Board 8 > Final Fantasy 14 Mafia - Day 3: Answers

(+) Yeah! (+)

Crescent-Moon posted...

I'm actually surprised no one tried to sooner.

Probably because, unlike some of these other clowns, you actually *talk.*

I don't like how isquen pretty much copied Chris's claim

masterplum posted...

I mean I can come up with a convoluted explanation of how isquen is town and chris is scum, but I don't think that is Occulams razor

The "Devil's Advocate" argument would be that Chris is scum claiming his own RB on you, and Isquen is town that coincidentally has a virtually identical power to what Chris claimed.

And it'd have to be coincidence. Even if scum Chris "knew" Isquen was "Ninja".. Ninja is exactly what Isquen described - A role that evades surveillance; not a role that does it.

MZero made a fair point here.

Am I the only one concerned that Isquen's claim looks copy pasted? Maybe we just shouldn't talk about it though

Anyway going to bed

I haven't paid enough attention to anything other than him claiming the same thing Chris did.

But yes, I guess there's a bit of an argument for that?

##unvote

I want more discussion without the risk of someone randomly voting

Good call.

Half the game hasn't chimed in on this claim yet.

According to the ninja there was apparently a third person who targeted plum n1 because if they were the only other person I wouldn't have noticed it.

Also kind of want to kill it just for the stupid flavor meta.

I think plum just kind of has to be town here. Which is annoying because it means I am going to have to put effort into this game.

hello

Actually I will correct. Possible scum has a protection role that saved plum n1 from possible vig. So if a scum protection role flips we can still murder plum. But I don't think any town night killing has been claimed so odds of that are slim.

Also I don't think a scum scare sacrifices himself for a scum plum with bg so that doesn't count.

Let me get to my computer and actually think for once.

Isquen posted...

If I role-blocked you night 1, Mike wouldn'tve been able to aether scan night 2, as he claimed.

I will say this line probably always comes from town in my experience and maybe we should stop trying to setup meta a madman

So I scan Chris town, Chris claims what he claims, then a full 24 hours later or so, Isquen claims literally the exact same thing, down to targeting the person that Chris pointed out got targeted night 1.

Did I read that right or am I still not all here after just waking up?

MikeTavish posted...

So I scan Chris town, Chris claims what he claims, then a full 24 hours later or so, Isquen claims literally the exact same thing, down to targeting the person that Chris pointed out got targeted night 1.

Did I read that right or am I still not all here after just waking up?

They claim I can't see their target

And still almost no one has said what they did night 2...

Isquin did if you think hard

So that means two people visited Plum.

I dunno, something is wrong here, isquen not immediately counterclaiming Chris is concerning, even with the good guy scan on him I don't see how town doesn't twitch at seeing literally the exact same claim.

Granted, isquen seemed to not even realize Chris had scanned so maybe they just straight up weren't reading the game, which is ALSO concerning for other reasons.

Given the choice right now I'd lynch Isquen over Chris for obvious reasons but I'm also happy with the Scare lynch because he very much seems like scum rolling over and dying and his team doesn't want to help him so we can deal with this Day 4 with more night actions to work with.

Chris had claimed*

MikeTavish posted...

So that means two people visited Plum.

I dunno, something is wrong here, isquen not immediately counterclaiming Chris is concerning, even with the good guy scan on him I don't see how town doesn't twitch at seeing literally the exact same claim.

Granted, isquen seemed to not even realize Chris had scanned so maybe they just straight up weren't reading the game, which is ALSO concerning for other reasons.

Given the choice right now I'd lynch Isquen over Chris for obvious reasons but I'm also happy with the Scare lynch because he very much seems like scum rolling over and dying and his team doesn't want to help him so we can deal with this Day 4 with more night actions to work with.

I don't think isquen's claim makes much sense as scum for so many reasons thus 'maybe we should stop setup metaing a madman'

Hello again

Hiya scare

Hi Scare, what do you think about all the claims? Surely you realize after all of this that you coming in and saying nothing but "hello" just makes you look worse?

MikeTavish posted...

Hi Scare, what do you think about all the claims? Surely you realize after all of this that you coming in and saying nothing but "hello" just makes you look worse?

