LogFAQs > #979269826

More than ever I believe in my original interpretation that everyone involved was town

MZero posted...

I think Peaf thought that by saving Kirby, one of two things would happen. If Kirby died first, Peaf looks good. If he died first, Kirby would get sussed. Kirby almost died yesterday so this almost worked

I think the reason he felt comfortable doing this is that everyone in the final group was town, so saving Kirby for some town cred didn't matter because another town would just die anyway. Thus, I think the remaining scum can be found in the players who were comfortably matched up, who wouldn't even be pressured into breaking up and have to worry about suspicion if they refused

Chris - death was not around
Ulti - red probably wasn't around and wouldn't have broke things off anyway
Sultan/MZero - I was snoozing. For fairness I will include myself as well
Corrik/Isquen - partnered up just before the mayhem. Corrik is claimed deputy so he can be taken out

If Kirby is town, I think scum is in Chris/Ulti/Sultan/Isquen. I've explained why I don't think it's Ulti or Isquen, but they are technically still in play.

Chris and Corrik have since flipped town, so that leaves Ulti/Sultan/Isquen/Me

Lea, Lopen, and Kirby have also all flipped town, leaving FD/JC/Dumey from the D1 mayhem

Now that we know Peaf wasn't trying to save Kirby because they were scum together, I think my theory makes even more sense