Board 8 > Persona 5 Mafia Topic 4 - Mementos: Path of Qimranut

(+) Yeah! (+)

For once in a game I'd love it if I didn't fucking second guess myself.

Not sure if I agree with Chris' assessment that everyone on Reg was town, though I'm not interested in voting for anyone who lynched scum's GF. That anom vote on eaed at the end makes everyone(myself included) look bad, but I'm also wary of the people on splinter lynches.

Excluding eaed obviously, that's John, red, MZero, and Corrik.

Hb [2] - (Scare), (Reg), eaed, Johnbobb
IGCD [1] - red, (Reg), (ben), (DYL)
Johnbobb [1] - MZero
Sheep [1] - Corrik

Some people are talking about SK, I'm not sure why considering there were only two deaths and ben claimed vig(And I don't see anyone accusing him of being that).

I agree with the sentiment of lynching someone on the eaed lynch, knowing that I'm included in those list of suspects. It's just the smart play.

Rereading the eaed voters later tonight. Day two should be far clearer.

That said...

##Vote: Sheep

His vote near the end sealed it for me. I had a bad feeling about him but my dumbass was like "Oh, it's day 1. You're only kind of sure he's scum, maybe blah blah blah".

Reg posted...

Sheep007 posted...

Well then, never mind...

##Unvote
##Vote: Ed

of course you'd wait until four minutes before deadline to help with it

cmon dude

This is a Scum/Scum interaction. Change my mind.
---

htaeD posted...

sidenote: johnbobb and shad are also soft-to-hard-defending reg a lot during the 2nd half of day2

Less defending more asking why he was considered scummy and couldn't get an answer, but I won't deny that.
---

Dark Young Link posted...

Reg posted...

Sheep007 posted...

Well then, never mind...

##Unvote
##Vote: Ed

of course you'd wait until four minutes before deadline to help with it

cmon dude

This is a Scum/Scum interaction. Change my mind.

You really think Reg called out his scummate like that?
---

Shaduln posted...

Dark Young Link posted...

Reg posted...

Sheep007 posted...

Well then, never mind...

##Unvote
##Vote: Ed

of course you'd wait until four minutes before deadline to help with it

cmon dude

This is a Scum/Scum interaction. Change my mind.

You really think Reg called out his scummate like that?

Reg seemed pretty desperate as the day started coming to a close. The whole "Let's special Terra!" bit, for example(Though red softballed the suggestion to him). To be honest I wouldn't put it past him to make a mistake like that so close to the wire.
---

Red suggested "Hey, lets special Terra" and it was at that point Reg decided to go for it.

Sheep followed.

Sheep007 posted...

Apparently the Ed wagon isn't taking off. I'll risk a Terra special. Fairly confident that Reg is town so a neutral-to-scummy player is a decent vote. Plus I feel like I've played with him enough to at least get some town vibes if he is town, although it's been a while and he's not posted a ton.

##Unvote
##Vote: Terra

---

Dark Young Link posted...

Red suggested "Hey, lets special Terra" and it was at that point Reg decided to go for it.

Sheep followed.

Sheep007 posted...

Apparently the Ed wagon isn't taking off. I'll risk a Terra special. Fairly confident that Reg is town so a neutral-to-scummy player is a decent vote. Plus I feel like I've played with him enough to at least get some town vibes if he is town, although it's been a while and he's not posted a ton.

##Unvote
##Vote: Terra

The argument against this is that it never really took off. Its a special that scum could have piled on if they wanted to(Its board 8, town will put something in tie range). Instead it seemed we piled back onto ed.
---

red13n posted...

Dark Young Link posted...

Red suggested "Hey, lets special Terra" and it was at that point Reg decided to go for it.

Sheep followed.

Sheep007 posted...

Apparently the Ed wagon isn't taking off. I'll risk a Terra special. Fairly confident that Reg is town so a neutral-to-scummy player is a decent vote. Plus I feel like I've played with him enough to at least get some town vibes if he is town, although it's been a while and he's not posted a ton.

##Unvote
##Vote: Terra

The argument against this is that it never really took off. Its a special that scum could have piled on if they wanted to(Its board 8, town will put something in tie range). Instead it seemed we piled back onto ed.

