LogFAQs > #972734926

X isnt really Star Wars has always been a terrible take since its a broad setting that can do a lot of different stories. Regardless it doesnt apply to Andor, which is obviously a thematic followup to parts of A New Hope and more obviously Rogue One.

As for the rest of it its all reviewed well and gotten good audience metrics except for The Rise of Skywalker and even that made a billion dollars. Its fair to say that the Disney-era stuff has gone down well despite some of it being divisive online. Of course with that said in audience terms the prequels also got pretty good scores and box office, though not on a level with most of the stuff under Disney.

The thing about the health of Star Wars is, for both the prequels and the sequels, you have to just ignore the internet entirely. There is no franchise I can think of where the online fandom is as divorced from the general audience as this and thats been true for a long time.

Its irrelevant on Lucas though, because whatever you felt about the prequels, after that he went on to be showrunner on The Clone Wars which has some of the best Star Wars content ever. Its the best stuff Lucas was involved with since 1980 for sure.