Board 8 > Percussion Mafia Topic 11

(+) Yeah! (+)

Panthera posted...

Needed to not literally claim SK and try to pass it off as being framed when you blew everyone up half an hour later at a time when everyone pretty much knew if your bomb SK thing was right, it's because it was you <_< Was FUN though, not gonna lie

Zero chance I was gonna live with Crescents completely wrong analysis and Plums disgust for me as a person. Needed Plum's vote gone. And Crescent to realize her thinking was hella wrong.

---

Let the town down and probably cost them the game. Was looking everything over again not wanting to be a fool with late mentions of redirect possibilities and perhaps a long shot of HB being town, hadn't considered if that was possible and almost had a heart attack when I noticed slightly different wording on my action PMs. Not an excuse fully understand especailly after seeing DYL's role.

---

Man, good job death. So yeah, being the only Vanilla sucked lol.

---

My voting had 100% accuracy and I went 1 for 1 with scum. Probably a career game for me to be honest.

---

Also, the worst thing about this game was I got some old school CE blood in the game and didnt even get to play with them.

---

BallaLeonHall posted...

Let the town down and probably cost them the game. Was looking everything over again not wanting to be a fool with late mentions of redirect possibilities and perhaps a long shot of HB being town, hadn't considered if that was possible and almost had a heart attack when I noticed slightly different wording on my action PMs. Not an excuse fully understand especailly after seeing DYL's role.

You didn't need to claim that day. Panthera was dead as fuck alrdy.

---

Good work bringing up home Death!

This game was wild right from the getgo, I loved it. My only regret is that I didn't meme harder with my power before I died.

(Also can all mafia games have just two topics for day 1? Because holy shit I'm getting too old for that 5-6 topic crap.)

---

Corrik7 posted...

Zero chance I was gonna live with Crescents completely wrong analysis and Plums disgust for me as a person. Needed Plum's vote gone. And Crescent to realize her thinking was hella wrong.

Yeah Crescent wasn't going to take off the tunnel vision on you no matter what probably.

---

Wasn't expecting scum double vote :(

---

I will say that I wasn't shitting on god or his play, I don't mind god in game. I was just asking if everybody else still hated him.

---

I went 1 for 1 but it was with a player who had a 100% voting record on scum so I'd say it was worth it for me and my team Woot woooot!

---

I love how half the immediate reactions to Ben exploding... were his fellow teammates. >_>

Good thing no one noticed that until they were already dead.

---

I'm sorry about my slot.


---

the reason I locked my crosshairs on panthera day 1 was I knew the hyper bomb stuff was going to be a problem for us if it was dealt with later rather than sooner. it was a beautiful marriage of damage control and my "fuck being scum" mindset. I didn't care whether the lynch was panthera or me, but either way it would damn half the team while giving the other half the chance to look squeaky clean

MZero11 posted...

Wasn't expecting scum double vote :(

Blame Chris!

---

I mean, Chris died N2. He gave out something N2. I don't think you guys ever determined who it was, or tried to?

---

We asked if anyone got anything. <_<

---

We assumed it was blocked by Balla.

---

Yeah I seem to recall the discussion being that Scare must have been Chris' target. I think people questioned him not giving it Death when Chris seemed to buy him so much, but Death looked so towny to everyone at that point that no one really doubted him. I doubt anyone ever really though to revisit it after the day where it was discussed

---

Dark Young Link posted...

(Also can all mafia games have just two topics for day 1? Because holy shit I'm getting too old for that 5-6 topic crap.)

It has absolutely been accepted that not putting the town on eternal catch-up is both more fun and more accessible to playing mafia.

---

Panthera posted...

Yeah I seem to recall the discussion being that Scare must have been Chris' target. I think people questioned him not giving it Death when Chris seemed to buy him so much, but Death looked so towny to everyone at that point that no one really doubted him. I doubt anyone ever really though to revisit it after the day where it was discussed

Psst

Scare was the one that questioned it going to scare over death and said it was very strange death didn't claim it lol

I applaud corrik for

• Claiming scum
• Blowing up 3 people
• THEN convincing game to lynch the confirmed town in spite of that

Truly amazing

---

amazing is one word for it

Fastbreak posted...

Scare was the one that questioned it going to scare over death and said it was very strange death didn't claim it lol

My point was more that when it came up, there was enough room to doubt between it going to you or it going to unidentified scum that no one really thought about Death because he seemed like town to everyone, and by the time people were willing to suspect him they'd forgotten about that whole ordeal

But yes, that Scare guy was really something.

---

DamionDL posted...

I will say that I wasn't shitting on god or his play, I don't mind god in game. I was just asking if everybody else still hated him.

@DamionDL I took no offence to the statement and it actually gave me a town read on you with the way people reacted to it and your responses around that. Granted I was already dead so that part doesnt matter lol.

---

DamionDL posted...

Man, good job death. So yeah, being the only Vanilla sucked lol.

Sucked for us too. I feel like a game should not be made up in such a way that scum fears fakeclaiming nilla. But eh... FUN.
---

Fastbreak posted...

Psst

Scare was the one that questioned it going to scare over death and said it was very strange death didn't claim it lol

I applaud corrik for

* Claiming scum
* Blowing up 3 people
* THEN convincing game to lynch the confirmed town in spite of that

Truly amazing

I mean, I knew Corrik was SK, but I figured I could use him to get that mislynch I needed.

Also I will be honest and say I didnt even notice I got the doublevote until halfway during the day. So my reactions to Scare's questioning were genuine at the time.
---

htaeD posted...

I mean, I knew Corrik was SK, but I figured I could use him to get that mislynch I needed.

Also I will be honest and say I didnt even notice I got the doublevote until halfway during the day. So my reactions to Scare's questioning were genuine at the time.

I mean that in itself kind of is also a thing. Town death would check to see if he got it or try to solve where it went I think since it's something you could do without needing a power role

---

corrik going in on my no safe list case tipped me off that he wasn't town but I couldn't do anything with it without outing myself, and I wasn't considering 4th party while alive

---

i feel this game was unique in it was played well by pretty much everyone and was soured by one poor decision by someone who has needed an extended time away from the game anyway. I don't feel like I can point to anyone and say they played poorly

Balla also played night actions like a stud, he just posted a little too late and it happenes

---

Fastbreak posted...

I mean that in itself kind of is also a thing. Town death would check to see if he got it or try to solve where it went I think since it's something you could do without needing a power role

The peril of having a scumboard for info instead of PMs.
I stayed up to see the results of the actions, but the gift came 10 minutes later.

I did talk about it tho, and 'concluded' it was sent to you since Chris expected you to be protected.
---

Really though, I am surprised nobody tried to pressure me for the hell of it. After Ace Attorney Mafia that is.
---

Chris on giving me the DV

yeah
I didnt think too much about it tbh
he said he wanted to be triple voter I was AMUSED

Lol, wishes do come true.
---