We?
---

we as in a collective, chris.
---

insinuating that i ever perspective slip is bush league.
---

red is french now obviously
---

Trolololo
---

Mais pourquois
---

this was smashing

goodnight for now
---

I wish people would stop acting like they are paying attention to the game with saying things like two vigs are claimed or Ben is claimed vig or so on.

Neab is vig.

Ben was faking and is unclaimed.

Jesus.

Ashethan made a huge massive post and it was pointless because he showed he doesn't know shit about the game regarding the vigs so why do I give a shit about anything else he said. Just makes me think you people are scum, that Ben is town, and you all auto believed his bluff and are trying to act like you are paying attention.
---

Corrik, can you give us a list of people you think are scum and why?
---

Hbthebattle posted...

Corrik, can you give us a list of people you think are scum and why?

Nah. Sheep and plum are claiming.

Chris
Red
Scare
Neab

Are likely town.
---

I have one order of business I need to get to. And I'm just going to come out and say it because I have no fear.

I need everyone in the game to answer this question. I don't want your flavor, I don't want your role, I don't want a hint of either in fact. I just want an honest answer to the question.

Are you a member of the Phantom Thieves?

For those dumb and flavor ingorant that is Joker, Morgana, Ryuji Sakamoto, Ann Takamaki, Yusuke Kitagawa, Makoto Niijima, Futaba Sakura, Haru Okumura

And because it was fun, yes I am in fact Morgana. Yes, Morgana is a cat(NOT A CAT) and obviously my favorite character in P5, so I decided to have fun with it(My role is, well, a mystery. And it will remain as such. Hence why I am comfortable asking this).

And yes, this puts a little bit of a target on our backs. I'm aware. I'm also telling you right now the benefits outweigh the risks.

I just want a Yes or No. Do not elaborate. Do not question other peoples flavor. The less discussion the better.
---

Corrik posted...

I wish people would stop acting like they are paying attention to the game with saying things like two vigs are claimed or Ben is claimed vig or so on.

Neab is vig.

Ben was faking and is unclaimed.

Jesus.

Ashethan made a huge massive post and it was pointless because he showed he doesn't know shit about the game regarding the vigs so why do I give a shit about anything else he said. Just makes me think you people are scum, that Ben is town, and you all auto believed his bluff and are trying to act like you are paying attention.

This post, I like this post

Clearly scum shot their own guy, double claimed, and has mindfucked us all into victory.
---

Corrik posted...

Chris
Red
Scare
Neab

Are likely town.

town is in good hands if this is the case
---

red13n posted...

Clearly scum shot their own guy, double claimed, and has mindfucked us all into victory.

I like it

and as stubborn as I have been I dont think that flavor post by Red is something that he does as scum

##Unvote
---

Dark Young Link posted...

Some people are talking about SK, I'm not sure why considering there were only two deaths and ben claimed vig(And I don't see anyone accusing him of being that).

The SK conversation started because of Ben's claim and he is the only one being accused of being an SK >_>

Also he retracted that claim anyway after Neablis claimed the shot
---

With Akechi flipped Godfather we can pretty safely assume we have another game without an SK.
---

I agree that red doesn't make that post as scum but I don't think I agree with his request.
---

the request is advantageous to us, I assure you.
---

red13n posted...

I have one order of business I need to get to. And I'm just going to come out and say it because I have no fear.

I need everyone in the game to answer this question. I don't want your flavor, I don't want your role, I don't want a hint of either in fact. I just want an honest answer to the question.

Are you a member of the Phantom Thieves?

For those dumb and flavor ingorant that is Joker, Morgana, Ryuji Sakamoto, Ann Takamaki, Yusuke Kitagawa, Makoto Niijima, Futaba Sakura, Haru Okumura

And because it was fun, yes I am in fact Morgana. Yes, Morgana is a cat(NOT A CAT) and obviously my favorite character in P5, so I decided to have fun with it(My role is, well, a mystery. And it will remain as such. Hence why I am comfortable asking this).

And yes, this puts a little bit of a target on our backs. I'm aware. I'm also telling you right now the benefits outweigh the risks.

I just want a Yes or No. Do not elaborate. Do not question other peoples flavor. The less discussion the better.

No
---

red13n posted...

I have one order of business I need to get to. And I'm just going to come out and say it because I have no fear.