It took two hellos to get people to respond. I mentioned yesterday no one has actually engaged me this proves that point that no one actually cares to read me, they would rather make up their own story based on my role

The last time you said no one was engaging with you you received multiple replies alongside questions you never answered so nah, gonna need a better reason than that.

Also in case it wasn't clear (also weird that no one has brought this up at all and completely dropped the topic), Ulti hasn't said a word since his initial tirade after being lynched.

Don't know if he's leaving us to our own devices and secretly hoping we lose so he can tell us again how bad we are or what but yeah, nada. I'll update if this changes.

Questions along the lines of "Why did you say looks like mass claim" which other people understood exactly why I mentioned it

What's an actual question that needs a reply

What do you think of Chris and Isquen claiming the exact same power?

BTW I raid from 4:30pm to 8pm eastern so I'll be gone for the end of day outside of quick peeks in downtime. Looks like today is all wrapped up anyway.

If Scare is town we deserve to lose because with town like this, who needs scum?

Scare really better be scum at this rate...

MikeTavish posted...

What do you think of Chris and Isquen claiming the exact same power?

If scum knew what was going on already Chris could have got out in front of it and claimed it first looking for more confusion. I'm wary of Chris being alive this long

that said Isquen hasn't really stood out to me. He seems to always come around late and respond to something just enough to seem town, but not actually do anything.

Leafeon13N posted...

Scare really better be scum at this rate...

Someone tried to call me scum for pulling my vote when you asked for more time

to that I say - lol

ScareChan posted...

If scum knew what was going on already Chris could have got out in front of it and claimed it first looking for more confusion. I'm wary of Chris being alive this long

that said Isquen hasn't really stood out to me. He seems to always come around late and respond to something just enough to seem town, but not actually do anything.

So did you miss my inno scan on Chris or are you ignoring that entirely?

MikeTavish posted...

So did you miss my inno scan on Chris or are you ignoring that entirely?

Your scan means less than nothing to me. You're a third party that magically got a scan by killing town, none of that jives

Fair enough. Thank you for actually responding to some things.

##Vote: Mike

May as well have a vote down

Convenient that Ulti never came around to say anything, except for things that were easily bullshitable

nice play Mike

Lol, alrighty.

Again, no activity

Town deserves to lose because it doesn't care to try

Fastbreak posted...

Again, no activity

Town deserves to lose because it doesn't care to try

I mean we have the obvious alternative of chris and tavish are lying but you hardly have put up anything.

I mean, I'm confused because multiple people attempted to engage with you and the return response was often silence.

So I really hope you are just scum.

I was gone all day yesterday
In here today

What haven't I answered?
Why I gave you more time yesterday? Does that deserve a response?

I'm just putting my vote back, nothing's happening

##Vote: Scare

NO MORE POSTING

The final votals.... are they truly upon us?

[5]Scare - Mzero, (Isquen), (Mike), Mike, (Tidus), Isquen, Plum, Tidus
[1]Mike - Scare
[0]Plum - (Isquen)
_______
Scare has been lynched!
He was....Lahabreah MAFIA Possessor

Once per night, you can pick a character from the DEAD PLAYERS LIST to posses the body of. You will now appear as that characters flavor and alignment if Scanned. You will also be able to use the abilities of the person you possessed. These abilities will be avaivle to use on the very same night that you possessed them. Any X-shot abilities that were used will have their uses refilled.

IT IS NOW NIGHT. YOU HAVE UNTIL TOMORROW AT 7PM EST TO PM ME NIGHT ACTIONS.

FOR THOSE WE HAVE LOST
1. [LD1]Shonen - Haurchefant, TOWN Bodygaurd
2. [KN1]Death - Quin69, TOWN Vanilla
3.[LD2]Ulti - The Warrior of Light, TOWN Bulletproof
4. [KN2]Banana - Alphinaud and Alisaie, TOWN Twins
5. [LD3]Scare - Lahabrea, MAFIA Possessor

FOR THOSE WE CAN YET SAVE
1.Red
2.Sir Chris
3.Crescent
4.Mzero
5.Isquen
6.Tidus
7.MikeTavish
8.Plum

https://gamefaqs.gamespot.com/boards/8-gamefaqs-contests/79888832