LogFAQs > #972007149

EDumey posted...

The easy one, Sheep's claim. What did you think of Sheep before claim? What did you think of Sheep's claim? Do you think anyone's reactions to Sheep's claim positive or negative stood out?

I still think Sheep seems town from the whole thing. It was wholly unnecessary to draw that much attention to himself and I can't think of a way it benefits scum. I think Sheep is town and was just trying to get some conversation going as it was still pretty early in the day. I don't think scum is particularly antsy to get the ball rolling usually. Scum certainly make boneheaded plays, so he's not town cleared by any means, but I don't have any reason to suspect him for it. I don't see the scum motive.

EDumey posted...

More recent, JC. Han, Ulti, and Sultan all called out JC's list post as being bad, for maybe differing reasons. Do you think there's merit to them calling out JC's list, or was it an okay post?

I think Han made a valid point about it sounding like JC was trying to comment on everyone, but it felt pretty authentic to me. He wasn't afraid to say he didn't have a read yet or that all he had was gut. He didn't say much about Han himself either, relevant to this game at least. I didn't feel like he was forcing anything, so I'm fine with the list. The list = scum argument is bad, though. You have to actually analyze the contents.

EDumey posted...

A harder one, thoughts on SirChris. He led a train on Sheep to get a claim out of him, and posted his thoughts on the results in post 2.043, then tried to start something on Ulti, but got no one to bite and said it was bait. Do you think this is a Town Chris trying to solve the game?

So far so good on Chris. He's poking around to see where things go and stimulating the game in a pro-town way as far as I can tell. I don't really remember a scum Chris game though, not sure I've ever seen it.