LogFAQs > #972010501

SirChris posted...

Anyway I am tired, but one last thing.

I think the criteria for reading into people that Ulti and now Sultan is employing is deeply flawed. i won't speak for Han's original vote but having problems with lists or surface level things like people not developing strong reads early isn't beneficial for town. There's a big difference between "I don't like someone did this" and "I can see the scum motivation behind it."

To vote JC I would need someone to lay it out for me why scum JC goes after death on a gut read when death is a really good player. Why would scum JC pick a fight with death there? What's the motivation? How does scum JC benefit from doing that with a weak reason? What does it accomplish for him? Why not sheep me? Why not attack a weaker player?

Sultan and han can you both answer these questions.

Edumey - I saw you say I started a train to get a claim out of sheep. To my recollection I never asked for a claim. Slight mischaracterization don't you think?