Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 6- Jokes on you

(+) Yeah! (+)

MZero11 posted...

But I don't think everyone claimed

Only ones I think didn't, were already claimed or claimed later. (neab claimed before, Sheep claimed after)
---

I think its safe to say scum is a 6 man team btw
---

actually I am still on the fence with igcd

because there was some good looks of him vs reg where he hounded reg

Im going to just dumpster dive agaiin
---

btw ed if you are reading, sorry we missed on you dude. Hope you try and be aggressive again next game. You had some good fire when focus switched to Battle, bring that again next game dude
---

Can someone post all end of day votals please
---

Day 1 votals:
eaed [8] - (Han), Neablis, (IGCD), (ben), (Scare), (Hb), (Sheep), DYL, (Reg), Death, Reg, Sheep, Shad, IGCD, Anonymous
Reg [7] - (IGCD), Han, plum, Terra, Ashe, ben, Hb, Scare
Hb [2] - (Scare), (Reg), eaed, Johnbobb
IGCD [1] - red, (Reg), (ben), (DYL)
Johnbobb [1] - MZero
Sheep [1] - Corrik
Ben [0] - (Reg)
Corrik [0] - (plum), (Scare)
Death [0] - (plum)
MZero [0] - (Scare), (Reg)
Neablis [0] - (Reg), (Scare)
Scare [0] - (Corrik), (eaed)
Terra [0] - (Reg), (Sheep)

Day 2 Votals:
DYL [6] - (Sheep), Neablis, (Ben), (Scare), IGCD, Red, Death, Hb, Ashe
Plum [5] - Shad, (Corrik), Scare, Johnbobb, Ben, Sheep
Sheep [3] - (Hb), Doom, DYL, (Scare), plum
Scare [0] - (plum)
MZero [0] - (plum)
Red [0] - (Scare), (Johnbobb)
Doom [0] - (IGCD)
IGCD [0] - (Doom), (Death)
Shad [0] - (Plum)

Day 3 Votals:
Scept [8] - (Sheep), (Shad), (Scare), (ben), (Corrik), Neablis, ben, Sheep, Hb, IGCD, Doom, Corrik, Johnbobb
Johnbobb [1] - MZero
Corrik [0] - (Scare), (Johnbobb)
Sheep [0] - (Corrik), (Hb), (Doom)
---

Mzero has been so anti-johnbob at least that they probably can't be scum buddies

Neab, SCare, Red, HB, are all totally town to me. Chris too prob. ANd then Sheep just looks like the town mislynch target of day 2, with how Plum and DYL both ended on him. Plus very little was said about him yet he floated in the lead for most of the day

Why is Ashe town? His posts are clearly very calculated, but that reminds me of Pendragon in the last game. Voting Reg was nice, but was he around for deadline anyway?
---

I think we have mostly all said Battle is town but want to point to topic 1, post 303 from Reg

its the post where he says that he agrees Red and I are town, but Battle is talking about in regards to previous game. Reg was pressed later on about if he read last game and said hell no. So I think that this speaks to him half ass reading a townie post and trying to chime in and curry favor.
---

I'm VANILLA. Eiko Takao. A very minor character who even I hardly remember despite playing the game.

Scare it was funny that you said you read me as power, because I was hoping to give off that impression. But nah I'd never knowingly play two games the same (Or would I?). There's so much power flipped that I dont think anyone would believe anything I said now, so yeah I'm just vanilla
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Mzero has been so anti-johnbob at least that they probably can't be scum buddies

Neab, SCare, Red, HB, are all totally town to me. Chris too prob. ANd then Sheep just looks like the town mislynch target of day 2, with how Plum and DYL both ended on him. Plus very little was said about him yet he floated in the lead for most of the day

Why is Ashe town? His posts are clearly very calculated, but that reminds me of Pendragon in the last game. Voting Reg was nice, but was he around for deadline anyway?

hanging the blocker

not as strong when its scum vs scum though

especially if sheep is scum as well and it really was all scum wagons
---

benjamin3740 posted...

I'm VANILLA. Eiko Takao. A very minor character who even I hardly remember despite playing the game.

Scare it was funny that you said you read me as power, because I was hoping to give off that impression. But nah I'd never knowingly play two games the same (Or would I?). There's so much power flipped that I dont think anyone would believe anything I said now, so yeah I'm just vanilla

Well played either way. You sold me, I would have bit on you
---

t1 p308 and 309

sheep responsds to corrik saying he wont claim but wil day 2 if they are both alive

then this

HB providing solid reads so early probably means he's Town. What was he in the last game?