I need everyone in the game to answer this question. I don't want your flavor, I don't want your role, I don't want a hint of either in fact. I just want an honest answer to the question.

Are you a member of the Phantom Thieves?

For those dumb and flavor ingorant that is Joker, Morgana, Ryuji Sakamoto, Ann Takamaki, Yusuke Kitagawa, Makoto Niijima, Futaba Sakura, Haru Okumura

And because it was fun, yes I am in fact Morgana. Yes, Morgana is a cat(NOT A CAT) and obviously my favorite character in P5, so I decided to have fun with it(My role is, well, a mystery. And it will remain as such. Hence why I am comfortable asking this).

And yes, this puts a little bit of a target on our backs. I'm aware. I'm also telling you right now the benefits outweigh the risks.

I just want a Yes or No. Do not elaborate. Do not question other peoples flavor. The less discussion the better.

No. For the record, I'm not a Confidant either.
---

That was me answering. I agree with red
---

I am not a Phantom Thief
---

Not a Phantom Thief
---

Alright since it's probably obvious yes I am.
---

I am a Phantom Thief, not.
---

"No"
---

why is the game stuck

why is no one posting
---

People want an easy answer on a day it isn't going to happen. Also we have a good chunk of mostly day 1 inactives that are still inactive.
---

Because people won't put their votes on people that have to claim today.
---

##Vote: Sheep

Claim
---

I will continue to offer plum as the easy answer.
---

Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

Corrik makes good posts then does stupid things like calling Chris town. Corrik has no f***ing idea if Chris is town. Nobody does. He is Chris and has played 24 hours.

I'm not sure if that makes him more or less likely to be scum
---

I can't tell if Plum is scum or if our playstyles are just completely incompatible
---

masterplum posted...

Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

sorry you are just going to have to trust me on this one.
---

masterplum posted...

Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

Corrik makes good posts then does stupid things like calling Chris town. Corrik has no f***ing idea if Chris is town. Nobody does. He is Chris and has played 24 hours.

I'm not sure if that makes him more or less likely to be scum

Lol
---

masterplum posted...

Not a phantom thief, but I hate this line of questioning. I would have argued against it before people started answering the question.

Corrik makes good posts then does stupid things like calling Chris town. Corrik has no f***ing idea if Chris is town. Nobody does. He is Chris and has played 24 hours.

I'm not sure if that makes him more or less likely to be scum

I am wondering if plum thinks Chris's spot just magically appeared into the game day 2.
---

Sheep - "Neab is a better vote than HB or Reg imo but I'm not particularly feeling a lynch on him and the fact I've already said I lean town on him would make a pressure vote redundant."

Death - "....so how is it a better vote in any way?"

Sheep: "Because I think Neab is more likely to be scum than HB or Reg."

Sheep, you say you were leaning town and not particularly feeling a lynch on Neab, yet you felt the need to say he was the most scummy as if he was the only option for you for the day. Of course you ended on Eaed, so why drop him from your list during this phase? Sounds like you just really needed to give a reason to vote Neab, and didnt even account for Eaed
---

Oh well at least you never did actually vote for Neab. What was up with the brief Terra stint? You went OFF of Ed to Terra and back to Ed again
---

Dark Young Link posted...

That said...

##Vote: Sheep

His vote near the end sealed it for me. I had a bad feeling about him but my dumbass was like "Oh, it's day 1. You're only kind of sure he's scum, maybe blah blah blah".

WHy would the fact that it's "only day 1" make you feel less convinced of a scum read? That sounds much more like a fake excuse you're giving now than a natural thought you went through.
---

Thinking shad is town now

Too lazy to unvote on mobile
---

benjamin3740 posted...

Dark Young Link posted...

That said...

##Vote: Sheep

His vote near the end sealed it for me. I had a bad feeling about him but my dumbass was like "Oh, it's day 1. You're only kind of sure he's scum, maybe blah blah blah".

WHy would the fact that it's "only day 1" make you feel less convinced of a scum read? That sounds much more like a fake excuse you're giving now than a natural thought you went through.

That entire post feels forced and fake tbh
---

Before I read through day 1, rip eaed. I would have defended you to the death, in my brief glances at the topic I was sure you were town.
---

If you didn't read day 1, how do you have me as town, Chris?
---