LogFAQs > #973349020

Doom_Art posted...

I see a lot more people saying those who like it are dumb than people shitting on people who dislike it.

Guess I'm not looking in the right places. At least most people who don't like don't accuse those who do of having horrible political views and other lazy arguments though I'm sure there's some who do. I see more accusations from certain fans than anything.

Punished_Blinx posted...

Thing is 'Exiled Luke' was already a thing in TFA and that was directly lifted from Lucas. Doesn't seem like that was ever happening in any of the movies. Of course the reasons could be different for each people but at the very least he was going to be used like another Obi-Wan or Yoda.

I don't think it's a negative to want something like that. They clearly wanted to go back to the feel of the OT and a successful Jedi school wasn't going to fit with that.

It's been a while since I've seen it, but I thought Luke was in "exile", but it was more that he was looking for something than being a recluse due to failure. And they shouldn't have just rehashed the OT in every way like that.