Town clears batte but does so without knowing his alignment last game to compare it to? disjointed information there
---

372 hedging from sheep

The c/p Death bit is throwing me off a bit, Ed. Plus your thoughts on Scare are really, really out there and you're somehow sticking with them? Like, this is so bad you could be Town because scum would realise they're digging themselves a hole and back off.
---

I'll claim too, I guess.

Principal Kobayakawa, TOWN Vanilla. Honestly wouldn't have chosen this character for a town flavor myself, but hey.
---

Bwuh?
Not that I am not grateful. But I had rather have Corrik sacrifice himself to save the doctor than me! I dont even know if there are phantomthieves left.

Reds not around, so I am not sure if he wants me to reveal the scans shad made so far. (allthough one of them was obviously Plum)
---

red13n posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

So, what were Shads scans?

There are two of us alive.

We aren't revealing these today.

Oh I see.
---

To be perfectly honest, I don't have the slightest clue where the last scum are. My biggest current scumreads are God, MZero and Chris but that's only cause just about everyone else has been removed from my PoE. In a normal game they'd all probably be townreads. Also, please don't get complacent. Assuming you do end up lynching me there's likely only one mislynch left and someone said that a massclaim probably wins the game. I really don't think that's the case and there's probably at least one scum who everyone thinks looks like town.
---

I fear there arent any PT left besides the ones on a safelist.

Also I am pretty miffed Garetha couldnt get the replace, but Plum could.
---

(Oh and its pretty weird that I was jokingly thinking to myself that I'd find myself revived this morning before I saw the site. I must be psychic)
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Mzero has been so anti-johnbob at least that they probably can't be scum buddies

Why is Ashe town? His posts are clearly very calculated, but that reminds me of Pendragon in the last game. Voting Reg was nice, but was he around for deadline anyway?

Ashe did also vote for DYL who was the slightly more dangerous role D2, when he would've been fully justified in voting Plum imo. Plus I don't know Ashe but I don't think he'd leave a vote on an under-pressure teammate as the wagon was forming and then not show up later in the day and just allow them to die.
---

benjamin3740 posted...

So uhh....Johnbobb why are you assuming DYL is even asking to be replaced?

Also does anyone here know f DYL has ever replaced before?

Interesting post from the end of Day 2. Johnbobb was using DYL looking for a replace as a reason not to lynch him, but no one couldn have known for sure DYL was replacing out

...unless he posted it on the scum board

Of course, he voted plum instead. Hm
---

MZero11 posted...

Interesting post from the end of Day 2. Johnbobb was using DYL looking for a replace as a reason not to lynch him, but no one couldn have known for sure DYL was replacing out

...unless he posted it on the scum board

Of course, he voted plum instead. Hm

a replace was asked for on the sign up topic.
---

red13n posted...

MZero11 posted...

Interesting post from the end of Day 2. Johnbobb was using DYL looking for a replace as a reason not to lynch him, but no one couldn have known for sure DYL was replacing out

...unless he posted it on the scum board

Of course, he voted plum instead. Hm

a replace was asked for on the sign up topic.

Yeah but that doesn't mean it was DYL

also there were two
---

we assumed the other was garetha
---

We've really drifted from the point here, which is that JB was super convinced that DYL was replacing when it could have been someone else
---

I mean, I said the same thing.
---

Not exactly. You floated it out there as a hypothetical, yes.

htaeD posted...

What if DYL is one of the two who needs to be replaced???

htaeD posted...

If DYL was the replacement, then I feel like this game is not even in our control.

John's stance was much stronger

I'm not lynching DYL. Simple as that. I'm not gonna lynch someone looking for a replace.

---

htaeD posted...

I fear there arent any PT left besides the ones on a safelist.

Also I am pretty miffed Garetha couldnt get the replace, but Plum could.

game would be 100% over with anyone in that slot. I hope the modkill was him doing something dumb and not just an idle modkill.
---

That is a difference I see.
---

I'm pretty excited that I kind of nailed the phantom thief host meta.
---

Johnbobb posted...

guarantee there are at least a few scum on that DYL lynch

DYL [6] - (Sheep), Neablis, (Ben), (Scare), IGCD, Red, Death, Hb, Ashe

Looks pretty clean to me. Two confirmed town, 1 basically confirmed (Neablis)
Ashe and Hb seem town on my reread so far
God I also think is town but he's probably the most suspicious of the group

Johnbobb posted...

well this doesn't feel particularly good

I mean I'm glad we caught scum last night but like, we just sort of lucked into it by making a play I still think was bad. It just sort of feels shitty, though tbh all of last night was just frustrating.

corrik what are you even claiming to have done

This is not a town reaction to lynching scum

Johnbobb posted...

