Current Events > Two transgender athletes place 1st and 2nd in Connecticut girls state champ

(+) Yeah! (+)

Darklit_Minuet posted...

Doesn't matter, sports suck either way.

But if you're gonna have em, be inclusive

Your argument played out to it's logical conclusion is literally the worst possible outcome for everyone but men, all in your desperate attempt to mental gymnast your argument into logical consistency.

Total inclusiveness would mean:

Women have no chance in any sport against men after puberty.
MtF would have almost no chance if they're on hormone therapy of any kind.
FtM would have no chance.
Men would continue doing what they do, except we would also get rid of weight classes in combative sports because why not.
Your argument is still technically sound.

Maybe if you don't care about sports you should shut up and leave it to people with some vested interest. You're the equivalent of 60 year old Senators trying to regulate video games.
---

Zero_Slash posted...

ImTheMacheteGuy posted...

Good for them :)

EliteLevel posted...

Girls breaking records in girls races. Fair, next.

Nope. Not even close to fair. They shouldn't be allowed to compete. They are biologically male, giving them an unfair physical advantage.

Damn_Underscore posted...

It seems like the "social justice" way, but it's unfair to every biological female.

This.

This

Should college scholarships for female athletes include men?
---

Pogo_Marimo posted...

Darklit_Minuet posted...

Doesn't matter, sports suck either way.

But if you're gonna have em, be inclusive

Your argument played out to it's logical conclusion is literally the worst possible outcome for everyone but men, all in your desperate attempt to mental gymnast your argument into logical consistency.

Total inclusiveness would mean:

Women have no chance in any sport against men after puberty.
MtF would have almost no chance if they're on hormone therapy of any kind.
FtM would have no chance.
Men would continue doing what they do, except we would also get rid of weight classes in combative sports because why not.
Your argument is still technically sound.

Maybe if you don't care about sports you should shut up and leave it to people with some vested interest. You're the equivalent of 60 year old Senators trying to regulate video games.

Seriously, I don't understand this logic where the obvious conclusion is the end of women's sports.

Only Gymnastics stands a chance since the sports are more specialized (Men's gymnastics emphasizes upper body strength more), but since the American women are destroying their competition with more muscular and less fat bodies, men would eventually take that sport over too.
---

Is this comparable to allowing boxers to compete at a lower weight class? Why or why not?
---

Yearwood hasn't started transitioning at all. He hasn't started hormone therapy. He still has a penis. He only identifies as girl. This is a man competing against women. It's time to stop this make believe nonsense.
---

Will the WNBA become the WTNBA?
---

GreatEvilEmpire posted...

Yearwood hasn't started transitioning at all. He hasn't started hormone therapy. He still has a penis. He only identifies as girl. This is a man competing against women. It's time to stop this make believe nonsense.

And testicles

Just watch the video here: http://www.courant.com/sports/high-schools/hc-hs-cromwell-track-andraya-yearwood-0407-20170406-story.html

Look at them quads and biceps, this is a straight scam.
---