why scum ctes would say he watched Lopen night 2 as scum.

1. Doesn't know Lopen is psychic
2. Thinks Lopen thinks highly of himself and will believe the watch choice

The miller case you're making here is also stupid. I was ready to humor two millers but I thought three would be ridiculous. How is that unreasonable. Why should I think there was no lier there because one of them flipped? Why would it have to be only me or all three? That logic is so bad.

You claim miller day 1 and force the standoff in this case imo

Scum ctes
1. Doesn't know Lopen is psychic
2. Thinks Lopen thinks highly of himself and will believe the watch choice

hold the line Kirby! do not fall for scum's temptations!

That literally doesn't answer the question at all. You were questioning attacking the second claimed miller after the first one flipped, which was day 2.

That doesn't answer why he'd think it was the smart claim to make.

Why haven't both of your Tango charges been spent yet?

Night 1 - Used Tango, No visitors
Night 2 - Used Tango, No visitors

There were two miller claims, and you know you're miller. You know one is lying if three can't exist.