I stand by the fact that lynching someone for being inactive when the host has already said they're looking for a replace is shitty

it was a terrible, unsportsmanlike play that happened to work out in our favor

frustrated scum

##Vote: Johnbobb

Why hasn't this guy been lynched yet
---

Ashe -

Okay, the kids are off to school, so I have some time now (at least until work)

Thoughts so far:

God doesn't like playing as scum, iirc? Someone can correct me if I'm wrong. I'm sure we could learn his alignment if he just gets high though >_>

I don't think ed's post was that scummy. Comes across as someone who doesn't usually try to get pressure on day 1, trying to get pressure on day 1. Not so much a fan of him backtracking on his Red read so fast, though.

Speaking of Red, his breadcrumbing has me leaning town on him. I'd be surprised if we don't have a thief. (Cause, you know. Phantom Thieves)

Reg got a little too defensive over the 'shitposting'. I mean it's day 1, topic 1, page 2. That's pretty much what we expect from start of day 1 isn't it?

Neablis following Han onto Ed... not really sure about. If ed's scum, though, I'd feel a little better about him.

This Day 1 post really looks good in hindsight. Defends eaed and shades Reg. Plus he was instrumental in lynching DYL. Like him as Town

Sheep - has town cleared way to many players. I think scum like to keep their options open, but Sheep has been town hunting and, as seen in his post on this page, has limited his options to push for a lynch. I think he's probably town too

Hb - had an argument with Reg in topic one. Reg also hopped on him after Scare did. Hard to see him as scum with Reg

With death and red confirmed and Neablis with the uncountered Reg kill, that leaves

2. benjamin3740
10. IfGodCouldDie
11. Johnbobb
17. ScareChan
20. DoomTheGyarados (replaced Terra-enforcer)

From this group I have liked Scare's contribution, and he seems more active and engaged than Scum Scare, although I feel like he's upped his scum game recently and I was fooled a few games ago. Anyway, I think he's probably town.

God I have also generally liked as Town, but I can't put a concrete reason to it. Will have to read back

I'm going to ISO all five and see what I find, but I think the most likely scum are John, ben, and Chris
---

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Jeez the day just started and we're already 100 posts in. Y'all aren't playing huh.

Trying to watch CapCup finals so I'll be in and out. But so far seems to be the same three or four faces making all the posts right now.

Terra's first post- not damning, but I dont like the verbiage with the complaint about activity and then double excuse for activity.

Terra-enforcer posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

I thought people would be a least a little more wary of "X OF CONFIRMED TOWN" after last time

I mean it's bound to happen where you play a game where you're completely right then another where your "confirmed town list" is very wrong. Nature of the game, and it's not like last game was the first game for most of us. But this right now is just a case of Scare being Scare, though I'm inclined to believe he's town because of it.

Then this post which is... fluff defense of book of confirmed town? Or explanation for failure? Then just kinda handwave for Scare and puts a loose Townread on him.

Before I made my posts on Reg and Eaed, I felt more confident on Terra, so I think my gut is more convinced than my brain. But my gut is usually right so *shrug*

Hangut didn't like Terra, who is now Chris. I've learned to listen to Hangut over the years, plus Terra did not look great
---

Actually Ben was instrumental in starting the DYL train, so that looks good for him

However, he did jump off last minute... on to plum, who was also scum but the weaker role
---

MZero11 posted...

HanOfTheNekos posted...

Terra-enforcer posted...

Jeez the day just started and we're already 100 posts in. Y'all aren't playing huh.

Trying to watch CapCup finals so I'll be in and out. But so far seems to be the same three or four faces making all the posts right now.

Terra's first post- not damning, but I dont like the verbiage with the complaint about activity and then double excuse for activity.

Terra-enforcer posted...

Hbthebattle posted...

I thought people would be a least a little more wary of "X OF CONFIRMED TOWN" after last time

I mean it's bound to happen where you play a game where you're completely right then another where your "confirmed town list" is very wrong. Nature of the game, and it's not like last game was the first game for most of us. But this right now is just a case of Scare being Scare, though I'm inclined to believe he's town because of it.

Then this post which is... fluff defense of book of confirmed town? Or explanation for failure? Then just kinda handwave for Scare and puts a loose Townread on him.

Before I made my posts on Reg and Eaed, I felt more confident on Terra, so I think my gut is more convinced than my brain. But my gut is usually right so *shrug*

Hangut didn't like Terra, who is now Chris. I've learned to listen to Hangut over the years, plus Terra did not look great

Chris also came into day 2 stating he should be considered confirmed town because of where Terra ended, the one of problems I have with that is that Terra doesn't care and will bus without hesitation.
---

Votals, as of #335
Sheep [2] - Chris, Hb
Johnbobb [1] - MZero

With 12 players alive, it takes 7 votes to lynch. Day ends at 10:00 PM on Friday, December 28th, thirty-seven hours from now.
---

seriously mzero what is your issue with me

do you plan on actually playing the game at any point? literally your only contribution in 4 days is to blindly call me scum.

do you have reads on anyone else? have you read anything that happened in the game? or are you scum just looking to lazily slide by while pretending to contribute
---

MZero11 posted...

Bad news: I was supposed to visit my family for Christmas but forgot my passport and missed my flight.

Bad news for scum cause I'm off work for 2 weeks with basically no plans *cracks knuckles*

---

Johnbobb posted...

seriously mzero what is your issue with me

do you plan on actually playing the game at any point? literally your only contribution in 4 days is to blindly call me scum.

do you have reads on anyone else? have you read anything that happened in the game? or are you scum just looking to lazily slide by while pretending to contribute

did you actually read my posts

I didn't "blindly" call you scum, first of all. I gave plenty of justification for my read
and I also just gave my reads on most of the game
---

looking at who's left

Player List (12)
1. Ashethan
2. benjamin3740
8. Hbthebattle
9. htaeD
10. IfGodCouldDie
11. Johnbobb
13. MZero11
14. Neablis
15. red13n
17. ScareChan
19. Sheep007
20. DoomTheGyarados

removing myselfbecause it's me
red and death are confirmed town
scare is pretty safely town too. that leaves
Ashe I honestly haven't noticed much from all game, but he did end the day on scum like every time, so he's either town or a major busser. I'd lean town.

2. benjamin3740
8. Hbthebattle
10. IfGodCouldDie
13. MZero11
14. Neablis
19. Sheep007
20. DoomTheGyarados

while I'm a little suspicious of a town Chris living this long, that's not exactly proof. I'm a little hesitant of him saying D2 that everyone who was on Reg's lunch was town. he would know everyone would listen to him and we know now it wasn't true

Sheep I'd say is outright scum at this point. my only hesitation is that it would mean we had s three way sum lynch n2 which I've never seen happened, but given how this game is going, it's not the craziest idea

mzero is either lazy unhelpful town or lazy scum but whateverit is it's annoying

leaning town on Ben and hb at this point. igcd i really haven't noticed much from; i feel like he flies under the radar a decent bit

so assuming 3 scum left, if i had to guess it'd be like

mzero
sheep
god or neab

with Chris over in a weird area on his own
---

I actually never cleared plum from my poe and neab is vig. Other than that gj
---

I do like how the poe' d people are scratching and clawing looking at me. Dance puppets dance.
---

So Red. Mzero or johnbobb?
---

If Sheep is town then Chris is scum for being on him two days and not Townclearing him. -.-
---

why is Scare town again?

I kept being weirded out by him day3, especially with that whole 'oh why dont you just scan sheep?' thing
---

The theory is that if Scare had intentionally tried to save Reg after scum had already cast the anonymous vote it would be against the rules. Something similar has happened in a past game and resulted in modkill

Personally, I just think he has been a lot more involved and present than typical scum Scare
---

Both of those, yes
---

I just dont think jbob is actually reading the game at this point.

He ended day 1 on HB, day 2 on Plum. Let's pounce him

##Vote: Johnbob

Also lol at Mzero ending on Johnbob like every day. I really think we need to aim for one of these two.
---

Sheep007 posted...

To be perfectly honest, I don't have the slightest clue where the last scum are. My biggest current scumreads are God, MZero and Chris but that's only cause just about everyone else has been removed from my PoE. In a normal game they'd all probably be townreads. Also, please don't get complacent. Assuming you do end up lynching me there's likely only one mislynch left and someone said that a massclaim probably wins the game. I really don't think that's the case and there's probably at least one scum who everyone thinks looks like town.

Johnbobb isn't in your PoE?
---